Surah 37: As-Saffat
The Holy Qur’an with English Translation and Commentary (Five Volume Commentary), Part 3
And stop them; for they must be questioned.’[3289]
[3289] Commentary:
Before being actually punished the guilty will be asked to show the cause why they should not be punished, or, if they had anything to say in defence or extenuation of their guilt, to produce it.
They will be asked, ‘What is the matter with you that you help not one another?’[3290]
[3290] Commentary:
The realisation of utter helplessness of the guilty people to assist each other will be brought home to them.
Nay, on that day they will surrender themselves completely.[3291]
[3291] Commentary:
The verse portrays the complete surrender and submission to Divine judgement of the guilty leaders and also of their beguiled and deceived followers. They will offer no defence but will only indulge in mutual recrimination as the following verses show.
And some of them will address the others, [b]questioning one another.
[b] 34:32.
They will say, ‘Verily, you used to come to us, from the right.’[3292]
[3292] Important Words:
الیمین (the right) is derived from یمن. They say یمن الرجل i.e. he came from the right side of the man. یمین means, right hand or right side; good luck; power. They say فلان عندنا بالیمین i.e. such a one holds a good position with us (Aqrab).
Commentary:
The verse, besides the meaning given in the text, may also mean: "you came to us exerting your power and influence and compelling us to obey and follow you."
The words 'the right side' may also signify religion, and the verse would thus mean, "you masqueraded under the cloak of religion to deceive us."
The pronoun 'they' in the expression "they will say" refers to common disbelievers.
Their associate-gods will answer, [a]‘Nay, you yourselves were not believers.[3293]
[3293] Commentary:
In this verse the pronoun 'they' in the sentence "they will answer" refers to the leaders of disbelief.
[a] 34:33.
[b]And we had no power over you; but you yourselves were a transgressing people.
[b] 14:23; 15:43.
Now the word of our Lord has been proved true against us that we shall surely taste the punishment.
And we caused you to go astray for we ourselves had gone astray.’[3294]
[3294] Commentary:
In vv. 30, 31 above the leaders of disbelief had refused to plead guilty to the charge that they had led their followers astray by saying that they had no power or authority over them; in the verse under comment they plead guilty to the charge of misleading them. The seeming contradiction is, in reality, no contradiction. The verse means to say that leaders of disbelief will say to their followers: "You yourselves chose to follow us, and since we ourselves had gone astray, you could expect nothing better from us. It was a case of blind leading the blind."
Truly, on that day they will all be sharers in the punishment.
Surely, thus do We deal with the guilty.
For when it was said to them, ‘There is no god but Allah,’ they turned away with disdain,