Appendix to the Book Nuzulul-Masih
The Miracle of Ahmad, Part 9
Further, Maulawi Muhammad Husain, who is called an advocate for those who believe in the Unity of God, has written in his journal Isha‘atus-Sunnah—in which he penned a review of Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya—that those who are granted an audience with the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, in a vision, are not bound to follow the opinion of the Muhaddithin. By way of their visions, they declare certain ahadith to be maudu‘ [inauthentic], despite the fact that the Muhaddithin consider them to be sahih [authentic]. And they consider certain ahadith to be authentic based on the testimony of their visions, whereas they are maudu‘ according to the Muhaddithin. When this is the case, why is Maulawi Muhammad Husain so angry with the person who has claimed to be the Promised Messiah and the Arbiter, as to not even consider his vision to be equal to the vision of others even though it is in accord with the Holy Qur’an? The statement of the latter should be accepted as his vision is consistent with the Holy Qur’an and is also supported by certain ahadith. Otherwise, of what benefit is it to name the Promised Messiah Hakam [Arbiter]?
Some cunning maulawis go so far as to say that even if someone descends from Heaven and declares inauthentic this or that hadith which they consider to be sahih, they will never accept his verdict; rather, they will slap him in the face. In answer to this one can only say: ‘Yes! This is what is expected of you!’ However, I would hereby like to politely ask such people to explain to me the meaning of the term Hakam that has appeared in Sahih al-Bukhari regarding the Promised Messiah. I have always understood the term ‘Hakam’ to refer to a person whose verdict is accepted to settle differences, and whose decision is seen as final even if he has to dismiss thousands of ahadith as maudu‘.
The one who will come from God will certainly not come to be slapped around by you. God Almighty will Himself open the way for him. The person who is blessed by God with visions and revelations, and at whose hands God has manifested very great Signs, and whom God has shown a certain course that is in accord with the Holy Qur’an, why should he abandon such a bright and certain path on account of a few conjectural traditions? And is it not incumbent upon him to act upon what God has bestowed upon him, and reject the ahadith that he finds inconsistent with the pure revelation of God, especially when the revelation received by him is in accord with the Holy Qur’an and when he also finds some other ahadith in support of his viewpoint? And will he not acknowledge only those ahadith to be true as are in line with the Holy Qur’an and are not contradictory to the revelation received by him?
Indeed, I am amazed at the kind of disposition possessed by the worthy advocate: He acknowledges that in the past there have been auliya’ [friends of Allah] who, based on their meeting the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him [in their dreams], rejected certain so-called sahih traditions as inauthentic, and accepted inauthentic ones as sahih; however, he is reluctant to bestow this status upon the Promised Messiah as well, who is Hakam. And, I am amazed at the kind of followers he has. They do not question him that while other auliya’ were entitled to such authorities, why then does he hold the Hakam to be a kafir for [ruling on] these differences, and why does he not fear Allah. It is surprising that Maulawi Muhammad Husain lost his memory in this manner due to old age.
He has forgotten what was recorded in Isha‘atus-Sunnah and is now proclaiming something entirely different. My dear fellow! No judge is willing to hear dissent after consent. You have acknowledged that those to whom God shows visions and who have discourses with God occupy a lofty station and are not bound to follow the research made by Muhaddithin. The Muhaddithin relate from those who are dead, while those who are blessed with divine visions hear from the Living and Self-Subsisting God. Hence, how would you like to describe the status of the one who has been named Hakam? Don’t you think he has been granted the status that you assign to others?
Further, Maulawi Sanaullah asks me why I have taken into account the prophecy regarding the Promised Messiah asserting that surely this must have been done so on the basis of ahadith. This is why he then asks me why I do not accept other signs given in ahadith. These simpletons either say this on the basis of sheer fabrication or rank stupidity. In reply to this I swear by Almighty God that I have not based my claim on the Hadith; rather, I have based it on the Holy Qur’an and the revelation that has descended upon me. I do, however present in my favour those ahadith that are in accord with the Holy Qur’an and which do not oppose the revelation I have received. Other ahadith I discard as worthless. Even if there been no such thing as the Hadith in the world, my claim would not have been harmed in the least. But yes, God has presented the Holy Qur’an in His revelations to me in a number of places. Thus you will see in Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya that no hadith is quoted regarding my claim; rather, in my revelations Allah, the Exalted, has presented the Holy Qur’an on numerous occasions.
I believe that I have now provided sufficient answers to the deceptive objections raised by Maulawi Sanaullah in the debate at Mudh. However, I remember that he had also put forth the notion that the hadith that speaks of the solar and lunar eclipse being a Sign of the appearance of the Mahdi, which is recorded in Dar Qutni and Ikmalud-Din, pertains to a lunar eclipse that will take place on some day before the 13th of the lunar month and on a day when the moon can be labelled as qamar. It has to be remembered that this interpretation too is a kind of interpolation committed by the Jews. God has appointed three nights, in accordance with His practice, for the eclipse of the qamar. Similarly, there are three days appointed for the eclipse of the sun. The hadith mentions categorically that at the time of the advent of the Mahdi, the qamar would be eclipsed on the first of the nights appointed for it in the law of nature, while the sun would be eclipsed on the middle day of the days appointed for it by the practice of Almighty God. To discard such a straightforward meaning and wander around lost in other directions - if this is not misfortune what is it?
Apart from this, according to the Arabs, the night in which the hilal is called qamar is not any one specific night concerning which there should be no disagreement. Some say that the moon is hilal for only one night and that on the next night it becomes qamar. Some call the third night moon qamar. While to some the term hilal is applicable for as many as seven nights. Hence, while this is the situation, one cannot specify one specific night for the fulfilment of the prophecy.
And to say that the occurrence of the solar and lunar eclipse, in accordance with the practice of Almighty God, is not any extraordinary phenomenon is yet another act of stupidity. The actual purpose of this prophecy is not to promise the occurrence of an extraordinary phenomenon; the actual purpose is to set forth a Sign which no one else shares [with the Promised Messiah].
Hence, the Sign that has been mentioned in the Hadith is that at the time when the true Mahdi would make his claim, the qamar would be eclipsed in the month of Ramadan on the first night of the nights of the eclipse, and that such an incident would not have taken place ever before. Indeed, never in the time of a false Mahdi has a lunar or solar eclipse taken place on the said dates in the month of Ramadan. If it has taken place, it must be brought to light. Otherwise, while this situation is in itself extraordinary when seen in its entirety, why shall we interpret the prophecy to mean what is contradictory to the practice of Almighty God? What was intended was to show one Sign of the fulfilment of the prophecy, so that was fulfilled. If it has not been fulfilled, you ought to present a precedent of the occurrence of such an event from the annals of history. And, I would like to remind you that you will never be able to do so.