A Rebuttal of Atheism

Early Writings, Part 2

Atheists will say that we have not seen the Creator of heaven and earth, whereas we observe the creators of everything else; so how can we believe with certainty in the existence of a Creator. The response to this is that even though you cannot see the Creator, you can see the creation. Now if there is a certain creation that is built with great skill, but we cannot see its creator, we would still invariably conclude that someone must have created the thing in question. The debate relates to whether a creation lends evidence of a creator or not. Atheists assert that even if a highly intelligent design possessing all the characteristics of intricate workmanship is present before them, until they physically see the creator of that thing, they will not accept his existence. This is nothing but deception, for there is no need to see the creator. When it is proven that an intelligent phenomenon possesses the qualities of intelligent design our heart accepts without question that some intelligent creator must have designed it.

When we observe the world around us, we can see with our own eyes that everything is created with the help of something else and one thing is sustained by another; in fact, it is through heaven and earth that all these things exhibit their powers. Now when this is the case, an atheist must answer the question: with whose help and support was heaven and earth created and who has sustained them for all this time? The atheist will respond by saying the very existence of heaven and earth is testimony itself that they are sustained themselves. However, we draw their attention to the fact that the nature of a father is reflected in the son. Similarly, all the creation present in the world is like the offspring of heaven and earth, and cannot exist without support. So this demonstrates that the real testimony of heaven and earth is in line with the principle mentioned above, because the nature of a son cannot be different from that of the father, as it were. An intelligent phenomenon that is proven to possess characteristics of intelligent design does not require us to see its creator with our eyes. The proof of this statement is that any action displaying manifest signs that it was performed by someone who consciously did so to create something with a particular objective in mind, cannot be deemed an action of chance, even by the most foolish of people. On the contrary, one would consider such an action to have been performed by an active entity. For example, if there was an ink spill on a piece of paper, we would not be sure how this happened. However, if one or two pages were filled with words that express an objective of the writer, then no intelligent person would say that these words were written all by themselves. The atheist should also tell us, who develops them to adulthood and then old age? What effect brings about this phenomenon?

Then, we also ask the atheist that the sun, moon, earth and air, all of which are in your constant service and do not stop serving you even for a moment, do you owe them your gratitude for doing so? If you were to say that these elements serve you without understanding this would be false, because any action that is caused without understanding or without any kind of supervision, ultimately turns into chaos. If you were to say that these elements serve you with understanding, then you ought to be thankful to them.

We also ask atheists: does the rising of the sun or rainfall occur by chance or through someone’s control? If it is all by chance, then what reason is there for the world to remain at all? Why should excessive rainfall and heat not cause random seasons? After all, a thing of chance is always prone to error. However, if this entire phenomenon is by some control, then this proves the existence of God, because the control we see on earth is essentially God Himself.

Atheists repeat the allegation that no one has seen God; if God existed someone ought to have seen him. The answer to this is that God shows Himself to the people through the eye of their heart. Those who follow these people and submit, ultimately reach the station where God blesses them with divine understanding. The claim that no one has seen God is like the example of a blind person who rejects the existence of the sun and says that until he sees the sun himself, he will not accept that it exists. The response to such a person would be that since you are blind, you cannot observe the sun with your eyes; therefore, the manner in which you can reach the truth is by trusting the statements of those who have in fact seen the sun; when your eyes are cured, you too will be able to see the sun.

We also ask atheists to tell us whether pleasure and pain is caused by someone else or whether we control this. If humans control this phenomenon, then why are people unable to prolong their lives according to their own wishes? Why can they not increase the pleasure in their lives? One person dies in old age, whereas the other dies when they are young, even though everyone desires a long life. On certain occasions a man desires pleasure, but they are struck with grief. This demonstrates that a higher being controls the phenomenon of pain and grief—and that being is God Almighty.

10 of 10 left today