Foreword
Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 15
That is, when you have elected the leaders then remember that there will be three authorities ruling over you. First the rule of Allah, second the rule of His Messenger, third the rule of the Amir. However, it is added:
As the Amirs will make various plans to fulfil these obligations so you are obligated to obey them to carry out those plans. If you, sometime, differ with them then refer the case to Allah and His Messenger, i.e. settle them in the light of the principles laid down by Allah and His Messenger, and do not follow your personal desires.
It is the best and very rewarding in the end for you. Here Allah, the Almighty has stated it clearly that when you hand over the power of government to the most competent persons then you will have to obey their commands along with the commands of Allah and His Messenger. This is because the objectives of establishing a government have been stated first. Allah, the Almighty says that it is necessary for your progress to hand over your affairs to one person. Nevertheless, remember to prefer competency during the election lest you should cast your vote to a person who has benefited you, or is a close relative or has friendly relations with you. It usually happens in the world that at the time of vote, preference is given to one who is closer to us or is a relative or a friend and the competency of a person for the job is not considered. Thus, Allah, the Almighty made it clear that same should not be in Islamic election that you merely elect a person who is your father or your son or your brother, rather entrust this responsibility to the most competent person whether you have relations with him or not. After this, it is mentioned that when you have elected the leaders then they will surely make plans for the progress of Islam. Therefore, We command you to obey their orders whether you fully understand them or not. However, if at any stage you differ with them then refer it to the command of God and His Messenger.
Those outside the Khilafat are overjoyed and say that the problem is solved as it is evidently mentioned that it is not necessary to obey Khalifah. They conclude that if the Khulafa’ proceed according to sharia, people should obey them, and if not, they should be rejected. I shall, God willing, address this issue later.
Right now, I want to say that the following principles have been described as general directives related to Islamic organization in the Holy Qur’an: (1) National organization is a trust because it
affects not just one person but the whole nation.
Therefore, while making a decision you should
prefer national interest and benefits to your
personal desires.
(2) An organization is required for the fulfilment of
this trust; people cannot execute it on individual level. Therefore, there should be an executive
for its performance.
(3) The nation should elect these executives. (4) During the election, it should be kept in mind
that the elected persons are competent to fulfil
these trusts. Apart from it, no other element
should be taken into consideration.
(5) Those who are assigned to such positions will
not be the master of national affairs but the
executives, because it is said: i.e. that
they will not inherit the ownership from their
forefathers but should be competent for the
service.
These commands are not purely for religious organization. It is evident from the words that these are the universal commands valid for both types of organization religious and worldly. Hence, Islam does not consider kingship a part of its organization, but it accepts a system based on the electoral process and stresses that all individuals should obey the people who are duly assigned to these functions.
Does Islam Acknowledge a Certain Type of Pure Worldly Government?
If it is asked whether Islam acknowledges a certain type of pure worldly government or not? The answer to it is that in the presence of all the means available for its support, Islam does not endorse any purely worldly organization. But it also does not ignore the prevailing circumstances. It is possible that the ideal organization which Islam envisions may not be enforceable under certain circumstances. In such a state of affairs there may arise a need for some worldly organizations. For instance, if the majority of Muslims comes under the rule of a government of the non-believers, and are deprived of their liberty, independence and collective power, then those countries where Islam is in power, cannot establish a combined religious and worldly organization because the majority of Muslims cannot follow it. In such constrained circumstances, there is a provision for the establishment of purely worldly organization, which will follow the principles of Islam, mentioned before.
Interpretation of Purely Worldly
Purely worldly organization does not mean that it will not enforce those rules of Islamic organization which deal with the government. It, in fact, means that its rules will not be religiously binding for the whole Islamic world, because neither the majority of the Muslims will be able to abide by them due to political circumstances nor will the majority of Muslims be involved in the establishment of this organization.