Evidence from Buddhist History Records
Jesus In India, Part 3
And from among the testimonies which we have found in the religious books of the Buddhists, there is one recorded by Sir Monier Williams, on page 45 of his book Buddhism. He says that the sixth disciple of the Buddha was a man named ‘Yasa.’3 This word seems to be an abbreviation of the word Yasu. As Jesus, the Messiah, may peace be on him, was born five hundred years after the death of the Buddha, sometime in the sixth century, he was called the sixth disciple. It should be noted that Professor Max Muller, on page 517 of the October 1894 issue of his periodical The Nineteenth Century, supports the aforesaid statement and says that established and renowned writers have pointed out many a time that Jesus, the Messiah, was influenced by the principles of Buddhism and that attempts are being made even today to discover some historical route along which the principles of the Buddha’s faith could be proved to have reached Palestine in the days of Jesus, the Messiah.1 This observation by Max Muller corroborates the Buddhist records in which it is claimed in as many words that Yasa was the disciple of the Buddha. When Christians of such repute as Professor Max Muller admit that the principles of Buddhism had certainly influenced Jesus, the Messiah, it would not be far wrong to say that this would amount to his being a disciple of the Buddha. Nevertheless, we consider the use of such a title in respect of Jesus, the Messiah, disrespectful and impertinent. The statement found in the Buddhist literature that Yasu was the disciple of the Buddha, is only an example of the age-old habit of Buddhist priests to designate a great personage appearing at a later date as if he were the disciple of his prototype. Apart from this, as has been pointed out, there being great resemblance between the teachings of Jesus, the Messiah, and those of the Buddha, it would not be wrong to speak of their relationship as that of the master and the disciple, though such thinking is very irreverent.
Nevertheless, we do not approve of the way the European investigators are eager to prove that the teachings of Buddhism had reached Palestine in the days of Jesus, the Messiah. It is, indeed, regrettable that when the name and mention of Jesus, the Messiah, are found in the ancient books of Buddhism, these investigators should adopt the dubious course of trying to find traces of Buddha’s faith in Palestine. Why do they not search for the blessed footprints of Jesus, the Messiah, in the mountains of Nepal, Tibet, and Kashmir? I know, however, that these researchers could never be expected to uncover the truth which was lying hidden under a thousand veils of darkness; it was for God to do it. He watched from on high that man-worship was running rampant the world over, and worship of the cross and the fictional sacrifice of a human being had alienated the hearts of tens of millions of people from the true God. It was then that His sense of Honour and care for what is sacred, holy and inviolable, made Him send into the world His servant, in the spirit of Jesus, the Messiah, of Nazareth, to demolish the creed of the cross. And he did come as the Promised Messiah in accordance with the prophecies of old. Then at long last came the time for the breaking of the cross, that is to say, the time when the error of the creed of the cross was to be manifested with perfect clarity quite like splitting one piece of wood into two. Thus, heaven has now thrown open the way for the demolition of the cross, so let every seeker after truth now get up and search. True, [the belief in] the physical ascension to heaven of Jesus, the Messiah, was a mistake but there was still a mystery within it.
And that was that the reality of the life of the Messiah, that had been forgotten and lost, as a corpse is eaten up by the earth and is no more; that reality had an existence of its own in heaven, and was present in heaven like a physical human being. And it was essential that that reality should again descend in the latter days. Thus that Messianic reality has now descended in the form of a physical human being and it has broken the cross. And the evil habits of deception and worship of falsehood - which our Holy Prophet had likened unto the swine, in a hadith about the cross—have been torn into pieces by the breaking of the cross just as a swine is cut down by a sword. It is wrong to interpret this hadith to mean that the Promised Messiah would kill the infidels and physically break crosses. In reality, the breaking of the cross means that at that time, the God of Heaven and Earth would manifest such a hidden reality as would, all of a sudden, result in the breaking up of the entire structure of the cross. And by the killing of swine is not meant the killing of men, or of swine, but the killing of swinish habits, that is to say, to persist in falsehood and promote it incessantly, which is like the eating of excrement. Thus, just as a dead swine cannot eat filth, so, the time is fast approaching—in fact, it has already come—when those possessing evil habits would be prevented from such gorging on filth. Muslim clerics, the Ulama, have been grossly mistaken in the interpretation of this prophecy of the Holy Prophet. The true meanings of the breaking of the cross and of the killing of the swine are the ones we have mentioned. It is indeed also written that religious wars would come to an end in the time of the Promised Messiah, and such bright truths will be manifested from the heaven as would display a brilliant distinction between the truth and falsehood.
Do not think, therefore, that I have come to wield the sword. No, I have come to put all swords back into their sheaths. The world has grappled much in the dark, many attacked their sincere well-wishers and caused pain to the hearts of their compassionate friends, and wounded their dear ones. But now darkness shall not remain. The night is gone and the day has dawned. And blessed is he who no longer remains deprived!!
And from among the testimonies which we have found in Buddhist books is the testimony mentioned on page 419 of the book, ‘Buddhism’ by Oldenberg. It is recorded on the authority of the book named Mahavagga (page 54 section 1) that a man called Rahulta1 was a successor to the Buddha. This Rahulta has been described not only as his devoted disciple, but also as his son. Here I make the claim that this Rahulta which appears in the books of Buddhism is simply a corruption of the name, ‘Ruhullah,’ which is one of the titles of Jesus, may peace be on him. And the story that Rahulta was the son of the Buddha, whom he abandoned in his infancy, and went to some other land; that furthermore, intending to part company forever, he fled to some other land leaving his wife asleep without informing her or saying farewell; this story appears altogether absurd and derogatory and contradictory to the high station of the Buddha. It portrays him as a cruel-natured and hard-hearted man who had no compassion for his helpless wife and left her asleep and slunk away like a thief without saying a word of consolation to her. He altogether ignored the duties he owed to her as a husband, neither divorcing her nor asking her permission to proceed on an endless journey, wounded her heart by disappearing so suddenly and did not care to send her even a single letter and took no pity on his child who grew up to manhood in his absence. A man such as this who had no respect even for the morals he taught his disciples could never be righteous? Conscience refuses to accept this story, just as it refuses to accept the story of the Gospels that once Jesus, the Messiah, failed to show regard for his mother, that he did not attend to her when she called on him and uttered words which were disrespectful.
So although the two stories about hurting the feelings of a wife and a mother have a mutual resemblance, yet we cannot ascribe such stories as do not size up to the lowest level of moral conduct either to Jesus, the Messiah, or to Gautama Buddha. If the Buddha did not love his wife, had he no pity on a helpless woman and her suffering child either? It is so serious a lapse of moral conduct that I am shocked even to think of this story which is hundreds of years old and belongs to the dead past. Why at all should he have behaved like this? To be a bad man, it is enough to be callous towards one’s wife, unless she no longer remains virtuous and obedient, or becomes faithless, malevolent, and a threat to one’s life. We cannot, therefore, ascribe such offensive behaviour to the Buddha, which goes against his own teachings. All this shows that the story is false. In point of fact, ‘Rahulta’ means Jesus, the Messiah, may peace be on him, whose other name is Ruhullah. The word Ruhullah in Hebrew comes close to Rahulta, and Rahulta, or, Ruhullah, has been described as a disciple of the Buddha because, as I have already stated, Jesus, the Messiah, came after the Buddha and brought a teaching similar to that of the Buddha. That is why the followers of the Buddhist faith declared that the Buddha was the source of the teachings of Jesus, the Messiah, and that Jesus, the Messiah, was one of his disciples. It should also not be surprising if the Buddha, on the basis of revelation from God Almighty, should have declared Jesus, the
Messiah, to be his ‘son.’ Another important piece of circumstantial evidence in this regard is that in the same book it is recorded that when the infant Rahulta was separated from his mother, a woman whose name was Magdaliyana, and who was a follower of the Buddha acted as the intermediary. It may be noted that the name Magdaliyana is in reality a corrupt form of the name Magdalena, a female follower of Jesus, the Messiah, may peace be on him, mentioned in the Gospels.
All this evidence, which has been briefly given, should lead an unbiased mind to the conclusion that Jesus, may peace be on him, must certainly have visited this country. Regardless of all these certain and sure grounds, no intelligent person can afford to disregard the similarity to be found between the teachings and the ceremonial rites of Buddhism and those of Christianity, especially in Tibet. This resemblance is so close and striking that most Christian researchers believe that Buddhism is the Christianity of the East, and Christianity the Buddhism of the West.1 Look how amazing it is that just as Jesus, the Messiah, said, ‘I am the Light and I am the Way,’ so said the very same Buddha. The Gospels call Jesus, the Messiah, the Saviour, the Buddha too calls himself the Saviour—see Lalta Wasatra. And in the Gospels, the birth of Jesus, the Messiah, is said to have happened without a father. Similalry is it written in the life events of the Buddha that he too was in reality born without a father,2 although apparently, just as Jesus, the Messiah, had a foster father Joseph, so had the Buddha a foster father. Similarly, it is stated that a star appeared at the time of the Buddha’s birth. Also there is the story of Solomon ordering the cutting of the child in two halves and giving each half to the two women; an exactly similar episode is to be found in the Buddha’s Jataka.1 From all this it can be understood that in addition to showing that Jesus, the Messiah, did come to this country, the Jews who had also migrated to this land had also established close ties with Buddhism.
And the account of the Creation of the world written in the books of Buddhism is also very similar to the one given in the Torah. And just as it appears from the Torah that man enjoys a degree of superiority over woman, so is a male devotee in the religion of the Buddha considered superior to a female devotee. The Buddha did, however, believe in the transmigration of souls, but his view of transmigration is not opposed to the teaching of the Gospels. According to the Buddha, transmigration is of three kinds:
(1) First being that, the resolute courage and conduct of a dying man demand, as an outcome, that another body be born. (2) Second is the category which the Tibetans believe in their own Lamas, that is to say, that some part of the spirit of some Buddha or Buddhsattva transmigrates into the present day Lamas, meaning that his power, disposition and spiritual qualities are transferred into the present day Lama and his spirit begins to animate the recipient. (3) The third category of transmigration is that in this very life man goes through various types of births until on account of his personal qualities he becomes an authentic human being. A time may come upon man when he is, figuratively speaking, a bull; and then, when he grows in greed and somewhat in mischief, so he becomes a dog; the first existence dies giving place to the second, corresponding to the quality of the actions of the first. But all these ‘metamorphoses,’ take place in this very life. Thus this creed is also not opposed to the teachings of the Gospels.
And I have already stated that the Buddha also believes in the existence of the Devil; similarly he also believes in heaven and hell, and angels and he believes also in the Day of Judgment. And this allegation that the Buddha did not believe in God, is a pure fabrication. However, he did not believe in Vedanta1 and in the corporeal gods that had been fabricated in the Hindu religion. And yes, he was an acute critic of the Vedas, and did not accept the existing Vedas to be accurate; he thought it to be a corrupted altered and modified book. He considered his birth in the period during which he was a Hindu and a follower of the Vedas, to have been an evil birth. For example, he hints that he remained for a certain period, a monkey also, again for a time an elephant, and then he became a deer, and a dog, and became four times a snake, and then became also a sparrow, a frog, twice a fish, ten times a lion, four times a fowl, twice a pig, and once a hare. When he was a hare he used to teach the monkeys, the jackals, and the water dogs. Again, he says that he was once a ghost, once a woman, and once a dancing Devil. All these hints are meant to point to phases of his life as were full of cowardice, effeminacy, impurity, savagery, beastliness, profligacy, gluttony, and superstition. It appears that in point of fact, his confessions pertain to the time when he was a follower of the Vedas, for, after rejecting the Vedas he never gives any hint of such things, that thereafter any part of the evil life remained within him. On the contrary, he made very great claims thereafter and said that he had become a manifestation of God and had attained Nirvana.1 The Buddha has also stated that when man leaves the world accompanied by hellish deeds he is thrown into hell. And the sentinels of hell drag him to the king of hell, whose name is Yamah, and the condemned one is asked whether or not he had seen the following Five Messengers who had been sent to warn him. And they are the following: the period of childhood, the period of old age, disease, being punished during one’s life as evidence of the punishment in the hereafter, corpses of the dead which remind us of the transitory nature of the world.
The condemned one replies that, ‘Sir, due to my own stupidity I did not ponder at all over any of these things.’ Thereupon the guardians of hell will drag him to the place of torment and secure him with chains of iron which would have been made so hot by fire as to have become red like the fire itself. The Buddha, moreover, says that hell has several zones where sinners of different categories will be cast. In short, all these teachings cry out aloud that the Buddhist religion gained something from the blessed personal example and influence of Jesus, the Messiah. I do not wish to elaborate this point further, and close this section here, because the prophecy about the coming of Jesus, the Messiah, to this country has been so clearly spelled out in Buddhist literature that no one can deny it. And then, apart from this, we see that the parables and the moral teachings of the Gospels are positively to be found in Buddhist books compiled in the time of Jesus, the Messiah. These two points, when considered together, leave no doubt whatsoever that definitely Jesus, the Messiah, came to this country. Thus, the evidence which we wanted to find in the books of the Buddhist faith has, thanks be to God, been discovered in full.