[Pundit Shiv Narayan’s Reply]
Early Writings, Part 2
If man is unable to protect himself from error merely by his own knowledge and judgement and if we accept that God too
(Who is Gracious and Merciful and free of every error and fault, and is the Knower of the truth of every matter) does
not help His servants through His true revelation, then how can we, who are His helpless servants, emerge from the veils of ignorance and misguidance, and gain deliverance from the calamities of doubt and misunderstanding? Hence, based on my firm and considered view, I would invite you to accept that the wisdom, mercy and compassion of the Omnipotent
Lord demands from time to time, whenever He deems it necessary to raise such people who receive revelation from God so that they are enlightened in respect of true beliefs and morals.
In this argument of yours, the reasoning that you have presented regarding ‘need’ is similar to the arguments that I have presented; whereas the laws of nature do not support them. Hence, such reasoning proves nothing, and is merely hypothetical and imaginary in nature. The reason for this is that one can cite a hundred such ‘needs.’ The question, however, is whether divine wisdom accepts those ‘needs’ to be genuine, or not. According to the intellectuals, only that ‘need’ is a ‘true need’ which is acknowledged by nature or the wisdom of God Almighty. For instance, our need to eat in order to satiate our hunger or our need to breathe air is not a hypothetical one; it is rather a natural requirement. That is why God has provided both resources to us in reasonable amounts to support human life. But a need which nature does not acknowledge as a genuine need of man and which we, on our own, consider to be a need is a hypothetical one. This is why when we cite it as a cause for a conclusion, the conclusion too is proved false in light of observation. I have amply explained this in the examples cited above.
Secondly, as for the degree to which your statement seeking to define revelation is relevant to the argument you have presented, it would be sufficient to write that the very ‘need’ on which you have based your argument in support of revelation is baseless, i.e. nature does not consider such a need to be a valid one. Now, even if we accept that the building you have raised on such a foundation has been constructed with quality material, it does not have a solid foundation and cannot stand on the baseless foundation built by your imagination. Just as the foundation is imaginary, so is the building that has been constructed upon it.
I hereby wish to shed light on the damage that has been caused to the people of the world due to this erroneous belief about revelation and the evils that it has given rise to, and also the impediments it has posed to human progress; however, as this matter is not directly related to the point being discussed, I put this aside for the time being.
Sincerely,
Shiv Narayan Agnihotri
Lahore