Part II—Arguments
Invitation to Ahmadiyyat, Part 19
No one can disagree with this outlook presented by the
Promised Messiah (as), because, otherwise, we will have to believe that God sent His guidance only to some people and left others without guidance. No sane mind can accept this. On the other hand, if they accept this outlook, they will have to accept the truth of Islam as well because Islam is the final religion and because it was Islam that presented this true concept to the world.
This was such an amazing discourse that the educated classes and broad-minded people, regardless of which religion they belonged to, could not help but be moved by it. If they were to abandon the principle presented by the Promised Messiah (as), they would have to abandon God as well, which they could not do. If they did accept this principle, they would have no recourse but to accept Islam at the same time.
Thus, by changing the world’s past conception, which was extremely myopic, the Promised Messiah (as) provided us with a powerful means to guarantee the supremacy of Islam.
The fourth tool given to the Promised Messiah (as), which transformed the whole debate around Islam and completely dazed its opponents, was that, having received guidance from God, he changed the very course of contemporary religious literature and prescribed certain principles around it which the opponents could not deny, and if they did accept them then they could not hold their own against Islam. They were vanquished either way. They could find no safety either in fight or flight.
Before the Promised Messiah (as), the way religious debates were held was that one side could raise all kinds of objections against the other and make whatever claims of its own. A debate held in such an unconstrained fashion could never produce real results. Even when horses run against each other, they have to run according to some rules, only then can the winner be judged. If one horse runs this way and the other that way, how would anyone know which one has won? In the same way, no opinion can be drawn from religious debate and scrutiny unless it is undertaken within some limits.
Also, before the coming of the Promised Messiah (as), anyone who came across some great teaching or read it in a book would at once ascribe it to his own religion and present it as proof of its excellence. There would be no real debate on religion, instead, scholars and debaters would merely talk about their personal beliefs and opinions. Consequently, seekers after truth were unable to decide between the various religions. The Promised Messiah (as) explicitly demonstrated the futility of this form of debating. He laid down the principle that if a Divine scripture has been revealed for our guidance then it must contain everything that it wants us to believe, as well as the reasons why we should do so. Of what good is the Word of God if it contains neither the claims nor the arguments for its teachings? In that case, the religion could not be said to have come from God; it would be of our own making since we are the ones who are suggesting its claims as well as providing the arguments to support them. When discussing any religion, it should be ensured that all the claims that the proponents of that religion make can be found in their respective scriptures. The same goes for the proofs and arguments that they put forth.
This was such a solid principle that advocates of other religions could never reject it. If they did, they would in effect be admitting that the claims they make on behalf of their religion are not to be found in their scriptures. And, if the claims are to be found in the scriptures, then why are the arguments missing from them? God has fashioned the human mind in such a way that he does not accept anything without proof or reason. How is it possible then that God should expect us to believe His teachings without giving us arguments to convince us of their truth? Non-Muslims could not reject this principle; if they did so they would be admitting that their respective religions were not worth believing in. The reason, which might surprise you, dear reader, is that when this principle was applied to other religions it was found that almost 90% of their claims could not be found in their respective scriptures. As for the claims that were found in the scriptures, almost 100% were without accompanying arguments. Are we to believe that God taught man something and then left him to prove and defend it on his own?
In this manner, the Promised Messiah (as) demonstrated that advocates of different religions invented beliefs or borrowed ideas from here and there and attributed them to their own religions, and thus wasted people’s time in trying to prove the superiority of their religions based on such beliefs. Even if they can manage to prove that their opinion about a matter is correct, this would not necessarily mean that their religion is also true because that concept is not found in their revealed scriptures. In contrast to this, the Promised Messiah (as) proved that all Islamic teachings are derived from the Holy Qur’an and that it also provides proofs and arguments for the truth of these teachings. The Promised Messiah (as) made this as clear as day by presenting the teachings of the Holy Qur’an on hundreds of topics along with their arguments, thereby completely humbling the opponents of Islam. They were so dispirited that to this day they have not found a way to counter this point, nor will they ever do so. This theological discourse is so perfect and superior that it cannot be rejected, nor can falsehood be upheld in its presence. As this criterion is employed more and more, advocates of false religions will withdraw from the field of religious debate, the vulnerability of these religions will become further apparent to their followers, and the world will witness the fulfilment of God’s promise that Islam will triumph over all religions.
The fifth method adopted by the Promised Messiah (as) was such that it completely humbled other religions and gave Islam superiority that no one can deny. The Promised Messiah (as) addressed the opponents of Islam and stressed that the true purpose of any religion is to establish a relationship between man and God; hence, only that religion would be considered true and chosen by God for this age that can establish this relationship and produce demonstrable signs of it. We know from our daily experience that everything, no matter how small, has an effect. If we touch fire, we get burnt. When we sit close to the fire, we feel its heat. Drinking water not only slakes our thirst but also brings life and freshness to our faces. If we start eating rich foods, we gain weight. If we exercise more, our body gets stronger and we have more energy. Likewise, all medicines have healing or adverse effects. Given all this, it would be strange if one’s connection with God had no effect whatsoever, and that even if one prays and prostrates for unbearably long periods of time, or observes fasting to the point of death, or gives charity to the end of one’s resources, one will still experience no transformation in one’s life and all these actions will produce no results. If this were indeed the case, why then would we need God at all? If we have a connection with a minor ruler, we observe the effects of this in that we are honoured in his presence, his subordinates respect us, our petitions are heard, our problems solved, and everyone can see that we are close and dear to that ruler. How then is it possible that we should have a relationship with God but it should have no effect on us or on our relationships and we should remain the same as before?
The Promised Messiah (as) demonstrated that a living religion is to be recognized by the fact that its followers can reach God and attain His nearness, and that those who have attained such nearness should possess some distinguishing signs. Therefore, instead of attacking one another, followers of the various religions should focus on providing proof of their own spiritual life and vitality and provide examples of individuals among them who, by observing the precepts of their religion, have attained nearness to God. Any religion which lives up to this criterion should then be accepted, and one that does not should be thrown away like a dead body that cannot support anyone and itself requires support. Such a religion will do more harm than good because it disgraces its followers in this world and leads them to damnation in the next.
This was a proposition that no reasonable person could question. It fell like lightning on the followers of other religions and they started looking for ways to save face. The Promised Messiah (as) proclaimed that only Islam possesses the signs of spiritual life and vitality and no other religion comes anywhere near it. He invited anyone who thought otherwise to come forward and take up the challenge but, despite repeated reminders, no one came forward. How could they do so when they had nothing to present. If it were a matter of shouting at the top of their voices and vociferously claiming that their religion is the true one, a thousand people would have come forward; but when they needed to prove their love for God and show signs thereof, they were unable to do so. Love of God is another matter, these people do not even have a superficial connection with God, how then could they present any proof of it?
The Promised Messiah (as) extended this challenge to the Hindus, Christians, Jews, and people of other religions, but nobody took it up. In different ways and on various occasions he tried to arouse their sense of honour so that they would accept the challenge, but to no avail. He invited the Bishop of Lahore to compete with him in the acceptance of prayer. He said that it was promised in the New Testament that if one has faith even as little as a mustard seed, one will be able to move mountains, and that our books also contain the promise of help for the believers and acceptance of their prayers, therefore, let the Bishop come forward and let us find out whose prayers are heard more, whether of those who lead their lives according to Islam or those who follow the Christian teachings. This challenge was offered repeatedly but the Bishop remained silent. Indeed, his silence was so strange that even some British newspapers criticised him and asked why people who drew fat salaries and made loud claims fail to come forward when they are challenged. Neither Christians nor anyone else tried to convince the Bishop to come forward, and so he kept avoiding it with one excuse or another.
The Promised Messiah (as) kept throwing such challenges at the opponents of Islam but no one dared accept them. This criterion, again, is such that it will have a deep impact on every man of reason and understanding. As people continue to realize the ineffectiveness of their own religions and the efficacy of Islam, the truth of Islam will become even more evident to them. In debates, one might be able to make up things to eclipse the truth, but the mind accepts no excuses when it actually observes the effects of something and it finally succumbs to the truth.