Appendix to the Book Nuzulul-Masih

The Miracle of Ahmad, Part 6

Then, in a way, you determine God Almighty to be a liar, because God says that after the event of the cross He settled ‘Isa and his mother on an elevated piece of land with pristine running water, i.e. springs flowed in it; it was a place affording great comfort and quite like Paradise, as God says:

That is: After the episode of the cross, which was a great calamity, We granted ‘Isa and his mother refuge in a great elevated land, which was a place of great comfort with pleasant tasting water; i.e. the land of Kashmir.

If you have even the slightest knowledge of the Arabic language, you would be aware that the term اٰوی [awa] is used only on such an occasion where one is provided refuge after having been rescued from a disaster. This usage can be found throughout the Holy Qur’an, Arabic sayings, and the ahadith. In addition, the Word of God Almighty proves that during the entire life of Hadrat ‘Isa , peace be upon him, the cross was the only calamity that befell him. And it is proven from the hadith that it was this very incident which aggrieved Maryam [Mary] the most during her entire life. Hence, this verse proclaims loudly that after the incident of the cross, God rescued Hadrat ‘Isa from this calamity and took him away from that dangerous country and settled him in some other country where springs of clear water flowed and which was situated on elevated ground. The question now is whether there is a highland in Heaven where springs of clear water flow and where, after the incident of the cross, God Almighty caused Hadrat Masih and his mother to settle. Reflect upon the life history of Hadrat Masih and cite an example where having suffered a misfortune he was provided refuge in a country that was as calm and serene as Paradise and situated on elevated ground above the rest of the world and having springs flowing in it.

Hence, according to your belief, God Almighty turns out to be, God forbid, a blatant liar, for He speaks of an elevated land wherein ‘Isa and his mother were settled after the episode of the cross, while you seat him in Heaven for no reason or purpose. Would you now care to tell why, in spite of being a Prophet, he has been sitting idle for such a long time? What is more, you and Maulawi Sanaullah—who, due to having denied this verse, take him to the second Heaven—cannot come up with an answer as to why a living person joined the souls of the dead. Those people had all departed from this world and arrived in the next. Has he too then reached that next world?

Again, yet another lie attributed by you to God is that He might not have understood the objection of the Jews and therefore replied in an ambiguous manner. The Jews’ objection was that the spirit of Messiah was not raised to God, and God replied that He had raised him alive in his physical body to the second Heaven, and that He would cause him to die sometime in the future. What kind of answer is this on the part of God? The charge was that ‘Isa was not raised to Heaven after his death and, therefore, God forbid, became accursed. The right answer to this question was: ‘ ‘Isa

[ Jesus] has not died as of yet. When he dies, I will raise his spirit1 to Myself.’ But the evasive answer given above this has nothing to do with the point at issue.

Likewise, you believe that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, told a lie when he said that he had seen ‘Isa among the souls of the dead who had already left this world. May I ask you how a man in his physical body can sit among the [heavenly] souls and reach the next world without having been dispossessed of his earthly life? I wonder what kind of faith you have; for God, by His word, bears witness that ‘Isa is dead but you do not accept His testimony. The Prophet s (as) also gave his testimony through his action, i.e. through his eyewitness account. He saw him among the souls of the dead; however, you reject this testimony as well. And yet you claim to be Muslim and take pride in being ‘Ahl-e-Hadith’. The Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, did not even speak with ‘Isa on the night of Mi‘raj [spiritual ascension to Heaven]. Instead, it was Musa [Moses] with whom he had a discourse. The Holy Qur’an says that one should not be doubtful about the meeting of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, with Musa. Hence, what an extremely repulsive lie it is that you have ascribed to both God and His Messenger.

What is more, the maulawis argue that the verse pertains to ‘Isa. Indeed one should fear people who have such gross misunderstanding of the Holy Qur’an, for an incompetent religious scholar can put a person’s faith in danger. O Wicked people! Is the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, himself not

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

while he has stated that:

and while God also stated:

Then how obnoxious a folly it would be on the part of the people to interpret the term سَاعَۃ [sa‘ah—the hour] here as the Day of Judgment! Now, allow me to explain that the term سَاعَۃ [sa‘ah] that has been used here refers to the punishment inflicted upon the Jews at the hands of Titus, the Roman Emperor, after Hadrat ‘Isa had left them. God Himself spoke of this سَاعَۃ [sa‘ah] in the

Holy Qur’an in Surah Bani Isra’il. This verse is elaborated further by another one:

That is, during the time of Hadrat ‘Isa, the Jews were given a taste of the Day of Judgment by being afflicted with a severe chastisement which could be likened to the سَاعَۃ [sa‘ah] for them.

In the idiom in the Holy Qur’an, the term سَاعَۃ [sa‘ah] means punishment. This is why it had been foretold that the سَاعَۃ [sa‘ah] would strike the Jews as a result of their rejection of ‘Isa. Consequently, the Sign appeared as foretold and the سَاعَۃ [sa‘ah] befell the Jews. What is more, they were also stricken severely by the plague in those days. These events served as Doomsday for them, since the سَاعَۃ [sa‘ah] resulted in the destruction of hundreds of thousands of Jews. Besides, thousands died of the plague and the remaining became dispersed in utter disgrace. The Last Day will be a great affliction for the whole of humanity. This, however, was an affliction meant specifically for the Jews.

This argument is supported further by the Holy Qur’an when Allah, the Exalted, says:

This means: ‘O ye Jews! With the advent of ‘Isa, you will experience the horror of the Day of Judgment as you will be afflicted with a similar calamity, i.e.:

which means that an affliction akin to the Day of Judgment will befall you; hence, you must not have any doubt about it.’

It would clearly have been out of place for God to have urged the Jews not to doubt the occurrence of the actual Last Day, saying they would surely witness it. The Jews of that time all passed away and they never witnessed the Last Day, which is actually yet to come. So, did God tell a lie?! What they did witness, however, was the destruction brought about by Titus, the Roman general.

·

10 of 10 left today