Foreword

Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 17

Separate Commands for the Two Types of Authorities

Now we see whether Allah and His Messenger have given separate commands for the two types of authorities or not. If this is so then what are they? We see that the Holy Prophet (sa) has given two different commands for two types of authorities. As Abadah bin Samat (ra) relates:

Ma‘siyatin, Hadith No. 4874.

Muslim, Kitab-ul-Imarati, Babo wujubi Ta‘atil umara’i fi Ghairi Ma‘siyatin, Hadith No. 4877, by Abul Husain Muslim bin Hajjaj bin Muslim Al-Qushairi An-Nisaburi, publisher, Darul Jail, Beirut and Darul Afaq Al-Jadidah, Beirut.

“We took the Bai‘at of the Holy Prophet (sa) on the conditions that we will always obey the rulers whether it is convenient for us or hard and whether our heart intends to obey their commands or not, whether they give our rights to someone else, even then we’ll obey them. Similarly, there was another condition of our Bai‘at that we shall not dispute with a person to whom we entrust the government considering him fit for it. We shall not indulge in debate with him why he issued one command instead of the other one. It is possible that those authorities sometime may give a command against the religion. In that case, we had the instruction to inform them of the reality truthfully, and should not be afraid of any censure for the sake of the religion of God.” In another tradition it is mentioned, “We had the instruction from the Holy Prophet (sa) not to involve in any sort of dispute with those whom we have entrusted the job after considering them entitled for the government. But when you see an open infidelity and treachery from them, while the clear commands are in favour of your standpoint, then it is your duty to decline to obey them in that religious matter, and do what you are commanded by God.

Similarly, it is mentioned in another Hadith: Hadrat ‘Auf bin Malik al-Ashjaey (ra) narrates that the Holy Prophet (sa) said:

“Your best rulers are those whom you love and they love you. You send Durud on them and pray for their progress and they, in return, do the same. The worst rulers are those with whom you have malice and they are malicious with you. You curse them and they curse you.” The narrator mentioned that the Companions asked: “O Prophet of Allah! When such rulers are thrust upon us then why should we not dethrone them by challenging them”? The Holy Prophet (sa) said, “No, not at all until they put any restriction upon Salat and Fast, and forbid you from worshipping Allah, the Almighty, you should not stop obeying them. Listen! when somebody rules on you and you see that he is disobeying Allah, the Almighty in some matters

Abul Husain Muslim bin Hajjaj bin Muslim Al-Qushairy An-Nisabury, publisher, Darul Jail, Beirut and Darul Afaq Al-Jadidah, Beirut.

then nurture hatred in your hearts but do not rebel.”

In another Hadith, there is an additional command that in case they commit clear infidelity then you can rebel against them.

The Command to Follow Always Sunnah of Khulafa’-e-Rashidin

There is another Hadith narrated by Irbaz bin Sariyah (ra).

He said, “One day the Holy Prophet (sa) led the morning Salat, and after the Salat he gave a

Abul Husain Muslim bin Hajjaj bin Muslim Al-Qushairy An-Nisabury, publisher, Darul Jail, Beirut and Darul Afaq Al-Jadidah, Beirut.

sermon. The sermon was so moving that our tears started falling and the hearts shivering. On this, a person stood up and said, ‘O Messenger of Allah! It indicates that this is a farewell sermon. You should give us some advice’. He said, ‘I advise you to adopt the righteousness of Allah, the Almighty and be submissive and obedient in your way of life, even if a Negro slave is made ruler on you. The people, who will live after me, will see great dispute among the people. Thus, for that time I advise you that you should adopt the sunnah of mine and that of Khulafa’-e-Rashidin after me. You should strictly follow that sunnah and should stick to it as strongly as something is held by teeth. Similarly stick to that sunnah and never leave this path that is mine or that of my Khulafa’-e- Rashidin. And save yourself from the innovations because every new thing which is against my sunnah and that of Khulafa’-e- Rashidin will be an innovation in religion which will lead to destruction.’”

From these two references it is proved that the Holy Prophet (sa) described two kinds of authorities: one worldly and the other religious and Islamic. The command of obedience is for worldly authorities, but simultaneously there is a reason of disobedience on case of their clear infidelity. In such a situation, provided there is a solid proof of it, and not a guess, there is not only permission but also a command to go out of their obedience. Some Muslim Ulema like Hadrat Mahyyuddin Ibn-e-Arabi has been so cautious in such matters that he said that in such situation only separation is permissible and not revolt. But there are religious and Islamic authorities, on whom we are not made judge, but they are made judge upon ummah; whatever they do is binding upon you and their obedience is as necessary as that of command of the Holy Prophet (sa). So rulers are of two types: one who are worldly and about whom there is possibility that they might commit an infidelity. For them it is commanded to continue obeying them. Verily when they commit a clear infidelity then separate yourself from them. But other rulers are those who cannot commit a mistake. For them there is a directive to always follow their sunnah, and to never turn away from their path. But in case of a doubt whether your beliefs are true or not then compare your beliefs with those of Khulafa’-e-Rashidin. If they corroborate, then consider yourself on the right path, and if not then consider yourself on the wrong path.

In fact, Khulafa’-e-Rashidin are an example from whom other people can assess whether their steps are on straight footing or not. If the weight of two kilograms is on one side of the scale, and the other holds radishes and carrots, everyone will judge the weight of the vegetables against the two kilos. No one will throw away the weight as defective if they feel that there is a shortage of five to seven radishes. Instead, he will consider the vegetables to be short in weight. Similarly, the Holy Prophet (sa) did not say that you should judge the steps of Khulafa’-e-Rashidin and see whether they make sense to you; nor did he say that you should judge how they compare with the commands of God and His Messenger. Instead, it is said that if a doubt arises about your own self whether your steps correspond with the will of God and His Messenger, then see what the Khulafa’-e-Rashidin have stated about them. If your steps correspond with their viewpoint then consider them correct, but if not, consider your steps to be incorrect.

So the matters which are to be judged against the commands of God and His Messenger are those that I have mentioned before, namely the rulers with whom you differ. But judge what type of rulers they are, worldly rulers or the Khulafa’-e-Rashidin? If they are worldly rulers then obey them as far as you can. However, if they issue an order against the clear command of God then it is your duty to warn them of their mistake. Try to bring them towards the right path, and tell them that they are on the wrong path. If they commit a clear infidelity—as for example if they prohibit the performance of prayers or the observance of fast—then you have the right to disobey their orders and to tell them that you will continue performing prayers and observing fast no matter what they may say or do. But if those

(authorities) are Khulafa’-e-Rashidin, then beware for they cannot commit a mistake. What they do will be according to the will of Allah, the Almighty, Who guides them towards that path which leads close to Himself. So instead of judging them, make them your judge, and do not become counted among those who differ with Allah, the Almighty by differing with them.

I will now take up the commandments about the pure religious organization in Islam. In surah Al-Nur, Allah, the Almighty says:

In these verses the commandment is first given for obeying Allah and His Messenger. Then a promise is made to the Muslims that if they are perfect in their obedience, He will make them leaders. Like the earlier nations, He would establish for them a Khalifah on the earth. At that time, it would be their duty to establish Prayer and pay Zakat, and also to obey the Messenger of God. By establishing faith through the Khalifah, they would also be following the Messenger. This is the point also stressed in:

In other words, at such times the obedience to the Messenger would consist of following the Khalifah in propagating and strengthening Islam.

Performance of Prayer, in its True Sense, is not Possible without Khilafat

So in these verses Allah, the Almighty has first promised Khilafat to the Muslims. Then they are commanded to perform Prayer and pay Zakat. In this way, Allah, the Almighty has indicated that performance of Prayer in the true sense is not possible without Khilafat, as is the case of Zakat. There was a regular system of Zakat in the age of the Holy Prophet (sa). When he died, Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) took charge of Khilafat. The majority of Arabs refused to pay Zakat. They were of the view that it was a command only during the period of the Holy Prophet (sa), but not for the period of later Khulafa’. Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) refused to accept their demand and was determined to fight with those who even refused to pay Zakat equivalent to the string that was used to tie the knee of a camel, and vowed that he would not stop fighting till he received Zakat from them the same way they used to pay in the period of the Holy Prophet (sa). He succeeded in his campaign, and the system of Zakat again started functioning, which continued in the periods of the later Khulafa’. When Khilafat was terminated the Muslim world was left with no system for the recovery of Zakat. This is what Allah, the Almighty has mentioned in this verse. If there is no Khilafat, the Muslims cannot comply with the command of paying Zakat. The reason for it is that Zakat is a basic pillar of Islamic teachings. It is taken from the rich and distributed among the poor. It can only be possible where a regular organization exists. If an individual distributes Zakat to a few poor people then how can such good results come of it which are possible only in the presence of a system that ensures the utilization of the total collection of Zakat for the welfare and progress of all indigent people? So the system of Zakat requires the supervision of Khilafat. Similarly the performance of Prayer is not possible without Khilafat. The reason is that the best part of

·

10 of 10 left today