Foreword
Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 3
he tries to prove that the involvement of the
Holy Prophet (sa) in management of the affairs of
the state was only provisional. Just as when
there is no chair in a house, one sits on the
floor, in the same way, he made some laws to
establish a temporary organization; this was a
worldly matter and cannot be taken as a
religious sanction.
In short, by accepting this principle, not only is the organization of state established by the Khulafa’ stripped of religious status, but the measures taken by the Holy Prophet (sa) in this regard have to be declared worldly as well. One would have to admit that they were not a part of sunnah to be followed by the people of later generations.
After these introductory comments, I will now discuss the fundamental issues of Khilafat and the Islamic organization.
To fully comprehend this matter, it is necessary to understand that there are two types of religion in the world. First, those which confine their jurisdiction to certain types of prayers and doctrines, and treat worldly matters as separate. They do not interfere in worldly affairs, though they provide guidance on how to perform Salat, keep fast, give charity, or carry out obligations due to other people. In short, they give commands for worship and remembrance of Allah, but they do not give guidelines for such affairs as the development of an organization, economy, international affairs, trade, or inheritance.
Real Reason why sharia is called a Curse in Christianity
Christianity is one such religion. It emphatically alleges that the sharia is a curse, primarily, because they seek to set apart the personal behaviour of people from the checks and restraints of religion. For them, the only purpose of religion is to direct people to say Salat, observe fast, perform Hajj, pay Zakat, and accept Christ as God. They believe that the sharia has no authority to impose laws concerning murder, riots, thefts and organized robbery; nor to lay down guidelines on how nations should enter into treaties with one another, or control the economy. They argue, concerning the rights of men and women to inheritance, that the sharia again has nothing to do with it; rather, it is the duty of the parliament of a country to promulgate such laws as are in the interest of the nation. Similarly, they assert that if the government has decided to institute interest, whether in the shape of currency or goods, religion cannot declare that such money is unlawful. In short, they detest such commands of religion as are related to the organization, and thus, they declare the sharia to be a curse. This does not imply that fasting is a curse. Had it been a curse, it would not have been written in older editions of the Bible:
“But the only way to force out that kind of
demon is by praying and fasting.”
Is it possible that in the presence of such texts in the Gospels, the sharia be called a curse? The fact is that when the Christians declare the sharia to be a curse, they really mean that the authority of religion over the organization of a country is a curse. To them, religion has no control over affairs of the world; rather, a country can itself come up with rules and regulations of its own choice. Thus, they did away with restrictions imposed by the Mosaic sharia related to affairs of the state. No doubt, when ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ) uttered these words (assuming that he did indeed say so), he did not mean what they attribute to him. On the contrary, he meant that the Jews gave greater importance to injunctions than to the inner self and spirituality, and this became a curse for them and pushed them far away from truth.
When Christianity spread in Rome, people were not willing to relinquish their national constitution. They considered Roman law superior to every other law, in fact, European governments still benefit from Roman law. Therefore, the people of that time, who were very enlightened and possessed remarkable legal acumen, presumed that no one else could frame a better law than those. They acknowledged the goodness in the teachings of Christianity related to the love of God Almighty, miracles, Divine signs, prayers, and the sacrifices made by Christ. When they studied the teachings of Christianity, their hearts inclined towards it, and they admitted that this religion was worth accepting. At the same time, they could not bear that Judaic law, which they deemed inferior to Roman law, be enforced among them. Thus, they found themselves in utter dilemma.
On the one hand, they were attracted by the alluring teachings of Christianity, but on the other hand, their superiority complex concerning Roman law prevented them from bowing before Judaic law. In this state of confusion, they came across these lines in The New Testament:
“Anyone who tries to please God by obeying
the Law is under a curse.”
“But Christ rescued us from the Law’s curse,
when he became a curse in our place.”
These are not the words of Jesus, but are of Paul. Nevertheless, the Romans found an excuse, and by extending the implication of these sentences, they decided that religion had no authority to issue commands concerning affairs of the world, and that every nation could frame its own laws according to the requirements of these affairs.
‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ) (if these are his words) and his disciples only meant that the Jews placed excessive emphasis on the letter of the Law and completely ignored righteousness. This became the cause of their being accursed. They did not observe prayers except in name, and their hearts did not turn towards God Almighty with love and fear, so this type of prayer became a curse for them. They slaughtered animals for alms and charity, but they never slaughtered their ego, so this charity and sacrifice also became a curse for them. In their acts of worship, they apparently bowed their heads down before God Almighty, but their hearts never bowed before Him, so their worship also became a curse for them. They, no doubt, spent in charity and abandoned their wealth for sacrifice before God Almighty, but they were not ready to abandon their false ideas, so Zakat also became a curse for them. In short, the Jews laid greater emphasis on pretence and ignored inner purification; therefore, ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ) or his disciples had to point out that following the injunctions of the sharia in name without purifying the inner self is a curse. It did not mean that the sharia was a curse; rather, it meant that their ostentation and disregard for inner purification had become a curse for them. Nevertheless, the Romans found an excuse, and they misinterpreted these verses to mean that religion should be followed only in matters of prayer and fasting, but not in worldly matters, for religion has no authority over these matters. It is up to people to draft the law of their choice. The Romans, who called Christianity and the sharia a curse, forced people to abide by the laws which they drafted themselves. If the mere presence of a law had been a curse, they would not have enacted any law. They declared religion a curse on one hand and enacted various laws for their use on the other. This shows that according to them, the meaning of this verse was that only people had the right to make laws of their choice; religion had no right to present commandments dealing with temporal affairs. In this way, they freed themselves of those restrictions which were imposed by the Mosaic sharia related to affairs of the state.
Involvement of Judaism in the Institution of Government
The second type of religions are those which have broadened their jurisdiction and made rules and regulations for all spheres of life, including human activities, mutual relations, institutions of government, etc. The followers of these faiths must accept the authority of religion in the affairs of government. Individuals and societies must abide by these injunctions as obligatorily, just as they accept doctrines and commandments like prayers and fasting that affect personal life. Judaism is a good example of this type. If one studies Mosaic sharia, one will find all types of injunctions including, but not limited to, punishments prescribed for murder and theft, rules and regulations to be observed in war, principles governing sacrifice and also guidelines for transactions and trade. Thus, Judaism deals with matters related to government. Therefore, whoever studies the Mosaic sharia will conclude that religion has authority not only over individual matters, but also over the affairs of the nation and state.
Now we must determine what type of religion Islam is: does it belong to the first category or the second? For this purpose, we must see whether Islam has exerted authority over national matters or not. If Hadrat Muhammad (sa) dealt with national affairs out of his own desire or because of the dire needs of the nation, then it will have to be admitted that his actions are not binding on us. Just as when someone finds a stray child in a jungle and brings him in his home out of pity, it does not mean that he has the right of guardianship over him. Similarly, Hadrat Muhammad (sa) adopted orphans of Arabia out of feelings of pity for them, but this did not confer upon him the right of guardianship over them. Rather, when they came of age, they had the right to adopt a law of their own choice. On the contrary, if Islamic sharia does indeed include injunctions, then it will have to be admitted that the Holy Prophet (sa) did not interfere in these matters out of his own desire, rather, he did so when God Almighty commanded him. If this is proven, then it will in turn prove that the part of his life spent in the management of the affairs of state is religious in nature. The Muslims, who are bound by Islamic directives in a purely religious organization, are also not free in the matter of the organization of state, and are under obligation to submit to the organization of the state established by Islamic sharia. Even one glance at the Holy Qur’an and sayings of the Holy Prophet (sa) shows manifestly that Islam is not among the religions of the first category mentioned above but is of the second category. Islam issued commandments not only for certain beliefs and individual behaviour, but also for government and law. Therefore, it not only asks its followers to observe Salat, keep Fast, perform Hajj, and pay Zakat, but it also gives precepts related to government and law. It discusses the relationship between husband and wife, and makes clear what should be done and what measures should be taken towards mutual reconciliation in case of a dispute; if a man ever has to punish his wife physically, Islam gives directives on how much and what sort of punishment should be given. Similarly, it elaborates the principles of transactions, prescribes the number of witnesses in case of debt, and discusses the illegality of certain types of debt. It also mentions the principles of business and finance, and defines the laws governing testimonies upon which the organization of Qada