[Pundit Shiv Narayan’s Reply]
Early Writings
Respected Mirza Sahib!
I have received your kind letter as well as the essay attached to it. Sadly, I cannot agree with what you have stated regarding the definition of revelation and its need. I write herewith the reasons for my disagreement:
Firstly: Putting aside the issue of whether or not your argument (which you refer to as propter quid) can prove that there can be a cause for revelation, which you claim is an effect is a blatant error, which contradicts reality. For instance, you have written:
We have no such absolute law whereby we can truly safeguard ourselves from error. This is why even the philosophers who formulated rules of logic and debate, and constructed philosophical arguments have always made errors, and have left behind hundreds of absurd notions, flawed philosophies
and meaningless discussions to remind the world of their ignorance.
By this statement do suggest that all the investigations and efforts that man has made thus far over the course of thousands of years have produced nothing except false notions and philosophies, and absurd theories, and have thus failed to put forward any sound notion or theory or credible proposition; or do you mean that the researchers who are now engaged in investigations about nature are only adding to a collection of ‘ignorance’ and that they are simply unable to reach any truth? If you do not answer these questions in the negative, it would become manifestly evident that you are in clear denial of hundreds of branches of knowledge, and thousands of credible pieces of information and authentic facts regarding these various fields of knowledge, which more or less benefit almost every nation of the world. I trust, however, that this is perhaps not the purport of your statement. What you most probably intend to state is that the possibility of man committing errors and misjudgements in his investigations is plausible, but not that man has been created, inherently by nature, in such a manner as restricts him from acquiring any information that is true. For you must have seen or heard of such people or even read about them in books of history as were not free of error or misjudgement in ‘all their conclusions and judgements,’ yet their knowledge in many areas has proven to be categorically sound and true.
Moreover, hundreds of investigations that have been conducted in the past or are being conducted today are such that it is absolutely impossible to find flaw with them. And, this you can surely confirm by looking at hundreds of pieces of information which relate to the natural sciences, mathematics and morality. Nature has provided all of the means that are required by any person to obtain the entire range of information that man has so far been able to obtain or will ever obtain in the future. Now, the more man continues to develop these means on an individual and collective level, by continuing to refine them and make them more effective through the best use of his capacities, the more he will continue to succeed in the acquisition of sound knowledge through investigations into nature.
Having read this brief statement of mine, I hope that you will not deny the fact that although it is possible for man to err in his investigations; this does not mean that all his investigations are flawed. Rather, many of his investigations are established as being true. It evidently follows that if he has not erred regarding a certain piece of information, the rule or method that was employed to obtain that specific fact must also have been free of error. The reason for this is that the use of a flawed method can never produce a correct conclusion. Hence, if a certain piece of information known to man is correct, then it follows that the means provided to him by nature for the acquisition of that knowledge were also used in a proper and reasonable manner. On the contrary, wherever a person fails to ascertain correct information, they must have failed to make use of the relevant means in a correct manner. This can be likened to the condition of a person who has a telescope and knows how to open it but is unable to see an object in front of him or see it clearly because of his inability to properly adjust the focus of the telescope.
Likewise, at times, a person remains unable to properly adjust the focus of the telescope of the means that nature has provided him. Consequently, he either remains totally deprived of witnessing the sight that reality displays or he witnesses it only unclearly.
However, he who is able to properly adjust the focus discovers the error committed by the people of previous times and thus discovers the truth of the matter at hand.
Now, this statement (which is a clear and unambiguous one) evidently proves that in some cases, man, having appropriately put to use the means provided to him by nature, quickly discovers the reality of a matter. Secondly, if he does not or is incapable of appropriately putting to use the said means and commits an error, someone else who finds the opportunity to put them to appropriate use is able to remove the misunderstanding of the one before him.
The history of humanity’s quest for knowledge is therefore replete of these sorts of interesting accounts. In this context, our experience spanning thousands of years clearly demonstrates that it is not at all difficult for any researcher to reach the conclusion that man who is equipped with all the necessary physical organs, and is blessed with mental and moral capabilities, is quite fit to seek a path for himself in this world (such that suits his disposition and is in harmony with his needs and requirements) and should himself obtain knowledge of the means necessary for his physical and spiritual well-being and progress and thus utilize them to his full advantage.
Hence, if we ignore this law of nature or seek to present a hypothetical argument against the wisdom of the True and Wise Lord by suggesting that it is a need of man to see in all four directions but he has only two eyes on his face, and due to this when he is looking at a thing in front of him, he cannot see behind even if danger lurks behind him; so since man only has two eyes at the front, he cannot see what is happening behind him; hence, was it not possible for God, who is Gracious and Merciful and Wise, to grant him two eyes in the back of his head as well, so that he could be alerted to the danger and try to protect himself from it? Therefore, you claim that when there is a need for two eyes at the back of the head as well, it would be necessary for God to provide man these two eyes so that he is able to further protect himself. Additionally, if someone were to argue that the intellect of man is prone to error and cannot even know, in advance, that the ship on which he is going to travel from Bombay to England will face a severe storm in the sea a week or so after its departure, which is bound to destroy it; so while man, on his own, is unable to safeguard himself from the destructive and fatal impact of the storm and while only God (who is Gracious and Merciful and free of every error and flaw and is the knower of the reality of every matter) can forthwith help His servants through His angels, how can we—His weak and helpless servants—safeguard ourselves from the fatal storm? The wisdom, mercy and compassion of that All- Powerful Lord, therefore, demands that He keeps informing us of the storm well before it has actually hit us, so that we can save ourselves and our ship.
Now, evidently, those who are blessed with the ability to sufficiently fathom the deeper reality of things and are well-versed in principles of logic would consider the two aforementioned arguments of mine to be categorically absurd and unfounded. The reason for this is that in the first place the argument constructed to prove the ‘need’, which I have declared to be the cause for the conclusion I have drawn, is an argument based merely on my imagination and fancy, and is not supported by the laws of nature. Rather, in doing so we neglect the laws of nature altogether, and put forth our own explanations to describe the wisdom of God. Secondly, since the cause I have put forth is hypothetical, the conclusion I have drawn from it is also purely hypothetical and the laws of nature reject this proposition. This is the reason why in the first example just as our conclusion is contrary to facts, inasmuch as man does not have two extra eyes at the back of the head; similarly, in the second example also, despite the fact that hundreds of ships have been destroyed in the sea and hundreds and thousands of people have lost their lives in such disasters, God, to this very day, has never sent any angel to the captain of a ship informing him of an imminent disaster.
Hence, we can say that in both cases the reasoning constructed by us in relation to ‘need’ were not in accordance with the wisdom of God or the laws of nature, therefore the conclusions we drew from them also proved to be contrary to the laws of nature, as they were at odds with the wisdom of God, and proved to be nothing more than hypothetical. Evidently, the argument you have put forth in favour of the need for revelation is quite similar to the arguments I have put forth above. You state: