Chapter One
Jesus In India, Part 6
It is possible that objections may arise in some minds that the Gospels also repeatedly point out that Jesus, the Messiah, may peace be on him, died on the cross, and that after resurrection he rose to heaven. This kind of objection I have already briefly answered, but I think it appropriate to mention now also that after the crucifixion, Jesus, may peace be on him, met the disciples; he travelled up to Galilee; ate bread and meat; displayed the wounds on his body; stayed a night with the disciples at Emmaus; escaped secretly from Pilate’s jurisdiction; emigrated from that place, as was the practice of prophets; and travelled under the shadow of fear. All these facts prove that he did not die on the cross; that he retained his mortal body together with all its needs and functions intact; and that he had undergone no visible change.
Furthermore, the Gospels do not contain any eyewitness account of the ascent to heaven.٭1 Even if there had been such an account, it would have lacked credibility, for making mountains out of molehills and magnifying small things into big ones, seems to be a habit with the evangelists. For example, if one of them happens to remark that Jesus, the Messiah, is the Son of God, another sets about making him into a full-fledged God, the third invests him with power over the whole universe, and the fourth bluntly says that he is everything, and that there is no other God besides him. In short, exaggerations carry them too far. The vision in which the dead were seen to come out of their graves and make for the city is a case in point. One can notice that this vision had been given a literal interpretation, so far as to say that the dead had actually risen out of their graves, had come to the city of Jerusalem, and even visited their relatives. Consider how an entire crow has been fabricated from a single feather, and that single crow did not so remain, for from it were made to fly hundreds of thousands of crows! Where such exaggeration is employed, how can one arrive at the truth! It is also worth considering that these Gospels, which are called the Books of God, contain preposterous claims, such as that if all the works of Jesus, the Messiah, had been committed to writing, there would not be room enough in the whole world to accommodate them!2 Can such exaggeration be the way of honesty and truth? If indeed the works of Jesus, the Messiah, were so limitless and exceeded all boundaries, how could they have been compressed into a meagre period of three years? Another defect that these Gospels suffer from is that some references they give of earlier books are wrong. They could not even write down the genealogy of Jesus, the Messiah, correctly.
From the Gospels, it appears that these noble people were rather naive to the extent that some mistook Jesus, the Messiah, for a ghost. And from the earliest times these Gospels have been open to the charge that they have not been able to preserve the purity of their texts, particularly when there were many other books too which were compiled as Gospels. Thus there is no solid reason why all the statements of those books should be rejected, and why all that is contained in the Gospels, generally so-called, should be admitted as true. We do not think that the other Gospels could contain such unfounded exaggerations as are to be found in the present four Gospels. It is strange that while on the one hand, it is said in these books that Jesus, the Messiah, was a righteous person and that his character was without blemish, yet on the other hand, such charges are heaped upon him as are not at all befitting the station and eminence of a righteous person. For example, the Israelite prophets, in accordance with the teaching of the Torah, undoubtedly had hundreds of wives each at a time in order that they might thereby produce a whole generation of righteous people. But you will never have heard that any prophet had ever set such an example of permissiveness that he should allow a wanton and lascivious woman, a noted sinner of the city, to touch his body with her hands, to let her rub oil—her sin’s earnings—on his head and to stroke his feet with her hair; that he allowed all this to be done by an unchaste young woman, and did not so much as tell her to stop it. One is saved from giving way to suspicion, which naturally arises on seeing such a spectacle, only by the blessing of thinking good. Nevertheless, this example can be of no benefit to others.
In short, these Gospels are full of material which shows that they have not preserved their original form, or that their writers were other than the disciples or their pupils. For example, can this statement from the Gospel of Matthew: ‘And this is well known among the Jews till today’1 be properly and correctly said to have been written by Matthew? Does it not show that the writer of this Gospel of Matthew was some other person, who lived at a time when Matthew had already died? Then, in this same Gospel of Matthew in Chapter 28, verses 12-13 it is written:
And when they were assembled with the elders, and had taken counsel, they gave large money unto the soldiers, Saying, ‘Say ye, his disciples came by night and stole him away while we slept. Notice how childish and meaningless these statements are. If it is meant by this that the Jews wanted to conceal the rising of Jesus, the Messiah, from the dead, and have, therefore, bribed the soldiers so that this great miracle should not become generally known, why was it that Jesus, the Messiah, whose duty it was to proclaim this miracle among the Jews, kept it a secret and forbade even others to disclose it? If it is said that he was afraid of being caught, I would say, that when the decree of God Almighty, had descended upon him once and for all, and he had, after suffering death, come to life again, assuming a glorious body, what fear did he now have of the Jews? Surely, the Jews could not now have any power over him; he was now beyond and above mortal existence? One observes with regret that while, on the one hand, it is said that he was made to live again and assume a glorious body, that he met the disciples and went to Galilee and thence went to heaven, yet the fear of the Jews prevails over quite trivial things and, in spite of his glorious body, he fled secretly from the country, lest some Jews should discover him; he made a journey of 70 koses to Galilee in order to save his life and time and again asked the people not to mention this to others. Are these the signs and ways of a glorious body? No, the truth is that his body was neither new nor glorious, it was the same body with wounds on it, which had been saved from death; and as there was still the fear of the Jews, Jesus, the Messiah, took all the necessary precautions and left the country.
All the things that are said contrary to this are, one and all, senseless and absurd; as that the Jews had bribed the soldiers to make them say that the disciples had stolen the corpse while they (the soldiers) were asleep. If the soldiers were asleep, they could very well have been asked how on earth they came to know in their sleep that the corpse of Jesus, the Messiah, had been stolen away. And from the mere fact of Jesus, the Messiah, not being in the sepulchre, can a sensible person conclude that he had gone up to heaven? Are there, in this world, no other causes, as a result of which, tombs might be found empty? It was the responsibility of Jesus, the Messiah, to provide proof of this; such that, on his way to heaven, he should have met a few hundred Jews, and also Pilate. Who was he afraid of in his glorious body? But he did not care to furnish his opponents with the slightest proof. On the contrary, he took fright and fled to Galilee. That is why we positively and certainly believe and accept that though it is true that he left the sepulchre, which was a chamber with an opening, and though it is also true that he secretly met the disciples, yet it is not true at all that he was given any new and glorious body. It was the same body, and the same wounds, and there was the same fear in his heart lest the accursed Jews should arrest him again. Just study closely Matthew 28:7–10. In these verses it is clearly written that the women who were told by someone that Jesus, the Messiah, was alive and was going to Galilee, and who were also quietly told that they should inform the disciples, were no doubt pleased to hear this, but they departed with hearts full of fear. In other words, they were still afraid lest Jesus, the Messiah, might even now be caught by some wicked Jew.
And in verse 9 it is said that while these women were on their way to inform the disciples, Jesus, the Messiah, met and greeted them with the greeting of peace. And in verse 10 it is said that Jesus, the Messiah, told them not to be afraid, that is to say do not be afraid of me being caught, but tell my brothers that they should go to Galilee;٭1 that they would see me there, i.e., he could not stay here for fear of the enemies. In short, if Jesus, the Messiah, had really come to life after his death and had assumed a glorious body, it was up to him to furnish proof of this new kind of existence to the Jews. But we know that he did not discharge this duty of providing such proof.
It is absurd, therefore, to accuse the Jews of trying to suppress the proof of Jesus, the Messiah, coming back to life again. The fact is that Jesus, the Messiah, himself failed to provide the slightest proof of his restoration to life; rather, by his running and hiding, and by the fact of his taking food, and sleeping, and showing his wounds, he himself proved that he did not die on the cross.