Foreword

Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 10

Nevertheless, they called upon an assembly of people to announce their decision. Hadrat ‘Amr bin Al-‘As asked Hadrat Abu Musa Ash‘ari to announce his decision first, and said that he would do the same after him. Hadrat Abu Musa announced the dismissal of Hadrat Ali (ra) from his office. After this, Hadrat ‘Amr bin Al-‘As stood up and said, Abu Musa has dismissed Hadrat Ali (ra) from his office, and I agree with him in this respect and remove Hadrat Ali (ra) from Khilafat, but I do not dismiss Muawiyah, rather, I reinstate him to his office. (Hadrat ‘Amr Bin Al-‘As himself was a very pious man, but, at this time I do not want to enter into a discussion of the reasons behind his decision.) On this, the companions of Hadrat Muawiyah (ra) started saying that the arbiters had given their verdict in favour of Hadrat Muawiyah (ra) instead of Hadrat Ali (ra). However, Hadrat Ali (ra) refused to accept this decision, because the arbiters were not appointed for this purpose, and their decision was not based on any injunction in the Holy Qur’an. On this, the same hypocrite associates of Hadrat Ali (ra), who had pressured him to appoint arbiters, started questioning him as to why arbiters were appointed when there could not be any arbiter in religious matters. Hadrat Ali (ra) replied that first of all, there was a provision in the agreement that the decision would be according to the Holy Qur’an, which had not been followed, and secondly, the arbiter was appointed on their demand, and now they were questioning the authenticity of that appointment. They responded, “We committed a mistake, and we do cut a sorry figure, but the question is, why did you listen to us? Therefore, we have become sinners and so have you. Now, we have sought Allah’s forgiveness, so you should do the same. You should confess that whatever you did was not lawful.”

Their purpose was that in the case of Hadrat Ali’s (ra) denial, they would separate themselves from his Bai‘at, under the pretext that since he acted against Islam, they could not remain in his Bai‘at. Even if he admitted his mistake and repented by seeking Allah’s forgiveness, his Khilafat would become null and void, because such a person who committed an immense mistake could not remain Khalifah. On hearing these arguments, Hadrat Ali (ra) replied, “I have not committed any mistake. The matter for which I appointed an arbiter was within the provisions of Islamic sharia. Furthermore, at the time of their appointment, I clearly mentioned that I shall accept their decision if and only if it is based on the Holy Qur’an and Ahadith. Otherwise, it would not be binding on me. As they did not follow this condition and did not give their verdict on that matter for which they were appointed, therefore, their decision is not binding on me.” However, the hypocrites did not accept the plea of Hadrat Ali (ra) and separated themselves from his Bai‘at. They were called the Khawarij (Secessionists). They made this innovation in religion, that no Khalifah is worthy of utter submission on the part of the people, and that all decisions should be according to the verdict of the majority of Muslims, because to honour a ruler as worthy of complete submission from the people is against this verse:

“There is no judge except Allah.”

This was the first disagreement in the matter of Khilafat. At that time, the people who were in favour of Hadrat Ali (ra) started refuting those objections. While doing so, the prophecies of the Holy Prophet (sa) about Hadrat Ali (ra) were also discussed in detail, and some of the miscreants stressed that debate on Khilafat was unnecessary because the Khilafat of Hadrat Ali (ra) was based, not on an electoral decision, but on the prophecies of the Holy Prophet (sa) about him. Therefore, he was the Khalifah appointed by the Holy Prophet (sa) without the need for any electoral decision.

This is the same as if someone, while discussing me as Musleh Ma‘ud [the Promised Reformer], should say that he pledges allegiance to me as Khalifah because there are prophecies of the Promised Messiah (as) about me, and not because my Khilafat was established through the majority vote of the

Community. The moment anyone starts thinking on these lines, he will start moving toward destruction. It is because, by doing so, the feeling for the sanctity of the system of Khilafat gives way to the idea of Imamat of one appointed person.

In short, some of the “Ghalis” [extremists] presented an interpretation from the prophecies of the Holy Prophet (sa) that Hadrat Ali’s (ra) Khilafat was only due to those prophecies, and not because of any election. Gradually, they inclined more and more towards the view that Hadrat Ali (ra) was, in fact, an Imam by appointment. To them, the concept of Khilafat, as had been generally believed by the Muslims, was invalid. Instead, whenever there is a need, an Imam is appointed by the special command of God Almighty, and he becomes the source of guidance and direction for the people.

Due to these differences concerning Khilafat, the Muslims were divided into three groups with different concepts, as following:

(1) “Khilafat is in the sense of Succession, and there should be a Successor to the Holy Prophet (sa). The method of the appointment of a Khalifah is that he should be elected by the majority of the Muslims, or in accordance with an electoral process agreed by the ummah. Such a person is appointed as Khalifah and submission to him is obligatory on Muslims.” The group holding this belief is called Sunni.

(2) “Authority belongs to God. To consider a human being worthy of obedience amounts to apostasy. Decisions should be based on the opinion of the majority, and Muslims are at liberty to appoint whomsoever they desire.” Those who hold these views are referred to as Khawarij (Secessionists.)

(3) “The people do not appoint an Amir (leader), rather, it is God Who appoints the Amir. He appointed Hadrat Ali (ra) as Imam, and after him, appointed eleven more Imams. The last Imam is still alive, but is hidden.” This group holding these beliefs is referred to as Shia. Among them, there is a sect that believes in the continuous necessity of a living and visible Imam. They are referred to as Isma‘iliyyah Shia.

This is the history of the Khilafat immediately after the Holy Prophet (sa). Now I turn to the Khilafat which was established after the Promised Messiah (as). The Ahmadiyya Jama‘at was in the same state of mind during the lifetime of the Promised Messiah (as) as were the Companions (ra) of the Holy Prophet (sa) during his lifetime. All of us believed that the Promised Messiah (as) would not die as yet. As a result, we never thought, even for a moment, about what would happen after his demise. I, at that time, was not a child. I was a young man, I used to write articles, and was editor of a magazine. I say on oath that I never thought, for a minute, or even for a second, that the Promised Messiah (as) would die, even though, in the last years of his life, there were a series of revelations about his demise. In his last days, such revelations increased manifold. Despite the fact that there were revelations and visions specifying the date etc. of the demise of the Promised Messiah (as), and we used to read Al-Wasiyyat (The Will), we still presumed that these things would probably happen after two centuries. Thus, the thought of what would happen after the demise of the Promised Messiah (as) never crossed our minds. Since we had assumed that he would not die in our lifetime, it was difficult for us to accept the reality of his demise when it happened. I clearly remember that after his demise, he was given a bath and was wrapped in the shroud. As is common, that one’s clothes and moustache etc. move with the blowing of the wind, some of the companions would come running, saying that the Promised Messiah (as) was alive, and his clothes or moustache was moving. Some said that they saw his shroud moving. Anyhow, the body of the Promised Messiah (as) was brought to Qadian and was placed inside a house in a garden. Around eight or nine o’clock, Khawaja Kamaluddin arrived in the garden, took me aside, and asked me, “Miyań! Have you thought of what would happen after the demise of the Promised Messiah (as)?” I replied to him, “Something should happen, but as to what it should be, I cannot say anything”.

He said to me, “In my opinion, we should give Bai‘at to Hadrat Maulawi Sahib (ra)”. At that time, due to my age and lack of knowledge, I said, “the Promised Messiah (as) did not mention anywhere that we should take the Bai‘at of someone after him, so why should we take the Bai‘at of Hadrat Maulawi Sahib (ra)”? (Though it was mentioned in Al-Wasiyyat, it did not occur to me at that time). On this, he started arguing that the Community would be destroyed if the Bai‘at was not taken at the hand of one person. He added that after the demise of the Holy Prophet (sa), the people took the Bai‘at of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra), so the same should be done now, and there is no one more suitable in the Jama‘at than Hadrat Maulawi Sahib. He also told me that Maulawi Muhammad Ali Sahib had the same viewpoint. Finally, the whole Community unanimously requested Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) to accept the Bai‘at of the people. Then, all the people gathered in the garden and Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) addressed them and said, “I have no wish for Imamat (leadership), and in my opinion, the Bai‘at of someone else should be taken”. For this purpose, he first proposed my name, then the name of our maternal grandfather, Mir Nasir Nawab Sahib, then the name of our brother-in-law, Nawab Muhammad Ali Khan Sahib, and then the names of some other people, but we all unanimously told him that he himself was entitled to the post of Khilafat. Then, everyone took Bai‘at on his hand.

·

10 of 10 left today