Chapter One
Jesus In India, Part 5
Here it is also worth remembering that in the statement contained in the said verse, namely, that at that time all the nations of the earth would mourn, the word ‘earth’ means Bilaad-e-Sham1 with which these three peoples are basically connected—Jews, because that is their place of origin and their place of worship; Christians, because Jesus, the Messiah, appeared in that place, and the first Christian peoples came into being in this very place; Muslims, because they are the heirs of this land to the Last Day. And if the word ‘earth’ is taken to embrace all lands, even then it presents no difficulty, for when the truth is laid bare every denier would be ashamed.
And from among the testimonies that have reached us through the Gospels, is this statement from the Gospel of Matthew that is written herein below:
And the graves were opened; and many bodies of the saints which slept arose, and came out of the graves after his res-
urrection (that is to say after the resurrection of Jesus, the
Messiah) and went into the holy city, and appeared unto
There is not the slightest doubt that this story that is mentioned in the Gospel that after the resurrection of Jesus, the Messiah, the people came out of the graves and appeared alive to many, is not the recounting of any historical incident that took place; for, had it been so, the Judgment Day would verily have manifested in this very world, and those matters that had been kept hidden from the world as a test of faith and sincerity would have been made apparent and evident to all. Faith would not have remained faith, and, in the sight of every believer and denier, the nature of the next world would have become an evident and open fact, like the existence of the moon, the sun, and the alternation of day and night. In that case, faith would no longer be that valuable and worthwhile thing, possessing which could give one hope of receiving a reward.
If the people and past prophets of Israel whose number reaches into the hundreds of thousands, had really been brought to life at the time of the crucifixion and had in fact come back to the city alive; and if this miracle, that hundreds of prophets and hundreds of thousands of saintly people were all brought to life at the same time, was really shown to prove the truth and divinity of Jesus, the Messiah, the Jews would have had an excellent opportunity to inquire of their prophets, saints, and other ancestors, whether Jesus, the Messiah, who claimed to be God was indeed God, or was he a liar! One can easily imagine that they could not have missed this welcome opportunity. They must have inquired as to what type of person this was, for the Jews were very keen to compare notes with the dead if they could be restored to life. Thus, when, hundreds of thousands of the dead were restored to life, and flocked to every street in the city in their thousands, how could the Jews have let go of such an opportunity? They must have inquired, not from one or two, but from thousands; and when the dead entered their respective houses there must have been great commotion all over the place, for many hundreds of thousands of them had been brought back to life. In every house there must have been great excitement, and everybody must have been questioning the dead as to whether the man Jesus, who called himself the Messiah, was really God. But because the Jews, after the testimony of the dead, did not believe in Jesus, the Messiah, as we would expect them to do, nor did their hearts soften, rather if anything, they became confirmed in their hard-heartedness, it appears more than probable that the dead did not speak a single favourable word for him. They must have pronounced straight away that this man was making a false claim to Godhood, and was lying against God.
That must have been why the Jews did not desist from mischief in spite of the fact that hundreds of thousands of men, indeed prophets and apostles had been restored to life. Having ‘killed’ Jesus, the Messiah, they attempted to kill all others. How can one believe that hundreds of thousands of saints who, right from the time of Adam up to the time of John the Baptist, had been resting in their graves in this holy land, should all be brought back to life; that they should all flock to the city to preach, and everyone of them should stand up and testify before thousands of people that Jesus, the Messiah, was really the Son of God—no, God Himself; that he alone should be worshipped; that the people should renounce their former beliefs, otherwise, they would go to hell, which these saints had witnessed for themselves! Yet, notwithstanding such excellent evidence and such eyewitness accounts which proceeded from the mouths of hundreds of thousands of dead saints, the Jews should not desist from their denial! My own conscience is certainly not prepared to accept this. Therefore, if hundreds of thousands of saints, prophets and apostles, etc., who were dead, had really come to life and had visited the city to give evidence, they must undoubtedly have given unfavourable evidence; they could never have borne witness to the divinity of Jesus, the Messiah. This must have been the reason why the Jews became more firmly entrenched in their disbelief after listening to the evidence of the dead. Jesus, the Messiah, wanted them to believe in his divinity, but they, because of this evidence, denied that he was even a prophet.
In short, such beliefs have a highly deleterious and unhealthy effect, namely, to say that hundreds of thousands of dead persons, or any dead person before that time, had been brought back to life by Jesus, the Messiah; for the restoration to life of the dead did not serve any beneficent purpose. This is a part of human nature that if a person goes to visit a far-off country and comes back to his hometown after several years of absence, he is naturally keen to tell the people of his wonderful experiences of that country, and to relate to them the wondrous of wonderful stories of the land he has visited. He will not keep mum or remain tongue-tied when he meets his people after a long period of separation. No, at such a time, others also are keen to listen to him and question him about the far off places; and if perchance, there comes to these people some poor and lowly person, humble in appearance, who yet claims to be the king of the country of which the principal town has already been visited by these people and who says that he is superior in his kingly rank even to this and that king, the people are always wont to question such itinerants whether the man, going about in their country, is really the king of that land; to which question these travellers reply to the best of their knowledge. This being so, the bringing of the dead to life by Jesus, the Messiah, would have been, as I have stated before, worth believing in, if the evidence on which the dead must have been questioned, which was but natural, had led to some beneficial result. However, this was not at all the case. Therefore, along with the supposition that the dead were brought back to life, one is compelled to suppose that the dead did not give evidence favourable to Jesus, the Messiah, which could lead one to believe in his truth. They rather gave evidence which added to the already existing confusion.
Would that instead of human beings, mention had been made of bringing back to life some quadrupeds, for then much could have been kept hidden. For example, if it had been said that Jesus had brought back to life several thousand bullocks, it would have been ‘reasonable’ enough, and, if the question was asked as to what the evidence of these dead animals had led to, the answer would have been easy: how could the mute bullocks testify one way or the other? The dead, however, whom Jesus, the Messiah, brought back to life, were human beings. Suppose some of the Hindus were asked if ten or twenty of their dead ancestors were restored to life and brought back to this world and were asked to state which religion was the true religion, would they still have any doubt about the truth of that religion? They would never say no. Therefore, take it for a certainty that there is no man in the whole world who would persist in his disbelief and denial after such a disclosure. What a pity that in inventing such stories, the Sikhs of our country have fared better than the Christians. The Sikhs have given proof of their astuteness in the art of inventing stories; for they state that their Guru, Bawa Nanak, once restored a dead elephant to life. This ‘miracle’ is not open to the above objection, for the Sikhs can say: the elephant had no tongue to bear witness for or against Bawa Nanak. In short, the common people, endowed with little intellect, are pleased with such ‘miracles’, but the wise are embarrassed by the objections raised by others and are put to shame in whichever assembly such silly stories are related. Now, as I bear the same feelings of love and sincerity towards Jesus, the Messiah, may peace be on him, as do the Christians; rather, I have a stronger attachment to him, for Christians do not know the man whom they praise, but I know him whom I praise, for I have as good as seen him.
Therefore, I now proceed to unveil the real nature of the reports contained in the Gospels that at the time of the crucifixion all dead saints had come back to life and returned to the city.
Let it, therefore, be clearly understood that accounts like these are of the nature of [visions] that were seen by some holy men after the crucifixion, in which they saw that the dead saints had been brought back to life and graced the city where they met the people. Just as dreams mentioned in divine scriptures are interpreted, for instance, Joseph’s dream, this vision too had an interpretation of its own. The interpretation was that Jesus had not died on the cross and that God had rescued him. If the question is asked as to the rationale behind this interpretation, the answer is that experts in the art of interpretation testify to its validity and have borne witness to it on the basis of their experience. I quote below from T‘atirul-Anam, a time honoured authority on the art of interpretation of dreams.
See the book T‘atirul-Anam fi T‘abiril-Manam, by Qutb-
Translation: If someone has a dream or a vision that the dead have come out of their graves and have made for their homes, the interpretation is that a prisoner would be released from bondage, and that he would be rescued from the hands of his persecutors. The context shows that
this prisoner would be a great and prominent personage.
Now, it should be noted how appropriately this interpretation applies to Jesus, the Messiah, may peace be on him.
One can readily understand that the vision about the dead saints coming to life and returning to the city was meant
to inform those with insight that Jesus, the Messiah, would be saved from death on the cross.
Likewise, the Gospels at a number of places clearly point out that Jesus, the Messiah, may peace be on him, did not die on the cross and that he escaped and migrated to another land. I think what I have said so far should suffice for the fair minded to understand the true position.