A Rebuttal to the Reply written by Bawa Narayan Singh Sahib
Early Writings
Published in the Aftab newspaper on 18th February
To begin with, Bawa Sahib has put the question to me that what proof is there that God is the Creator of the souls, and that He has the power to create them? Before I proceed to pen my response to this question, it is necessary to mention that according to the established rules of debate, you are not entitled to demand from me the proof that God is the Creator of souls. Rather, the right is mine to seek from you the proof that souls are born without a Creator. The reason for this is that you yourself have admitted, in the same newspaper, that God is All-Powerful and that He alone maintains order in the entire universe. Evidently, it now falls upon you to prove this subsequent assumption that while initially God was All-Powerful, now He has become powerless. It does not fall on me to prove that God, who has been Omnipotent from the very beginning, is still Omnipotent. So, my good sir, it is in fact your responsibility to provide comprehensive evidence of how God, despite being the All-Powerful Lord, would be unable to create the souls. I cannot be asked about how much capacity God (Who has already been accepted as being the Omnipotent) has for creating the souls. For you and I are already believers that God is All-Powerful. To this extent, there is no matter of contention between us. The contention has arisen on your account when you suggested that the All-Powerful God is unable to create the souls. Hence, under these circumstances, you ought to judge for yourself as to who is responsible for providing evidence.
If, for the sake of argument, we assume that the burden of proof was on me even though you are the one who has made the claim, I would hereby like to give you the good news that I have already provided categorical proof of God being the Creator in the issue of Safir-e-Hind dated 21 February. When you study the aforementioned edition of the newspaper with justice, you will be fully satisfied. Moreover, it is self-evident that only that being can be God who brought into existence the whole of creation, not one who, like despotic rulers, establishes His divinity by simply dominating others.
As for your apprehension that since God cannot create another being like his own, so too, He is also perhaps unable to create the souls, I have penned a befitting answer to this in the same newspaper mentioned above, in the edition dated 9 February. To summarise, God does not perform such actions as may undermine His eternal attributes. For instance, He cannot create a partner like unto Himself; He cannot destroy Himself, for if He does, His eternal attributes such as His Oneness and everlasting existence will be rendered false. This is why the Lord of Holiness will never perform any such act as would contradict His eternal attributes. Apart from this, He can do whatever He wills. Hence, you are mistaken when you draw an analogy between the creation of souls and the creation of partners with God. I have already stated that this is a false analogy. If, however, you had proved that the creation of souls is contradictory to an attribute of God, or is opposed to His grandeur and majesty, as it is for God to create a partner like unto Himself, your claim invariably would have proved to be valid. So, your demand that it is for me to prove how God created the souls clearly demonstrates that you are in total denial of God’s natural powers and consider Him, like man, to be dependent on means. And, if, by what you have written, you mean to state that you fail to rationalise how God manages to create the souls, I have already refuted this objection by saying that in order for it to be established that God is the All-Powerful Lord, there is no precondition that man must also be able to understand all His works.
There are thousands of such phenomena in the world as are beyond human comprehension. Besides, there is a difference between a phenomenon being incomprehensible and for it to have been established as being impossible. Lack of evidence in respect of how God created the souls does not establish that God is unable to create the souls. For absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Is it not possible for our flawed wisdom to remain unable to comprehend the secrets behind a particular act of God while God possesses the power to perform that act? In fact, the very definition of divine power is to be free and pure of the blemish of dependence on means, and to be beyond the scope of human comprehension. To state, in the first place, that God is All-Powerful and then to suggest that His providence cannot act beyond the limits of material means amounts to the denial of His very Being. For if, by inherent nature, He is All-Powerful, what would be the meaning of this if He is dependent on the help and support of another? Do the Hindu scriptures you believe in describe the All-Powerful and Omnipotent God as one Who depends on means to sustain the workings of the universe and who can do nothing solely by His own command? Perhaps this is written in your holy books but we do not believe in such a weak God. Ours is the Omnipotent Lord Who possesses the attribute that as He willed, so it was, and whatever He wills, so it will be.
Then, in his reply to me, Bawa Sahib has written that just as I believe that God cannot create another God like Himself, I should also believe that He also cannot create the souls. In the face of such wisdom and at such a remark, what shall I do if not be astonished? Good Sir! I have already refuted this objection of yours on a number of occasions. How much more shall I write on this, again and again? It amazes me as to how you cannot understand the obvious difference between the two and why this veil cannot be lifted from your heart.
It is wrong to compare the creation of the souls to the creation of another god. To make another god would destroy the eternal divine attribute of being One and without partner. However, creating souls does not necessitate the annulment of any necessary attributes of God Almighty. Rather, His inability to create something would render His necessary attributes useless. For, in such a case, His attribute of being the All-Powerful, which is a fact that we both agree upon, would remain hidden and unproven. The reason being that if God has not created anything out of His own inherent power and without having relied on any means, then how can we come to know that He is by inherent nature the All-Powerful? If you say that He is not All-Powerful in His nature, this would make Him dependent, that is, He would have to rely upon somebody other than Himself, which is evidently and rationally false.
In short, it is so crucial for God to be the Creator of the souls that if this were not the case, the whole system of God’s divinity would be ruined. However, to create another god is against the attribute of divine oneness. How, then, can God commit an act that would undermine an eternal attribute of His? Secondly, if one believes that the souls have not been created by God and are eternal, then they all become partners with God in terms of His eternal and infinite nature. Moreover, one will have to believe that God, who, from the very beginning, possesses the attribute of creating without dependence on any means, is deprived of this quality, thus one will have to admit that God only supervises the souls and is not their Creator and the Necessary Being.
After this, in his same reply, Bawa Sahib has addressed the issue of the infinite nature of souls. This is despite the fact that I have already refuted this idea in the Safir-e-Hind edition dated 9 and 16 February with as many as fourteen compelling arguments. Yet, Bawa Sahib continues to persist in his denial. I would, therefore, like to make it clear that it is easy to reject and deny an argument and everyone is definitely free to hold fast to whatever belief they choose. However, I would have acknowledged Bawa Sahib’s scholarship if he had refuted any of the arguments I presented and if he had given proof for his belief on the infinite nature of souls. You ought to understand that since souls are not found everywhere, they cannot be infinite. Do you believe that a boundless thing is such that if it moves from one place to another, the place where it earlier rested would become empty? If your Parameshvara too is infinite in the same sense, then I am sorry to say that His divinity is in danger. Sadly, you have not reflected and pondered upon the sound arguments that I have presented in this regard and have written a response without due care. In fact, fair-mindedness would demand that you ought to have taken care in your reply to quote each one of my arguments and then put forth your own arguments alongside them. But, how could you have done this while you had nothing to say in your defence?
What is even more surprising is that in your rebuttal you accept that undoubtedly in the beginning of the universe all souls are born on earth, and the world has a lifespan of only four and a quarter billion years—no more than that. Now, my friends and dear ones, reflect for yourself and ponder upon your statement, and explain to me how can something that is born at a specific time and in a finite place, and the reproduction of which comes to an end after a particular period of time be infinite? You must have read that one of the established rules of philosophy is that even if certain entities of finite nature multiply for a limited time, ultimately, even after their increase in quantity, they will still remain finite all the same. This establishes that if a few animals continue to reproduce for a period of time, their number, as per the aforesaid principle, will not exceed a specific number.
Moreover, even in light of mathematics, every wise person can understand that whatever rate of birth is assumed to occur within a timespan of four and a quarter billion years would clearly be double in number if it was hypothetically assumed that this period was increased to eight and a half billion years. However, it is an obvious reality that an infinite number cannot be doubled in quantity.
If souls were infinite, how could they be confined within a finite timespan with a number that can logically be multiplied twofold? No intelligent person would term an entity that is limited in time and space to be infinite. Would Bawa Sahib kindly explain to me that if the amount of birth that occurs in four and a quarter billion years is what he calls infinite, then how would he quantify such birth which takes place over a period of eight and a half billion years? Therefore, it is a categorical misstatement to say that the existing souls, in spite of being confined to a limited period of time and space, are infinite. For such reproduction as occurs within a limited period of time cannot exceed a fixed number. And, if you say that all souls are born instantly at once on the earth, this too would evidently be false. According to you, the earth is limited while souls are unlimited in number. How then can the infinite exist within the finite? If you say that some animals, due to their having not achieved salvation, do not appear in the new world, this would be against your own principle. For it has already been mentioned above that as per your own principle, all such souls that fail to find salvation during an earlier cycle of creation, are reborn once again so that they may taste the fruit of their past actions, and no soul is exempt from this process of rebirth.
Now, putting all other arguments aside, if we were to reflect over just this argument alone of being confined in time and space, it is clearly established that you have no choice but to accept that souls are limited in number—you must concede on this point. If all the arguments given by me in answer to Question Number 1, and those cited by me in answer to the question being addressed now are read collectively, any fair-minded person would conclude that to deny such categorical arguments is to, as if, deny the existence of the sun. It is unfortunate, therefore, that Bawa Sahib still believes that souls are infinite and will never cease to exist even after they have obtained salvation, whereas we have come to learn by your own position that all souls in fact cease to exist within a period of five billion years, and that at the time of each doomsday they are met with death.