Part II—Arguments
Invitation to Ahmadiyyat, Part 18
One religious group that would seem to escape the brunt of this argument is the Sikh religion, and this is because Guru Nanak, the Founder of the Sikhs, appeared long after the Holy Prophet s (as). This is despite the fact that they, too, have a prophecy about a Reformer of the latter days, and it is clearly written that he would appear from around Batala. (Batala is the tehsil within which the village of Qadian is located, thus this prophecy has been literally fulfilled). The objection that might arise is how could the Sikh religion have been born after the Holy Prophets (as) if he was Khatamun-Nabiyyin? In order to reform the Sikh religion and to convert its members to Islam, Allah informed the Promised Messiah (as) through a dream that Guru Nanak was not the founder of a new religion but was in fact a sincere Muslim.
The reader will be amazed to learn that this seemingly strange claim was proven with such strong arguments that thousands of Sikhs accepted its truth. Sikhs, who had hitherto associated themselves with Hinduism, now started to vehemently distance themselves from that religion. Before the coming of the Promised Messiah (as), many Hindu idols would be found in Sikh Gurudwaras. After this claim by the Promised Messiah (as), while the Sikhs as a community did not accept Islam, there came about such a transformation in them that they started throwing out these idols from their Gurudwaras and began distancing themselves from Hinduism.
When the Promised Messiah (as) started researching the Sikh religion after his dream, he found that the Granth Sahib, the collection of the teachings of Baba Guru Nanak, contains strong exhortations for the five-daily prayers, the annual month of Ramadan, paying Zakat, performing the Hajj, as well as warnings for those who fail to observe these religious duties. It also appeared from Sikh literature that Guru Nanak Sahib used to visit Muslim saints, meditate at the tombs of past divines, and join Muslims in congregational prayers. He also performed the Hajj and visited Baghdad and other Muslims holy sites. Most important of all was the discovery of a cloak (Chola Sahib) worn by Baba Nanak Sahib which the Sikhs protect and adore as a relic. This cloak is covered with inscriptions of verses from the Holy Qur’an, such as Surah al-Ikhlas, Ayah al-Kursi, and the verse
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
‘Surely the true religion with Allah is Islam’. Even the Kalimah is written on it in bold letters. The Sikhs, being ignorant of Arabic, revered these writings as divine mysteries and failed to realize that they were Baba Nanak’s affirmations of his faith in Islam.
Armed with these arguments, derived from Sikh literature and relics, the Promised Messiah (as) started conveying to the Sikhs that Baba Nanak Sahib was a Muslim. This has to a great extent succeeded in bringing about a change among the Sikhs, and it is hoped that, as they become more and more cognizant of this fact, they will realize that they are but our lost brothers and that Islam is their true religion from which they deviated centuries ago because of political controversies. At the source of these controversies, as historical research has shown, were Hindus, not Muslims. We are hopeful that the Sikhs will not let this history be a barrier to accepting the true faith, that they will use their famed bravery to overcome all barriers and, raising the cry ‘Sat Sri Akal’ (‘Hail, the One True God’), join the ranks of Islam, and that they will accept the Reformer who appeared in the locality of Batala (according to their own prophecies) and join the community of believers in its struggle against unbelief and heresy.
The third means through which the Promised Messiah (as)
brought about the triumph of Islam, and in the presence of which no religion could stand up against Islam, was that he changed people’s notion of religious debate. Before the Promised Messiah (as), the way religious debates were held by and large was that each group would try to prove the Founder of the other group to be a liar. The Jews would say that Jesus was false, the Christians would say the same of the Holy Prophet s (as), the Zoroastrians would reject the Founders of all these three religions, and the followers of the three religions would in turn label the Prophets of the Zoroastrians as impostors, and then all the four together would label the Founders of other religions as untrue. Each group was thus at war with the other. Every sane person, seeing in every religion proofs for its truthfulness and yet finding every religion labelling the founder of every other religion as false, was left in a quandary.
Such disputes resulted in increased bias and antagonism. The Hindus would read about the lives of their Rishis and marvel at their great moral and spiritual qualities, and yet they heard followers of other religions say that these Rishis were liars and pretenders. Naturally, they were offended by this and thought that these people had been blinded by bias. Followers of other religions were equally horrified and angered to hear others denigrate their spiritual leaders. In short, an unsolvable dilemma had arisen that no one was able to solve. Those who examined the question without prejudice wondered how God could have chosen just one people and abandoned all the rest, but no one dared to openly raise this question, for it would destroy the very foundations of their religion.
Hindus solved this problem, in their own estimation, by saying that all religions originated from God and are like the many paths that lead to the same destination, but that the Hindu religion was the best of these paths. This solution was of no help either, for it was open to two serious objections. The first was that if all religions, as we find them today, are from God and lead ultimately to Him, why do they contain fundamental differences? There could be differences in matters of detail but how can there be differences in the fundamentals? Many roads may lead to a mansion but it would be absurd to think that roads coming from the east should reach it via the west or the north or the south. There can be minor divergences but the general direction should be the same. There can be no disparity in eternal truths. It may be understandable that God taught various people various modes of worship, but the sane mind cannot comprehend how He could say to one group ‘I am One’; to the other, ‘I am two’; and to a third that He is the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit; and to a fourth that Divine powers reside in thousands of idols; and to a fifth that everything is God; and to a sixth that God transcends all and cannot appear in material form; and to a seventh that He can incarnate into a human body; and to an eighth that He can adopt the guise of the lowest of creatures, even swine; and to a ninth that life after death is real; and to a tenth that there is no life after death; and to an eleventh that the dead do not return to this world; and to a twelfth that man keeps returning to this world in new incarnations. In short, while it is possible for God to reveal different commandments to different people, He could never teach them contradictory beliefs about eternal truths and verities. Since all religions, as they exist today, differ from one another not just in terms of their commandments but also in terms of eternal truths, it cannot be correct to say that they are different paths leading to the same God.
The second objection to the Hindu doctrine is that while they see their religion as superior to all the others, they also say that it is the most ancient religion. However, no sane mind can accept that God revealed the best religion first and lesser religions afterwards. If man, in his initial stages, had been able to receive and benefit from a perfect teaching, why would God reveal lesser religions later on when mankind had become more advanced in its knowledge and understanding? It is more reasonable to believe that the religion that comes afterwards is superior than, if not equal to, the religion that came before.
So formidable were these objections that the proponents of the doctrine could not answer them, and the question remained as to what provisions God had made for the guidance of mankind since the beginning of the world.
The Christian solution to the problem of conflicting religious beliefs was to contend that since God had invited the whole world towards guidance through Jesus Christ, the Christian faith could not be accused of bigotry. This solution also did not work as it did not answer the vital question of what were the means that God had adopted for the guidance of mankind before the coming of Jesus. The Bible tells us that Jesus came only for his own people and that his teachings were not for anyone else. Later Christians, however, opened the doors to others. Yet, the question remains as to what provisions had God made for guiding millions of people who had lived before him?
The question remained unanswered and was inwardly gnawing at people’s minds when the Promised Messiah (as) turned to the
Holy Qur’an for an answer and changed the very outlook of the world regarding this issue. The Holy Qur’an says:
There is no people to whom a warner has not come.
That is to say, God’s Messengers came to every country and every people. We do not say that India did not have Prophets, or Africa did not have Prophets, or Europe did not have Prophets, or America was without Prophets, nor do we hear of the spiritual founders of other religions and consider them to be false, for we have been told that Prophets have come to every people. The fact that Prophets and Divine laws and scriptures are found among other peoples and nations does not contradict our beliefs in any way. Indeed, this testifies to the truth of our religion.
We do, however, believe that while in the past God sent Messengers to various nations and peoples according to their specific requirements, later, when man became capable of receiving the perfect Guidance, God revealed it through the Holy Prophets (as) and sent him as a Messenger to the whole world. In this way, no people were ever deprived of Divine guidance. Today, Islam alone is the path of guidance, for it is the final and perfect teaching and all past teachings were abrogated with its coming. A sign of the abrogation of past teachings is that God no longer safeguards them and they constantly suffer from human interpolation. They have deviated far from the truth and are beyond recognition. They are true in terms of their origin but are false in the form that we see them today.