Foreword
Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 2
Under the influence of the West, the underlying current of these thoughts had long been in motion, but no Muslim had the courage to discuss them openly. When the Turkish Khilafat was destroyed, and Kemal Ataturk abolished the institution of Khilafat in Turkey, a commotion erupted in the entire Muslim world. Orthodox Muslims started forming Khilafat Committees. Many Khilafat Committees were also established in India, and people declared that they would fight this outrage [of absolution of Khilafat]. When people, who already had misgivings about the matter, witnessed that a victorious and honoured king supported their views by his actions, they became bolder in declaring their ideas and even wrote booklets. Such booklets were written by Muslims, Europeans, and also Russians. However, an Egyptian scholar, Ali bin Abdur Razzaq, who is one of the scholars of Jamia Azhar and is a Justice of The Religious Court, presented this perspective cogently in his book Al-Islamo wa Usul-ul-Hakam. The prime instigator of this trend, as I have already mentioned, was the profound unrest in the Islamic world in general, and Arabian countries in particular, caused by the abolition of Khilafat in Turkey.
It might be asked: How is this discussion related to Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya, which should be the real crux of my discussion? The Khilafat discussed in this book is monarchic, whereas the Khilafat of the Ahmadiyya Jama‘at is spiritual. The Turks are kings and Ahmadis are not. Therefore, the arguments in favour of, and against, the Turkish Khilafat should be of a different category. After all, what possible relationship can this Khilafat have with Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya, which has no kingdom and is only spiritual in nature?
The answer is that it is not necessary to confine oneself to those aspects of an issue which are raised specifically. At times, it is necessary to deal with all aspects of an issue comprehensively. For instance, when someone asks how hands are to be washed in ablution, there is no harm in describing all the steps of ablution to him. In this way, he will be able to understand related details as well. Similarly, though the Ahmadiyya Khilafat is a spiritual Khilafat, yet, there is no harm in discussing monarchic Khilafat. Indeed, it is essential to make the discussion comprehensive.
The second point is that politics is, in fact, another name of an organization; it exists with or without government. It is a mistake to link politics exclusively with government, for politics can exist without government. In the same way, an organization can also be established without a government. For instance, the Holy Prophet (sa) said that when three people go on a journey, they should appoint one among themselves as their leader, so that he can lead Salat and direct consultations for addressing problems arising during the journey. This is a kind of organization which is not linked with government. An organization is, in fact, a permanent entity which directs the affairs of people and also of government, if the government is involved. Thus, the issue of Khilafat deals with the Islamic organization, whether it involves government or not.
The third point is that if anyone were to prove that Islam has not presented any specific organization, it would not only affect monarchic Khilafat, but also the one presented by us. Thus, the monarchic Khilafat and the purely spiritual organization would both come under fire. All arguments presented against the Turkish Khilafat also affect Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya. Therefore, it is necessary that we should discuss these arguments in detail, for if Islam has not presented a specific organization, then Muslims would have free rein to choose not only the type of organization of state, but also that of religion. It would further grant them the unrestricted freedom to choose their own organization in any age and in any country.
Combination of Organizations of State and Religion in Early Period of Islam
This question acquires greater importance when we find that the organizations of state and religion were combined in the early period of Islam. Along with a religious organization in effect, there was also a standing army and justices as well. They administered penal laws, collected ransom, distributed stipends, and appointed people to offices. Similarly, they had institutionalized Salat, Fasting, Hajj, and payment of Zakat. Thus, in early Islam, both types of organizations were combined. If it were argued that this does not ordain any specific organization, then the establishment of spiritual Khilafat would also have to be considered an interim arrangement made by the Muslims of that time, it would not be an authority for establishing spiritual Khilafat in the future. If the institution of Khilafat were not proven to have existed from the beginning, its establishment in the later era would not be a valid issue. Thus, if the issue of Khilafat were to be affected in any way, not only would people declare the Turkish Khilafat unlawful, but also they would deny Khilafat altogether. As a result, we, who believe in Khilafat, would not escape its effects. For example, if an objection is raised against Hindus and Christians which can also apply to Islam, then, it cannot be said that it only affects Hindus and Christian, and not Muslims. If the same objection can also be made against Islam, it would be our duty to resolve it, for if it were to cause people to turn away from religion, Islam would also be affected.
The fourth point is that we cite the precedent of Khilafat-e-Rashidah of the Holy Prophet (sa) to prove the truthfulness of Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya. We declare that just as Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra), Hadrat Umar (ra), Hadrat Usman (ra), and Hadrat Ali (ra) became Khulafa’ after the Holy Prophet (sa), likewise there should be Khilafat after the Promised Messiah (as) as well. If the first Khilafat were to lose its validity, Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya would also become invalid.
Does Organization Developed by the Holy Prophet (sa) Have Religious Sanctity or Not? It should also be kept in mind that if the belief of Ali bin Abdur Razzaq, which is also that of those who moved away from Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya, were to be taken as valid, then it would raise the question: were the measures taken by the Holy Prophet (sa) for the development of an organization religious or not? If we were to declare that Islam does not present any specific type of organization, and that the Khilafat of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra), Hadrat Umar (ra), Hadrat Usman (ra) and Hadrat Ali (ra) were interim arrangements of the Muslims, and that whatever they did for the stability of the organization of the state was only done following in the footsteps of the Holy Prophet (sa), then the question would naturally arise: Were the steps taken by the Holy Prophet (sa) for the establishment of a state and organization only provisional measures, or did they bear the support of religious authority? If they were temporary, then whatever was done by Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra), Hadrat Umar (ra), Hadrat Usman (ra), and Hadrat Ali (ra) in his obedience would also be provisional and would not be an authority of sharia for us. On the other hand, if the steps taken by the Holy Prophet (sa) related to the government and the organization were religious, then we will have to adopt them as our guideline. Thus, this issue is not confined to the Khulafa’ but it also affects the Holy Prophet (sa). If the institution of Khilafat is not based on a basic religious principle and is only done to follow the actions of the Holy Prophet (sa), then it would be concluded that the actions of the Holy Prophet (sa) related to the establishment of an organization are not religious and do not need to be followed. Just as in the matter of food and clothing no one says that we should follow the Holy Prophet (sa) literally.
For instance, no one says that the Holy Prophet (sa) wore a loincloth so others should also wear it, or that the Holy Prophet (sa) used to eat dates so we should also eat the same. Only a general principal is deduced from these practices that we should live a simple life. Similarly, if the steps taken by the Holy Prophet (sa), which are concerned with the establishment of an organization, are not considered religious but are called provisional measures, then they would not be an authority for us to follow. At the most, we would be able to assert that with the fall of the rival Arabian empire, all of Arabia came under his command, so, he was compelled to establish a kind of organization. Since laws and regulations were required for the establishment of an organization, he made some as well. His only purpose was to improve the condition of people and not to establish an organization bearing religious authority for all time.
In short, by accepting this doctrine, we would also have to accept that the measures taken by the Holy Prophet (sa) related to the establishment of an organization carry no religious significance, and that they were simply done to meet the need of the time. Had they borne religious authority, they would have been a sunnah binding on later generations. This is the natural conclusion which results from this doctrine. Those who turned away from Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya have always tried to hide this natural conclusion from people for fear that if they declare that the part of the life of the Holy Prophet (sa) concerned with management of the affairs of the state was only a worldly matter to meet provisional needs of the time, the Muslims would not tolerate it, considering it a defamation of the Holy Prophet (sa). Therefore, they have always taken a very irrational approach to this subject. However, Ali bin Abdur Razzaq, one of the scholars of Jamia Al–Azher, has discussed this issue openly and boldly, and has reached the logical conclusion that I just mentioned. It is, therefore, an interesting coincidence that when I started collecting notes on this topic, it crossed my mind that if this argument were stretched to its limits, it would also affect the Holy Prophet (sa). One would have to admit that this part of his life was merely a worldly matter which was adopted to meet the needs of that time. I reached that conclusion initially; later, when I read his book, I noticed that he drew exactly the same inference that I drew, though he, being afraid of Muslims, avoided discussing it in detail. He tried to present his perspective like sugarcoated poison. Nevertheless, the crux of his reasoning becomes very clear when he points out that the institutions of justice, and other requisites of government like budgeting, were not present at that time, which shows that whatever the Holy Prophet (sa) did was to meet the immediate needs of the time.
The fact is that with the denial of Khilafat, one would have to admit that the government of Hadrat Muhammad (sa) was not religious either. No matter how gently this idea is presented out of fear of opposition from Muslims, the fact is that it not only denies the religious status of the rule of the Khulafa’, but it also contends that the part of the life of the Holy Prophet (sa) which dealt with the management of the affairs of state was only worldly, undertaken to fulfil the needs of that time. It would be concluded that, with the exception of Salat, Fasting, Hajj, and Zakat, organizational matters are left to the discretion of the people, and they are given full liberty by the Holy Prophet (sa) to follow the organization of their own choice. Ali bin Abdur Razzaq has discussed this subject also, and he says that:
If the Holy Prophet (sa) had been running a
government in the true sense of the word, he
would have appointed judges everywhere and
would have approved budgets on a regular
basis. This is not found in his life. In this way,