A Rebuttal of Atheism

Early Writings

Atheist Question: If God does not have a body, than what is He?

Answer: A body is something that can be weighed in pounds and kilograms, or measured in length and width. God is a light that is free from all forms of defect. God Almighty states:

When we reflect upon the soul we come to know for certain that there are also such things in the world that do not have a physical body, yet they exist. Allah the Exalted says:

One argument in favour of the existence of God Almighty is that we must definitively accept that time had a beginning. For if time had no beginning then we would have observed the entire surface of the earth full of human beings, without a single corner vacant. However, scholars have estimated by observation that the human species can multiply enough from one man and woman to cover the land area of the earth in seven thousand years. If more than seven thousand years elapse, another earth would be required. Every individual can ponder over the extent to which the people of their respective nations are spread throughout the world. For example, eight hundred years ago there was a man named Maghul, whose children are known as the Mughals. Now just count how many Mughals there are in the world. Similarly, there was a man named Bawa Nanak Sahib who lived just three hundred years ago and his progeny has multiplied to the thousands. This argument establishes that the world has a beginning and an end. The beginning is proven by the fact that when we look back at the ages, we are able to estimate the duration of time. The end is proven by the fact that the world is a finite space which cannot accommodate within itself infinite birth. Therefore, we have no choice but to accept that one day this world will come to an end. As such, anything that has a beginning and an end must be a created entity, it cannot be eternal. So when the world is a created thing, it must have a creator and that Creator is God.

If someone were to suggest that certain families do not have very many children and remain limited in number, the answer to this would be that such cases are an anomaly. Otherwise, observation would show that when someone purchases even a single goat, it multiplies to become an entire herd. It is also a general principle in this world that natural death usually occurs around the age of sixty or seventy years. Moreover, population multiplies after a period of fifteen years. A clear proof of this fact is that islands which were previously uninhabited have now become populated.

The second argument in favour of the existence of the Necessary Being is that no creation can be observed to exist without the agency of a creator. Even a small room cannot be constructed without a builder. Then, how can this large ‘room’ the floor of which extends over a distance of more than 24,000 miles and the roof of which is built in a most flawless and reinforced manner, adorned with lamps that give light—all ordered in such a way that one of them stands superior with others subservient to it in brilliance have been self-created, without someone having created it.

An atheist would respond by saying that we can visually observe the people who create physical rooms in this world, but we cannot see the creator of heaven and earth. I would say that if the argument is that a worldly builder can be physically seen, then what need is there to provide evidence of his existence? The need to provide evidence arises only when something that cannot be physically seen must be proven. One observes that many ancient buildings are present in Egypt which the people of this age cannot recreate. However, it can still be accepted with certainty that it was worldly builders who erected those structures. These created structures themselves are proof of the existence of a builder, irrespective of whether one can see those builders now or not. If a man were the first to invent a certain machine, and no one had ever built this type of a creation before him, even if we had not seen that individual ourselves, would we deduce that the creation in question built itself ? Every intelligent design proves the skill of an intelligent creator. It would be extremely biased and close-minded for someone to accept on the one hand that a certain creation possesses characteristics of intelligent design, yet reject the fact that an intelligent designer created it. There is always a difference between the actions of an intelligent creator and the unintelligent. Moreover, if any creation shows within it signs of a creator who demonstrates a conscious consideration of his own objectives and whose action does not appear useless, then sound reason lends evidence of the fact that the creation in question springs forth from the action of an intelligent creator. For example if there was an ink spill on a piece of paper, it is possible that the ink could have been spilled by a particular person, or a mouse, or even by itself as chance. However, if the text of a book were written on the piece of people conveying some important meaning, no wise person would say that this text was written all by itself without the action of a scribe. Taking this further, even if the letters on the paper were so different in appearance that we had never seen such letters before, but when it is established that these too are letters of some sort, and the text continues for hundreds of pages, even if we had not seen the scribe ourselves and even if we had not seen such unique letters before, there would be no doubt in the fact that these letters were the creation of some scribe.

You see, for example, if all of heaven and earth had been like a small room, you would definitely observe its extreme beauty in entirety and say that some wise individual had created it. Now, one ought to reflect that when even a small room cannot be built without the agency of a builder how can the entire realm of heaven and earth be without a creator?

The third argument in favour of the existence of God Almighty is that we observe in the world that one thing develops with the help of other elements. For example, trees are nourished by water and rain occurs with the help of the sun. Certain animals are created by the agency of other animals. No creature is born except through procreation. Therefore, we must accept the existence of one Necessary Being who supports the creation of all other creations.

Humans are created from a droplet of sperm, and sperm is produced by consuming food, and food is grown from the soil, and how is soil produced? If someone were to say that soil has always existed since the beginning, this would be false, because only such a thing may be described as existing independently by itself which does not depend on anything else in any circumstances. However, in order to maintain its form, soil requires water. If soil had not contained water, the wind would blow it away. So even the soil depends on water in order for it to grow vegetation and no dependant thing can be eternal. Moreover, a dependant thing cannot be described as a necessary entity existing independently. Moreover, the soil produces trees and trees are a superior creation. So a deficient thing cannot be a necessary creation.

The fourth argument is that God Almighty states:

Then, He also says:

The meaning of these two aforementioned verses is that evidence is furnished by an observation of the universe that all things are created by one Creator and Maker. For example, the heat of the sun causes vapours, which in turn forms the clouds. The clouds then produce water and water creates fruit. However, God is the Best of Creators, He is the Maker of the heavens and earth, Who brings all of these things into existence from nothing.

Moreover, if God did not exist, the door to all goodness and benefit would come to a close. The reason being that all people do good because this is beneficial to them. In fact, no one performs any action without first considering the benefit or harm that it entails because certain actions are useless in a person’s estimation. Similarly, a person who does not believe in the existence of God cannot fear evil. For evil is only evil when it results in ill consequences. If the consequences of a certain action are not deemed to be harmful, the heart will never consider it to be evil. If no one were to fear the ill effects of evil, how could anyone prevent the people from committing wrongdoing. If someone were to suggest that kings and rulers can prevent people, I would say then who would prevent the kings and rulers themselves? Those who possess authority and power fear no one. Moreover, kings and rulers are not omnipresent, nor do people believe that they are watching their every action at all times.

Additionally, the proposition that we do not believe in a

Creator of heaven and earth because we cannot see him, is nothing but deception. For if we could see the Creator in this world, then the world would no longer serve any purpose, nor would anyone receive spiritual reward for doing good. The reason being that an individual is only worthy of spiritual reward until they act with righteousness and believe in a God Who is Hidden. If God had shown Himself openly to everyone then what merit would there be in believing in Him? Allah the Exalted states:

Another argument in favour of the existence of God Almighty is that the thoughts of all humanity converge on the fact that there is One Being Who is the Lord of all the worlds. Moreover, all of humanity agrees that the creation of the heavens and earth is one which could not have come into existence without the hand of a Creator. So when many wise people agree on a point, it is always the truth. As the saying goes: the wise always hold one view, but the foolish one each his own.

10 von 10 heute frei