Foreword
Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 9
A dispute arose between the Ansar and Muhajirin. The Ansar thought that, as the Holy Prophet (sa) lived among them during that part of his life which was related to an organizational system, and as there had been no such system in Mecca, they could understand the system better than any one else and were thus entitled to Khilafat. Their second argument was that as the territory, i.e. Medina, belonged to them, their word would carry more weight than that of the
Muhajirin. Therefore, they thought that the Successor of the Holy Prophet (sa) should be from the Ansar and not from the Muhajirin. Contrary to this, the Muhajirin said that their companionship with the Holy Prophet (sa) was longer than that of the Ansar, thus, they could understand the religion better. People were still considering this dispute and had not yet resolved it when the group in favour of the Ansar gathered in the verandah of Bani Sa‘dah and started consulting with one another. They were inclined towards the appointment of Sa‘d bin Ubadah, leader of Khazraj and a recognized Chief, as Khalifah. During this discussion, the Ansar argued that they were the owners of the country, its lands, and its properties; therefore, it is better for Islam that the Khalifah be from them. They thought no person more competent for the post than Sa’d bin Abadah. While this discussion was taking place, some said: What if the Muhajirin reject this arrangement. Someone said that they would reply “one Amir from us and one from you”. Sa’d, who was a wise man, called this the first weakness; saying that “one Amir from us and one from you”, denotes complete ignorance about the concept of Khilafat. Such a situation would hurt Islam. When the Muhajirin learned of what was happening, they went there in a hurry, for they knew that if the Khalifah was not from the Muhajirin, the Arabs would not submit to him. No doubt, the Ansar were the majority in Medina, but all of Arabia honoured the nobility and greatness of the Meccans. The Muhajirin thought that if the Khalifah were from the Ansar, the Arabs would be put to a great crisis and there might be many who would not be able to preserve their faith in the face of such a crisis. Consequently, all of the Muhajirin went there, and among them were Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra), Hadrat Umar (ra), and Hadrat Abu Ubaidah (ra).
Hadrat Umar (ra) later recalled: “I had prepared an eloquent speech for this occasion. I had planned to deliver it immediately upon arrival so that it would convince all of the Ansar, and they would have no alternative but to elect a Khalifah from the Muhajirin rather than Ansar. When we arrived, Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) stood up to make an address, and I did not expect anything exceptional from him, but by God, he presented all the points that I myself had thought of. In addition, he put forth more of his own arguments. Then I understood that I was no match to Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra).”
The Muhajirin pointed out the necessity of an Amir from the Quraish, and quoted a saying of the Holy Prophet (sa), “The Amirs should be from Quraish”. They also pointed out that they were the first to accept Islam and narrated the sacrifices that they had made for Islam. Habab bin al- Mundhir of Khazraj opposed this, and said that they could not accept a Khalifah from the Muhajirin, and that if the Muhajirin could not agree to this and strongly insisted upon their view, then , “one Amir from us and one from you” should be acted upon. Hadrat Umar (ra) asked him to be careful of what he was saying and pointed out that the Holy Prophet (sa) has said that having two Amirs at one time is unlawful. (This indicates that there were such traditions in which the Holy Prophet (sa) had elaborated the system of Khilafat, but, in his lifetime, the Companions (ra) did not pay much attention to them. The reason for this is the Divine wisdom that I have mentioned before.) Thus, Hadrat Umar (ra) concluded that the demand of making one Amir from each group did not satisfy reason or sharia.
After some discussion, Hadrat Abu Ubaidah (ra) stood up and addressed the Ansar saying: You were the first people outside Mecca who accepted Islam; now do not be the first to pervert the principles of religion after the demise of the Holy Prophet (sa). This had such a deep impact on them that Bashir bin Sa‘d Khazraji stood up and addressed his people: “This is true that the help and support that we offered and the services we rendered to the Holy Prophet (sa) were not for any worldly gains or to attain sovereignty after him. They were only for the sake of God. The main concern now is not about the right to Khilafat but about the obligation to Islam. From this perspective, the Amir should be from the Muhajirin, for they were blessed with the company of the Holy Prophet (sa) for a long time.” The debate continued for some time, and within half an hour or so, the people came around to the view that the Khalifah should be from the Muhajirin. Then Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) nominated Hadrat Umar (ra) and Hadrat Abu Ubaida (ra) for this post, and asked everyone to enter into the Bai‘at (allegiance) of any one of them, but both declined the proposition and said that they would pledge allegiance to the person whom the Holy Prophet (sa) made the Imam of Salat, and who was the best among the Muhajirin. In other words, there was no one better suited to Khilafat than Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra). On this, the people started taking the pledge of Bai‘at at the hand of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra). Hadrat Umar (ra) was the first to take the Bai‘at, then Hadrat Abu Ubaida (ra) and after him, Bashir bin Sa‘d Khazraji (ra). After them, the tribe of Aus and the people of Khazraj started taking Bai‘at. The people were so enthusiastic, that in their eagerness, they nearly trampled Sa‘d, who was ill and was unable to get up. Within a short time, all except Sa‘d and Hadrat Ali (ra) took the Bai‘at. Sa‘d’s son also took the Bai‘at.
Hadrat Ali (ra) did the same after a few days. According to some traditions, Hadrat Ali (ra) took Bai‘at after three days, and according to others, after six months. The traditions mentioning six months also add that Hadrat Ali (ra) could not take the Bai‘at of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) because he was busy looking after Hadrat Fatimah (ra) who was ill at that time. When he came to Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) to take the Bai‘at, he apologized for the delay, due to the illness of Hadrat Fatimah (ra).
On his deathbed, Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) sought the advice of the Companions (ra) on who should be appointed the next Khalifah. The majority gave their opinion in favour of Hadrat Umar (ra). Some of them raised only one concern, that Hadrat Umar (ra) was very strict by nature and he might be hard on people. Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) said that the harshness of Hadrat Umar (ra) would vanish when he is burdened with the responsibility. Thus, all the Companions (ra) agreed upon the Khilafat of Hadrat Umar (ra). As the health of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) was very poor, he, with the support of his wife Asma (ra), with trembling hands and feet, went to the mosque and addressed all the Muslims, and said, “I have continuously deliberated on who should be your Khalifah after my demise. After much contemplation and prayer, I have decided to nominate Hadrat Umar (ra) as Khalifah. So Hadrat Umar (ra) will be the Khalifah after me.” All of the Companions (ra) and others agreed to this Khilafat and took Bai‘at of Hadrat Umar (ra) after the demise of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra).
When Hadrat Umar (ra) was injured and realized that his demise was imminent, he nominated six persons and advised them to elect the Khalifah from among themselves. They included Hadrat Usman (ra), Hadrat Ali (ra), Hadrat Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf (ra), Hadrat Sa‘d bin Al-Waqqas (ra), Hadrat Zubair (ra), and Hadrat Talhah (ra). In addition to them, he included Hadrat Abdullah bin Umar (ra) as advisor, but did not declare him as entitled to Khilafat. He also admonished that these people should give their verdict within three days, and Suhaib (ra) should lead the prayer during that period of time. He appointed Miqdad bin Al-Aswad (ra) to oversee the consultation and election process and directed him to gather the Electoral College at one place and to guard them. He issued more directions, the people should take the Bai‘at of the person who is elected by the majority of votes, and if any one declines to do so, then he should be killed. If there be three votes on each side, then Hadrat Abdullah bin Umar (ra) would recommend who the Khalifah should be. If the members of Electoral College do not agree to the decision of Abdullah bin Umar (ra), then the person favoured by Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf (ra) should be appointed as Khalifah.
These five persons discussed this matter (as Talhah (ra) was not in Medina at that time), but could not come to any conclusion. After a very long time, Hadrat Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf (ra) asked if anyone wanted to withdraw his name, but all of them remained quiet. On this, Hadrat Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf (ra) withdrew his name, then Hadrat Usman (ra) withdrew his name, and then two others did the same. Hadrat Ali (ra) remained quiet. Finally, the members of the Electoral College took a pledge from Hadrat Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf (ra) that he would be completely impartial, and entrusted the responsibility of making the decision to him. For three days, Hadrat Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf (ra) visited every house in Medina to obtain the opinion of every man and women about the issue. All of them expressed their agreement to the Khilafat of Hadrat Usman (ra). Thus, he gave his verdict in favour of Hadrat Usman (ra) and he became the Khalifah.
After this, Hadrat Usman (ra) was martyred and the Companions (ra) who were present in Medina—witnessing that discord was spreading among the Muslims—persuaded Hadrat Ali (ra) to accept the Bai‘at of the people. On the other hand, some miscreants also rushed to Hadrat Ali (ra) and told him that the Islamic state was facing the risk of destruction. They pleaded that he should accept the Bai‘at of the people in order to dispel fear and to establish safety and peace. In short, he was compelled to accept the Bai‘at and he took the responsibility after declining many times. Some of the eminent Companions (ra) were not present in Medina, and some were forced to take the Bai‘at. It is related that Hakim bin Jablah and Malik Ashter were sent with some aides to force Hadrat Talhah (ra) and Hadrat Zubair (ra) to take the Bai‘at at the point of the sword. They brandished their swords before them and asked them to take the Bai‘at of Hadrat Ali (ra) or they would kill them. According to some traditions, they were brought dragging on the ground for Bai‘at. Obviously, such an expression of allegiance cannot be called Bai‘at. Further, they took the Bai‘at on the condition that Hadrat Ali (ra) would take revenge from the murderers of Hadrat Usman (ra). However, later, when they felt that Hadrat Ali (ra) was not taking any prompt action, they abandoned their Bai‘at and went from Medina to Mecca.
A group from those who were involved in the murder of Hadrat Usman (ra) convinced Hadrat Ayeshah (ra) to declare Jihad to get revenge for the blood of Hadrat Usman (ra). Thus, she issued a declaration of Jihad and called on the Companions (ra) for help. Hadrat Talhah (ra) and Hadrat Zubair (ra) joined her. As a result, the armies of Hadrat Ali (ra) and Hadrat Ayeshah (ra), Hadrat Talhah (ra), and Hadrat Zubair (ra) fought a battle called the Battle of Jaml. In the very beginning of the war, Hadrat Zubair (ra), on hearing a prophecy of the Holy Prophet (sa) from Hadrat Ali (ra), left the battle and swore not to fight against him. He admitted that he was wrong in his interpretation. Hadrat Talhah (ra) also gave the pledge of Bai‘at of Hadrat Ali (ra) before his demise. It is mentioned in traditions that when Hadrat Talhah (ra) was dying from mortal wounds, somebody passed by him, and he asked that person which group he belonged to. He told him that he belonged to Hadrat Ali’s (ra) group. On this, Hadrat Talhah (ra) put his hand in his hand and said, “Your hand is the hand of Hadrat Ali (ra), and I enter into the Bai‘at of Hadrat Ali (ra)”. In short, the differences of the Companions (ra) were settled at the time of the battle of Jaml, but the dispute of Hadrat Muawiyah (ra) remained unsettled, and that became the cause of the battle of Safin.
In this battle, the comrades of Hadrat Muawiyah (ra) made a clever move and raised the Holy Qur’an on their spearheads, and declared that they would consent to the verdict of the Holy Qur’an, and for this, arbiters should be appointed. On this, the mischievous people who were involved in the conspiracy of Hadrat Usman’s (ra) murder, and who, just after his martyrdom, associated themselves with Hadrat Ali (ra) to protect themselves, started pressuring Hadrat Ali (ra) to appoint arbiters. Hadrat Ali (ra) refused vehemently, but the mischievous persons, and other weak-natured persons who fell prey to their connivance, forced Hadrat Ali (ra) to appoint arbiters. Hadrat ‘Amr bin Al-‘As from the side of Hadrat Muawiyah (ra), and Hadrat Abu Musa Ash‘ari from the side of Hadrat Ali (ra), were appointed arbiters. The issue to be settled was the murder of Hadrat Usman (ra), under the condition that the decision would be according to the Holy Qur’an. However, ‘Amr bin Al-‘As and Abu Musa Ash‘ari, after consultation, decided that Hadrat Ali (ra) and Hadrat Muawiyah (ra) should be dissolved from their offices, for it was they who had put all the Muslims to trouble, and then, the Muslims should be allowed to decide freely to elect the Khalifah of their choice. They were not appointed to make a decision in this respect.