Appendix to the Book Nuzulul-Masih

The Miracle of Ahmad, Part 8

Hence, in the case of a Prophet, his claim and teachings can be likened to the eye looking at things from very close and does not err in identifying them correctly. And, the misjudgement on their part regarding certain matters can be likened to the eye that at times makes an error in recognizing the objects lying at some distance. On this very basis, we can say that—since Hadrat ‘Isa (as), for the sake of the well-being of the Jews, thought of becoming a king—Satan, as mentioned in the verse,

succeeded in deceiving him by putting into his heart a desire for the throne of David. However, as he was close to God and dear to Him, those satanic delusions could not prevail and he soon came to realize that his kingdom was heavenly rather than earthly.

In summary, this interpretation of Hadrat Masih turned out to be wrong. The actual revelation was surely true, but he erred in understanding it. It is sad that the extent to which Hadrat ‘Isa erred in his interpretations, the like of it is not to be found among any other Prophet. Perhaps this was also a pre-condition to attaining divinity. However, can we say that, on account of his many wrong interpretations and wrong prophecies, his prophethood became doubtful? Certainly not. The fact of the matter is that the conviction that is instilled in the heart of a Prophet regarding the authenticity of his prophethood is reinforced by the Signs that shine forth like the sun and pile up so consistently that his prophethood becomes a self-evident reality. And, after this, if an error of judgment occurs on his part regarding some insignificant issues, it is not detrimental to the conviction granted to him. For instance, the human eye would not err in identifying the objects brought closer to a person or to the eye itself. In this case, the eye is sure to comprehend the nature of the objects and their size, and this understanding is invariably correct. Further, the courts of law accept the testimony based on such eyewitness accounts.

However, when an object is not lying nearby, for example, if a person is asked to identify an object of white colour from some distance, which is of a half or quarter of a mile, the person might mistake a man clad in white clothes to be a white horse; or for that matter, he might confuse a white horse with a man dressed in white clothes. Likewise, the Prophets and Messengers are enabled to perceive their claim and teachings so clearly and consistently that there remains no doubt about them. But, matters of lesser significance, which are not related to the chief objectives of the Prophet, are viewed by the spiritual eye in a way as if they are lying at some distance. What is more, they are not disclosed quite often. And, this is the reason why the spiritual eye at times misperceives them. The misperceptions on the part of Hadrat ‘Isa, on whom be peace, were in reality of this very kind. However, he had no misperception regarding his claim of being a Prophet, for its authenticity had been impressed upon him from a close distance and repeatedly.

Maulawi Sanaullah is involved also in this other mistake that he puts contradictory traditions before everyone. The very same fault lies with his mentor, Maulawi Muhammad Husain. And at every place where the issue of the life and death of Hadrat ‘Isa is raised before them, they forthwith begin to quote a huge assortment of traditions from Sahih al-Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Jami‘ Tirmidhi, Sunan Ibn Majah, Sunan Abu Dawud, Sunan Nasa’i, Musnad Imam Ahmad, Tabarani, Mu‘jam Kabir, Nu‘aim Ibn Hammad, Mustadrak Hakim, Sahih Ibn Khuzaimah, Nawadir-ul- Usul Tirmidhi, Abu Dawud Tayalisi, Ahmad, Musnad al-Firdaus, Ibn ‘Asakir, Kitab al-Wafa Ibn Jauzi, Sharh as-Sunnah Baghawi, Ibn Jarir, Baihaqi, Akhbar al-Mahdi, Musnad Abu Ya‘la, and certain other books of Hadith saying they all mention that ‘Isa will descend. Whether it would take place in Jerusalem or Damascus or on Mount Afiq or among an army of the Muslims is, however, still not decided. They cite this as the most complex issue today.

What is even more surprising is that some of the books mentioned above are so rare that even the fathers of these esteemed gentlemen would not have seen them. Yet, they keep mentioning these books so that the people may at least think of them as learned, scholarly men familiar with such a large corpus of literature. Alas, they act perfidiously. I now feel embarrassed to invoke the name of the Jews, for ‘Jews’ such as these are found only in Islam.

Only a few days have passed since Maulawi Muhammad Husain tried to ingratiate himself with the British Government by presenting to them a book regarding the Mahdi. The book says that not even a single hadith regarding the Mahdi can be proved as authentic. The author has also received a piece of land as reward for his services. I do not know what services he has rendered. But, one service that he has surely rendered to the government is that he has straight away rejected the very idea of the appearance of a Mahdi. May I ask him among whose army the Messiah would descend if there were to be no Mahdi at all? The assortment of the books listed above is mentioned only to establish that the Messiah would descend to support the cause of the Mahdi. But, why would he ever appear if there were to be no Mahdi at all? The Khalifah had to appear from among the Quraish, but this does not seem to be the case anymore.

I state justly that the traditions in the above-mentioned books are bipartite. One, which Maulawi Muhammad Husain has ruled out as inauthentic, pertains to the Mahdi. As for the second part, that pertains to the advent of the Messiah from Heaven. I will prove it inauthentic. When one of the two interdependent parts is rendered inauthentic, the other one necessarily becomes liable to revocation. ‘Isa [ Jesus] cannot be the Khalifah as he is not from the Quraish; as for the Mahdi, the Maulawi has himself done away with him. So why then should ‘Isa be burdened with returning to the world? For about 2,000 years now he has become accustomed to remaining idle and has become disposed to inaction. It would now be improper to bother him needlessly.

What is more, these ahadith contradict each other so greatly that if you were to try and find a hadith to oppose another, you could find it at once with no delay. Hence, to abandon the decisive statements of the Holy Qur’an thereby, and to ruin one’s faith by following such contradictory traditions, can only be the work of a fool, not of a wise person.

If ahadith held any weight despite being inconsistent with the Holy Qur’an, the traditions regarding Salat should have been given prime importance and should have had an unbroken chain of narrators. However, you have your differences and dissensions in this case as well. It is also not firmly established where exactly to position one’s folded arms [during Prayer]; further, the disagreements over whether or not to raise the hands, or to recite Surah al-Fatihah behind the imam, or to say amin aloud, and so on, continue to this day with different groups rejecting the traditions supporting the view held by others. If a Wahhabi were to practice rafa‘ yadain [i.e. raising both hands during various movements in prayer] in a Hanafi mosque and recite Surah al-Fatihah behind the imam and fold his arms against his chest and say amin aloud, he would definitely emerge therefrom beaten and thrashed, even if he were to present four hundred authentic traditions in support of his action. This proves that from the early times, the Hadith has not been accorded great prominence. Imam A‘zam [Imam Abu Hanifah (rta)], who lived before Imam Bukhari, does not care at all for the ahadith of Imam Bukhari. His was an age that was closer [to that of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him]. It should have been the case that those ahadith should have reached to him. It is, therefore, quite appropriate that the Holy Qur’an not be abandoned for the sake of the Hadith. To do so would put one at risk of losing one’s own faith:

Besides, if the verdict of the Hakam [Arbiter] is not to be accepted, then of what exactly is he the Hakam?

On the other hand, even if I am highly accommodating, I would bestow only the status of conjecture to these ahadith, and the same viewpoint is held by the Muhaddithin [scholars of the Hadith]. A conjecture is a statement that might have an element of falsehood in it. So what kind of prudence and righteousness would it be to have one’s beliefs based on conjecture and to do away with the authentic and categorical Word of God? I do not say all ahadith should be set aside like mere rubbish; rather, I say that you should accept those from among them to be authentic that do not oppose or contradict the Holy Qur’an, lest you be ruined.

It is not proven from any hadith that ‘Isa (as) would live up to two or three thousand years. Instead, it is recorded that he lived for 120 years. Now tell me, have those 120 years come to an end yet or not? In which hadith—that can be traced directly to the Holy Prophet s (as) and has an uninterrupted chain of narrators—can you find recorded that Hadrat ‘Isa, having torn apart the roof [of his house], ascended to Heaven, and that one of his disciples, or an enemy, was crucified in his place to become accursed? If the person was a disciple of ‘Isa, then, in view of the Torah, this believer became accursed as he was crucified. Can such an abominable act be ascribed to God? On the other hand, if the person was a Jewish man, why did he remain silent when he was being crucified? Had his wife and other relatives already passed away? Or was he dumb that he was unable to say anything to prove his innocence?

·

10 of 10 left today