Foreword
Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 16
Therefore, in such circumstances it would be permissible to establish a separate purely religious organization. It would not only be lawful but also necessary that a separate purely religious organization be established which is affiliated to that Islamic organization which, in turn, should be linked not with any government but with a spiritual organization of Islam so that the other governments do not interfere. Since it would be a spiritual organization and will not meddle with the affairs of the government, such an organization would be able to unite the Muslims living in other countries and Islam would be saved from disarray. If the Muslims had acted upon the theme of this verse, they would have surely been saved from the degradation in the last period.
Muslims committed a mistake during the period of their decline. They presumed that since they could not establish an organization in the whole world to address both the religious and the secular, there was no scope for them to establish a purely religious organization. They also presumed that these two organizations could not be separated under any circumstances. When establishment of one organization became impossible, they abandoned the other too. It was the duty of the Muslims that after the institution of Khilafat came to an end, they should have made a centre for their national endeavours including the propagation of Islam in the whole world. Under this centre, they could have established the preaching missions in the whole world for the improvement of the morals of the people, teaching the
Qur’an, and to convert the non-Muslims to Islam, and strive collectively for their common national interests. However, they presumed that there was no scope of the establishment of any religious organization. As a result, they continued to decline day by day. If, after their failure to establish an organization comprising religious and worldly affairs, they had established a purely religious organization, they would have saved themselves from a great misfortune. With such an arrangement, Islam could have been dominant in the whole world, and Christianity could have been totally wiped out. But they made the mistake that if they could not establish such an organization in the whole world based on religious and worldly sections, then there was no chance of establishing a purely religious organization. Therefore, when they lost one organization, they abandoned the other one.
Their second mistake was to draw the inference that election was necessary only for the organization which covers the worldly and religious affairs of all the Muslims. The fact is that in these verses God Almighty has clearly mentioned that election is as necessary in a purely worldly organization as it is in the combined organization of religious and worldly affairs. If they were not able to do more, the Muslims could have set up an electoral system for choosing the king. It would have saved them from great destruction. If they had comprehended this point the hereditary kingship that prevailed among the Muslims and caused the destruction of the Islamic government, would have been avoided. Moreover, they would have become the first and true pioneers of the development of democracy.
Establishment of Purely Religious
Organization when Differences Prevent Setting up an All-encompassing System
I have stated that the cited verse provides the need of the establishment of purely religious organization in a situation when there are controversies in the secular arrangements. This is because all the Muslims are addressed in this verse, and they are directed to obey “those in authority among them” at all times. There is no restriction of any period to obey those in authority, Rather, there is a command to obey them in every situation and in every age. If somebody says that the command to obey “those in authority” is for the time being, then it will have to be assumed that obedience to Allah and His Prophet are also temporary, because God has first commanded to “obey Allah and obey His messenger”. Since the command to obey God and His Messenger is for all times and for every age therefore the command to obey “the authorities” should be for every situation and for every age. In fact, by this verse, Allah, the Almighty has drawn the attention of Muslims to the fact that compliance with an organization is binding for them at all times. Just like the other commandments, if compliance of one part is not possible, the other parts are not automatically cancelled. One who cannot participate in Jihad, cannot be excused from Prayer. One who cannot perform Ablution, cannot be excused from bowing and prostration. He who cannot perform Salat by standing, cannot be excused of performing his Salat by sitting or by laying or by nodding. Similarly, even if there cannot be a political organization for the whole Islamic world, yet Muslims cannot be free from the compliance of other parts of the obedience of “those in authority”. Just as if someone goes to Hajj and cannot perform Sa‘i in between Safa and Marwah, he is not excused from it. Rather, it will be necessary for him to fulfil this obligation by sitting on the back of some other person.
Therefore, the Muslims committed a great mistake when they inferred that, as one organization had become impracticable for them so they were also freed of other organization. On the contrary, the establishment of purely religious organization does not become impossible when Muslims are divided in several political entities as has been proved by the advent of the Promised Messiah (as). If people ask us why we do not cut the hand of a thief then we can tell them that it is not in our power but those matter in which we have control we consider it our foremost duty to establish an Islamic organization within our own community. If the Muslims had realized that to obey “those in authority” was binding at all times and had they established organization in other parts leaving the impracticable parts of the obedience to “those in authority” aside, they would have fulfilled this commandment and Islam would have been saved from the decline that it has reached. Perhaps it was the will of Allah, the Almighty that this part of Islamic organization be implemented through the Jama‘at of the Promised Messiah (as) and the community called [others of them] may achieve this excellence because there should have been virtue reserved for us. The Companions (ra) were granted the excellence that they established a combined religious and worldly organization based on Islamic principles. However, Allah, the Almighty directed our attention to the establishment of an organization, which is purely religious. It is as if Companions (ra) followed one part of this verse and we followed the other, so we also joined them. In short, the principles of the establishment of Islamic organization are mentioned in this verse. This command is given:
(i) Islamic organization should be based on election.
(ii) The Muslims should remain obedient to [those among them who are vested with authority].
It is regrettable that the Muslims forgot these two principles during the time of their decline. Even where it was possible for them, they did not maintain electoral process. And in situations which were not fully under their control, they did not keep the Islamic Unity by obeying the organization of “those who are vested with” authority even in areas where they did have control. They involved themselves in useless debates that they should obey only “those in authority”. In this way, they ignored the real spirit of this commandment. If they had fulfilled that part which was in their power, they would not have been accountable for things that were beyond their power.
Clarification of an Objection on
“Authorities among You”
Someone may raise an objection that the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community teaches that “the authorities” that are non-Muslim are also included in these words, “authorities among you”, and according to this verse the obedience of non-Muslim authorities is also required. However, the meaning given above cannot be applied to non-Muslims. It is true. However, this meaning is based upon the part of the words, “the authorities” i.e. when we say that non- Muslims are also included in “the authorities” then we do not take the whole portion into consideration, but we deduce it from one part of the verse. But we cannot ignore the meaning of this part in conjunction with all the verses. No doubt, in worldly affairs the obedience of every “authority” is obligatory, but with it we cannot ignore that in every age the obedience of “those among them [Muslims] who are vested with authority” is obligatory for them.
Interpretation of “Refer to Allah and His Messenger in situations of Disagreement with Authority among You” Now I come to the topic that I had promised to explain before. Some people have raised the objection that in case of disagreement with “authorities” Allah, the Almighty says, “refer it to Allah and His Messenger”; it indicates that their obedience is not obligatory but in controversial situation, we have to look at what the command of Allah and His Messenger is. The answer to this question is that this interpretation makes the whole verse meaningless because every person considers his own viewpoint as correct. If this meaning of verse is adopted, then there cannot be any obedience. After all what will the command be that would be unanimously acknowledged by all the people as the command of God and His Messenger? There is no doubt that difference of opinion is always present. If everybody has the authority to declare a command to be against the teachings of God and His Messenger then in that situation Khalifah is left to rule upon his own self. Particularly in the present age, it is the condition that followers are few and the self-proclaimed authorities in interpretation abound. When everybody considers himself a great mind, Khalifah while sitting on his mat will order the people to do such and such thing and the people will ask him first to prove the command from the Holy Qur’an and Ahadith, and then they will obey, otherwise not. It is evident that there is no religious matter that is unanimously believed by the whole world. There is always a debatable point in every matter. There is a famous story that an illiterate person was fond of attending the company of learned people. As he had no knowledge of religion, wherever he went the people would throw him out. Once he told his friend that he was fond of attending the meetings of Ulema, but the people did not let him do so. What should he do? He advised him to wear a long robe and turban.
The people would consider him a great scholar from his appearance, and they would not stop him from attending the meetings of Ulema. After entering a meeting, if somebody asks about something, he should tell him that it was a controversial issue. Some have written this and others opposite of it. As there is disagreement in most of the matters, no one would realize that he knows nothing. Therefore, he wore a long robe and a large turban, took a staff in his hand and started attending the meetings of Ulema. In the meetings, he would sit with his head bowed down. The people would seek his opinion on the topic under discussion. He would nod and say that it was useless to argue on that topic. The jurists of Islam greatly differed on it. Some Ulema had written as is told by this scholar and some Ulema had written so as is told by that scholar. The people thought that he was a well-read person, so they agreed with his viewpoint and would leave the dispute to talk on something else. It continued for sometime, and he was greatly honoured in the meetings of Ulema. One day it so happened that a discussion started on the topic that the time is very bad and even the educated people are denying God and ask for the proof of His existence. On this as per tradition, the people asked him to say something. He said it was useless to argue, some Ulema had written that there was God and some wrote otherwise. On hearing this people came to know of his ignorance and he lost his reputation. They expelled him from the meeting.
To sum up, differences are rampant in the world. Therefore, if the verse:
is taken to mean that whenever anybody differs with Khalifah about some command issued by him, he must ignore the Khalifah under the pretext that his command is against the command of God and His Messenger. In such circumstances, Khalifah will be unable to fulfil his obligations. This is not a rational approach. Some people of our Jama‘at have erred in comprehending the true meaning of this verse. If they had comprehended the true meaning, they would never have erred.
The Verse “Those who are in authority among You” is Applicable to Both the Worldly Authorities and Khulafa’-e- Rashidin
What are the true meanings? To know them it should be kept in mind that this verse is all-inclusive, and it includes pure worldly authorities and Khulafa’- e-Rashidin as well. Therefore, this verse is not only related to pure religious Khulafa’ but is also concerned with worldly authorities. Now keeping it in mind that this verse, as meaning is concerned, is all inclusive and it includes both the pure worldly authorities and Khulafa’-e-Rashidin, bear this in your mind that there are separate commands of the Holy Qur’an and the Holy Prophet (sa) about them. There are separate commands of Islamic sharia for pure worldly authorities, and separate for Khulafa’-e-Rashidin. So when God says that “if you differ in saying anything among yourselves, refer it to Allah and His Messenger”, it does not mean that when you differ with authorities then you start interpreting the command of God and His Messenger according to your wishes. It means this universal command applies to both Khulafa’-e-Rashidin and worldly authorities. So in case of difference with them, look what type of authorities they are. If they are Khulafa’-e-Rashidin then follow the course of action laid down by Allah, the Almighty about Khulafa’-e-Rashidin. If the authorities are worldly then act upon those commands which Allah, the Almighty and His Messenger have given about them.