Al-Istifta’

Haqiqatul-Wahi (The Philosophy of Divine Revelation), Part 17

The Holy Qur’an repeatedly mentions Jesus [‘Isa] to be dead. It also mentions that he was granted refuge on an elevated land of green valleys and springs of running water. It has been established with a number of other arguments that this was none other than the land of Kashmir, where Jesus’ grave has been discovered. This event is also mentioned in the old literature of this country—evidence that cannot be denied. Truth has become manifest, and all praise is due to Allah, the Lord of all the worlds. The people of this country [Kashmir] have testified that the grave is that of an Israelite Prophet who had migrated to this region after he was persecuted by his people, and that this occurred almost as many as 2,000 years ago. In short, there are incontrovertible arguments to prove that ‘Isa is dead. Only one who does not believe in the categorical arguments of the Holy Qur’an and Hadith can deny this. Had God so willed, He would have granted guidance to such people, but He lets go astray who wishes it and guides who wishes it, and they will all be returned to Him. They follow nothing but conjecture. I do not find them sticking to any reasonable argument. To cling to conjectures in the face of such precepts of incontrovertible import is dishonesty and departure from the path of righteousness. Woe unto those who do not desist.

Those who do not ponder would say that Jesus’ advent is a ‘Sign’ of the Day of Judgment [and quote the verse]:

This is what they have heard from their forefathers, but they have never pondered over it like the wise. What has gone wrong with them that they do not know that the word ‘Sign’ here signifies his miraculous birth which was without a father which is mentioned in the Scriptures and which no sane and knowledgeable person denies! As for the belief of the People of the Book in [the truthfulness of ] Jesus—as is imagined to be the import of this verse—you are only too well-aware of its reality. There is no need to delve into it further. You know that hosts of Jews have died without believing in Jesus. Therefore, do not interpolate the Word of God for the sake of a belief so obviously wrong. Verily, God has said:

Hence, how can they be his enemies after believing in Jesus? Is there not an iota of sense in your brains? Does this verse not disprove any such person who believes that all the sects of the Jews will come to believe in Jesus? Why are you then going against the text that is so clear and evident? Which verse [of the Holy Qur’an] is now left in your hands to which you are clinging?

Indeed, I am amazed at your condition! What argument do you have to oppose me? God Almighty repeatedly mentions the death of Jesus in the Holy Qur’an. Why, then, are you not admonished? There cannot be any contradiction in the Word of the Lord of all the worlds. What has gone wrong with you that you bear enmity towards the rational arguments and reject the scriptural records? I present to you the Word of God but you turn your faces aside and walk away.

You are well aware that both you and we unconditionally agree on the advent of the Promised Messiah. So the real contention between us and you is the issue of the son of Mary coming down from the sky. God Almighty has settled this issue by conveying the news of Jesus’ death in His enlightening Scripture. Anyone whom God chooses to guide to the right path, He opens his heart to accept the statements in the Holy Qur’an. After all, which book, besides the Furqan [Holy Qur’an], deserves to be followed with the utmost conviction by you and us both? Woe unto you! You neither want to show up for the debate nor accept the invitation to mubahalah. You only attack from afar. I have numerous arguments in my support from the Book of God and the Sunnah of His Messenger (sa), but how can I present them to those who are turning away? Know they not that Allah never grants succour to those who bring innovations into faith or are unbelievers, nor are they helped. Such people are neither accepted by Him nor are they given preference as is granted to the righteous.

After all, what wrongdoing can my opponents ascribe to me except that I have informed them of Jesus’ death? Whereas all other Prophets that lived before him are also dead, will they reject an established consensus that is evident and based on an incontrovertible argument, or will they make a decision on their own? I declare in the name of Allah that Jesus is dead. They [my opponents] are hostile to evident truths and claim what is contrary to the Holy Qur’an. Indeed, they have no fear [of the Almighty]. What prevents them from accepting that ‘Isa is dead? The fact of the matter is that they are a people who exceed all bounds. They ascribe to him [i.e. Jesus] an attribute which is not found in any human being, and knowingly support the Christians. How can the jealousy of

Allah tolerate ascribing anyone with one of His attributes, which no one has shared with Him from the beginning of the world to the end of times? What can be closer to disbelief than this belief ? Would that they had pondered over this, for such particularization is the very basis of idolatry. O ignorant ones! Is there any sin greater than holding partners with God Almighty? Remember when the Christians said that Jesus was the son of Allah because he was born fatherless and they were holding firmly to this belief. Allah responded to them with His word:

But we do not find in the Holy Qur’an any response to Jesus’ assumed peculiarity of physical ascension to heaven and then his descent from there, whereas the people of the Cross consider it to be the strongest evidence in support of their deification of Jesus. If Jesus’ ascension to the heavens and his descent from there were correct in the knowledge of our Gracious Lord, He would surely have compared Jesus with a person with the same attribute in the Holy Qur’an, just as He has compared him with Adam to refute the argument of the people of the Cross. Hence, certainly, the absence of such a comparison implies that the whole story of ascension is false; it is entirely baseless, and is nothing but nonsense. Do you know what wisdom prevented Allah from giving this answer whereas He was expected to respond to and uproot the Christian inference comprehensively? The Christian scholars are a people who are, with each passing day, increasing in exaggeration; and they do not turn towards the truth because of their arrogance and haughtiness. Nevertheless, I have fully established Allah’s argument in support of Islam against them.

I wrote numerous books on this subject and, for the benefit of the general population, published them in far off countries. However, when the debate between me and my opponents was prolonged and I did not find even a single person taking interest in Islam, I understood that it was a matter that demanded the succour of Allah the Great Bestower; for, I am nothing except when the mercy of my Gracious Lord comes to me. I then prostrated at the threshold of the Holy Lord to seek His help like a person who was already dead. It was then that my Lord blessed me with a new life by granting me two sentences and enlightened my eyes. He said:

lievers. To refute this, the Word of Allah that is recorded in my book Barahine-Ahmadiyya, is: 'Say: I have been commissioned from God and I am the first of the believers.’ Also, my enemies asserted that I should not be buried in a Muslim graveyard. To refute them, the Holy Prophet (sa) said that the Promised Messiah would be buried in his grave and they will be raised together on the Day of Resurrection. This is in response to those who say that I have declared Muslims to be disbelievers and consider me from among those who will enter Hell. If you have any doubt about what I have quoted above, you may enquire the righteous ones. It is from among the peculiarities of the state between the day of death to resurrection that some people, after they die, are granted spiritual nearness to the grave of the Holy Prophet (sa) which holds Paradise beneath it; whereas some are taken away from it. The Holy Prophet (sa) has, therefore, declared me to be from among those who will be granted nearness. This negates anyone who considers me to be from among the dwellers of Hell. God Almighty will spiritually bury me in the grave of the Holy Prophet (sa). This is what has been intimated on a number of occasions in the Book of God Almighty as well as in the sayings of the Holy Prophet (sa). Those who are cognizant of the spiritual realm do testify to the truth of this phenomenon.

Another objection that my opponents raised was that those who follow me will become disbelievers, and, therefore, should not be buried in a Muslim graveyard. To them, my followers were the worst of the disbelievers. At this, God spoke to me and drew my attention to a piece of land which He said held Paradise beneath it. He said those who will be buried in it shall enter Paradise and shall be granted security. Hence, there would have been no such rewards

Allah has placed blessing in you, O Ahmad. The Most Gracious

God has taught you the Holy Qur’an so that you should warn the people whose ancestors have not been warned, and that the way of the guilty ones might become manifest; say, ‘I have been

·

10 of 10 left today