A Rebuttal to the Reply written by Bawa Narayan Singh Sahib

Early Writings, Part 3

My honourable sir! Who says that contingent beings cannot possess similarity and resemblance so far as external characteristics are concerned? The matter of contention here, in fact, is whether anything other than God can share with Him in His divine attributes, or whether His attributes are exclusive to Him alone? As regards this disputed issue, you are the one who makes a claim; however, the example you have cited pertains to contingent beings, whereas this has no relevance to the debate at hand. You are obliged to put forth an example which relates to the issue at hand. Only then will your argument stand proven. Otherwise, to speak of partnership and resemblance in terms of contingent beings cannot serve as a clinching argument against me. Moreover, it is not appropriate to judge the inherent qualities of God against characteristics possessed by contingent beings. In addition to this it should also be noted that even in the case of contingent beings, their inherent attributes are related distinctly to their essences. For instance, the complete definition of man is that he is a rational animal and this quality of being ‘rational’ is from among his essential characteristics; it is the differentia that distinguishes him from other species. The differentia of man is not his faculty of sight or his ability to see with his eyes. For even if he were to become blind, he would still remain a human being. In reality, the essential characteristic of man may be defined as that which subsists even after his soul has left the corporeal body.

It is true, nonetheless, that since contingent beings are similar in respect of their basic elemental constitution—certain characteristics they possess are beside their fundamental essence and so they do share certain traits with each other. For example, a human being, a horse, and even a tree share a similarity in substance, three-dimensional form and in their faculty of growth. Further, in terms of their ability to feel and move by independent choice man and horse are alike. However, in their fundamental essence the two are surely different from one other. In short, the accidental properties of contingent beings is in addition to their fundamental essence and at times a similarity or difference can exist in various cases between such beings. Moreover, despite their differing fundamental essences and natures, at times, on account of shared properties, they may be classified as falling under the same genus. As a matter of fact, sometimes on account of even one essential property, entities can become one genus. Do you know why this is the case? This is because their material constitution is in addition to their fundamental essence, and the essence of their material constitution is the same. Now, it is perhaps clear to you that this sharing of traits between contingents, does not imply equality in their essential properties; rather, this is an external similarity in accidental properties. Other animals can never be partners to man in terms of his inner eye which may be described as insight of the heart (enlightenment).

Towards the end of his essay, Bawa Sahib chose to remain silent after having stated that all the arguments presented by me were mere fallacies and thus unworthy of refutation. From this statement, every wise and intelligent person has perhaps immediately understood why Bawa Sahib felt compelled to utter such words.

The fact of the matter is that our esteemed friend, the honourable Bawa Sahib, came running initially to refute my arguments and exerted his best efforts, kicking and jumping, but unfortunately when he could not succeed, and when he ultimately failed to untangle the knot before him, he sat down, panting and out of breath, simply to say, ‘What is the use of refuting these arguments, they are mere conjectures anyway.’ However, any sensible person knows that arguments which are based on categorically established propositions cannot be brushed off as mere conjecture. I now conclude this exposition and shall not write any further unless it is necessary to do so again.

The author,

Mirza Ghulam Ahmad

Chief of Qadian

10 of 10 left today