Al-Istifta’

Haqiqatul-Wahi (The Philosophy of Divine Revelation), Part 16

What can be a greater sin than this: Allah gives the news of the death of ‘Isa in the Holy Qur’an; He mentions that on the Day of Judgment ‘Isa will plead that he died before the apostasy of his people and has no knowledge about it, as has been mentioned earlier; and the Holy Prophet (sa) says that he saw ‘Isa among the dead with Ilyas [Elijah] during the night of Mi‘raj; yet you raise him with his physical body to the heavens! I have not seen anything stranger than this! What is the matter with you that you do not understand? What I have said in this regard is decisive; you cannot flee from it. You insist on him being alive, yet you fail to present an argument for it.

The only answer you have to this is that your forefathers adhered to the same belief, even though they might have fallen away from the right path. What is the value of the thoughts of those who were born after the Companions—indeed, three centuries later? They had no right to interpret the news [of the unseen] conveyed by Allah before those events had actually taken place. Due respect called for leaving the issue of the origins of this spring to Allah. Indeed, such has been the practice of the elders of the ummah that while interpreting the tidings of the unseen they never insisted on any single meaning. They believed in the prophecies in their entirety and left the details to the All-Knowing God. This is the safest way according to those who possess righteousness and wisdom. However, afterwards, there came a people who transgressed the limits of their knowledge and forgot what has been said:

Like fleas, they jumped around from one place to the other and insisted upon things they had not fully comprehended. What pity upon them and their audacity! They have caused such damage to the Religion that it can be called the sister of the damage caused to it by Christianity. Indeed, they are like the years of famine for the Religion.

They raise ‘Isa with his physical body to the heavens and do not reflect upon the words of God Almighty:

Instead, they continue to increase in malice and spite. O brave young people! What is your stance vis-a-vis these verses? Why do you follow that which is dubious and abandon the Signs that are evident and certain? Do you not know that the disbelievers had, according to the verse

[Publisher]

my Lord! I am not but a man sent as a Messenger (Surah Bani Isra’il, 17:94)]. Doubtless, this verse categorically rejects the idea of any human being ascending to heaven with his physical body. Only the most ignorant would deny this. In fact, the words

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

refer to another verse of the Holy Qur’an, which is

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

[Therein shall you live and therein shall you die (Surah al-

A‘raf, 7:26)], for physical ascension of any individual to heaven would result in the breaking up of this natural law and God Almighty does not violate His law. Hence, reflect upon it, O wise ones! (Author)

mentioned above, demanded from our Holy Prophet (sa)—the Best of Mankind and the Chosen One of God—the miracle of physical ascension to heaven? In response, God told them that His practice never allowed any human being to be physically raised to heaven; rather, it was in contradiction with His eternal practice and law? Suppose that ‘Isa [ Jesus] was really raised to the Second Heaven, then what would the restriction laid down in the aforesaid verse imply? Did the God of Honour not consider ‘Isa to be a human being? So why was there an urgency for him to be raised to the high heavens? Had the earth become too narrow for him? Or was there no refuge left for him to escape the Jews so that he had to be raised to the heavens to be hidden?

O people! Deviate not from the right path, and weigh with a fair balance. By God! The death of Jesus is better for Islam than his life. The victory of the Religion [of Islam] lies entirely in the death of Jesus. Do you want to exchange what is good for that which is foul? Can you not distinguish between profit and loss? By God, Jesus’ life cannot coexist with the life of Islam. You have seen what his presumed life has constructed and what it has demolished, and you are seeing how it has helped and advanced Christianity and has wounded the most upright religion. Since the damage it has caused is proven before us, how can we expect it to bring any good in the future? Having so long experienced the harm done by his presumed life, what good can we hope to acquire from this belief thereafter, given the established proof of its being invalid?

Wise indeed is he who does not go against this experience. God Almighty guides to the paths of wisdom, and shows mercy to His servants and safeguards them against the doors which lead to misguidance. Without a doubt, the belief that Jesus is alive and will descend is a door from among the doors to misguidance and nothing can be expected from it except for various unwholesome consequences. In His works Allah has wisdom which you cannot comprehend, as well as appropriateness which you cannot fathom. Therefore, ponder over this; may

Allah have mercy on you! The belief about Jesus being alive which you insist upon to this day, and the belief of his descent in the Latter Days, is a matter that has not provided you even an iota of benefit. Moreover, it has not helped our Faith, which is the best of all faiths. It only supported Christianity and caused droves of Muslims to join the people of the Cross.

O people of Islam! I do not understand what made you feel the need for Jesus to descend. The fact is that his life only brings you harm, not benefit. Have you not witnessed its damage in the past years? Has this belief benefited you in the bygone age? Instead, it brought ruin upon you by causing your males and females to become apostates. Therefore—O brave, young people!—How can anything good be expected from this belief ? You have seen that the converts to Christianity were pulled towards the priests only through these lassos, and indeed they [these priests] are the very thief who threw them into the well of destruction even though they had descended from the Muslims. But, then they became like snakes and wild beasts. They became hostile to Islam and defamed it in a voice worse than a donkey’s. They left their near ones and their parents weeping and wailing upon their condition and devoted themselves to vituperation against the Best of Mankind [the Holy Prophet (sa) ] and to blaspheming the Best of Books [the Holy Qur’an]. They alleged that it contained nothing but poetry and that it had not been beneficial to anyone. They made our religion the target of their ridicule and spoke of it only as an object of derision and warned the Muslims that if they died practicing it, they would enter Hell.

May God show you the right path and safeguard you from the path of His displeasure. Remember that the bane [of Christianity] that you consider to be harmless is, in the eyes of God, a great evil. It has ruined many among you and dispatched them to Hell. This is why God Almighty warned of it in a number of places in the Holy Qur’an. Indeed, it is to this very belief that He ascribed the renting asunder of the heavens, the blowing away of the mountains, and the appearance of the Signs of great punishment. By Allah, I am amazed at the Muslims who have supported the Christians by stating what is contradictory to the Word of God Almighty; they said that Jesus was physically raised to the heavens and would, at some time in the future, return to the earth. The Christians consider this to be the greatest argument in support of their belief in the divinity of Jesus Christ. Indeed, they misguide so many ignorant people by dint of the same argument in spite of the fact that Jesus is dead and is living among the dead. This is affirmed by a number of arguments set out both in the Holy Qur’an and Hadith. The Holy Qur’an speaks of him as dead in a number of places. The Holy Prophet (sa) saw him in the Second Heaven during the Night of Mi‘raj, residing among the dead along with Prophet Yahya [ John]. What can be a greater and more magnificent testimony than this? Yet the ignorant attack me when they hear it from me. They say that if they had a sword, they would have killed me. Verily, the sword of Allah is sharper than the swords of this group. Have not some of them already seen the strike of His sword during the mubahalah [with me]?

·

10 of 10 left today