Foreword

Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 26

When some members of our Jama‘at were martyred in Afghanistan, we made a protest and by the grace of Allah, the Almighty it was so effective that it became the talk of the streets of London for six months, and the Ambassador of Afghanistan was put to great shame. Whenever he came out the people remarked, “Is this the liberty in your country”. But many Pathans are killed in Afghanistan, and nobody takes any notice of it. Due to the system of Jama‘at the members are getting many benefits. Therefore, when someone from a Jama‘at gets such a reward then it is said that the Jama‘at has received the reward, because the Jama‘at shares the rewards and benefits related to Khilafat or as a kingdom. As the whole nation is honoured through kingdom, so for this reason, it is said: [made you kings]. The whole Jama‘at has benefited by Khilafat. Therefore, it can also be said about Khilafat that you will be made Khalifah.

Khilafat is established through an

Electoral Process in Which the Whole Community is Involved

The second answer is that Khilafat is established through an electoral process and the whole Jama‘at is involved in the election. To put emphasis on election it is said:

The import is that this is a promise with the Jama‘at so this post cannot be inherited, but the Khalifah would be the person around whom the Jama‘at is gathered. The special emphasis is on the issue of election. It is mentioned that only he can be a Khalifah who has the support of the believers. No doubt, it is a Divine reward but it is a reward that Allah, the Almighty gives first to His believers. He admonishes them to hand it over to the most competent person amongst them by election. He gets the Khalifah elected by the believers so that Khilafat may not run on the basis of inheritance. For this purpose, the Jama‘at always elects the best person. Allah, the Almighty has promised the Muslim ummah:

To emphasize that the promise of Khilafat is national, and Allah, the Almighty will make Khalifah whomsoever He pleases through the hands of Jama‘at.

Why did Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) Nominate Hadrat Umar (ra)?

When it is said that the Khalifah can only be made by the election of Jama‘at then why did Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra) nominate Hadrat Umar (ra)? The answer is that he did not nominate someone on his own. His consultation with the Companions (ra) on this matter is a proven historical fact. The only difference is that the other Khulafa’ were elected after the death of their predecessors, and Hadrat Umar (ra) was elected in the life of Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra). He did not just merely hold consultation with some Companions (ra) and declare the Khilafat of Hadrat Umar (ra). In spite of his severe illness and weakness he came to the mosque with the support of his wife and addressed the people, “O people! After consultation with the Companions (ra) Hadrat Umar (ra) is my choice for Khilafat. Do you approve of his Khilafat”? On this all the people gave their approval, so this was also a type of election.

Can the Appointment of Yazid as Khalifah by Hadrat Muawiyah (ra) be Called Election?

If it is said that the appointment of Yazid by Muawiyah (ra) can also be called election because he also presented this matter before the people. The answer is that Muawiyah (ra) himself was not elected and when his own Khilafat is not proved, how can the Khilafat of his son be proved. We are ready to admit Yazid as successor of Muawiyah (ra) but we cannot call him a Khalifah. When the Khilafat of Muawiyah (ra) is not proved then how can that of his son be proved? As Muawiyah (ra) was a temporal king, we can admit Yazid to also be a temporal king. But neither Muawiyah was the Khalifah nor was his son.

Moreover, when Muawiyah consulted his people about his son, he was the ruler of those people. In such a situation his consultation cannot be called an election, because freedom of expression is necessary in such matters. When there is no freedom of expression, and the king asks the subject to take the Bai‘at of his son, how can the subjects be at liberty to give advice, or even to disobey his order? To give an example, if the king of Afghanistan were to ask his subjects to accept him as Khalifah, and upon their acceptance were to say that the people have elected him to rule; this would not be an election, nor can such type of counselling be called consultation. Real consultation only takes place when the people are free to express their opinions, and every one is at liberty to propose the name of his choice. Thus, firstly Muawiyah himself was not a Khalifah but a king. Secondly, he presented the matter of the Khilafat of his son to the people during his rule. This cannot be called consultation or election in any way.

It is against the Sunnah of Companions (ra) that a Father Should propose His Son for Khilafat

The father’s nomination of his son for Khilafat also indicates that it was not a real election because the nomination by the father is against the sunnah of the Companions (ra). When Hadrat Umar (ra) was on his death bed, many delegations came to him and all unanimously suggested that his son Abdullah was the most suitable person for Khilafat after him, and they asked him to appoint his son Khalifah. But he said that for a long time the Muslims had been under the rule of his family, and now he wanted to let someone else have this blessing. If the people had elected his son Abdullah for Khilafat after his death that would have been something different, but the nomination by Hadrat Umar (ra) would not have been lawful. Similarly, if Muawiyah (ra) had not presented the case of Yazid before the people in his presence, and later on, the people had elected him, we could have called him an elected king. But now we can neither call him Khalifah nor an elected king. We do not call Muawiyah (ra) sinful, as he did it under the pressure of the circumstances. But we cannot give the title of Khilafat to Yazid, nor to Muawiyah (ra). We can only call them kings.

When the case of Yazid was presented before the people by Muawiyah (ra), the Companions (ra) of that time considered it a mockery. For them it had no significance. History shows that when Muawiyah (ra) addressed the people saying: “O Muslims! You know that my family is one of the chiefs of Arabia, so who is more entitled for rule than I, and after me who is more entitled than my son”. Hadrat Abdullah bin Umar (ra) was also sitting in a corner. When he heard Muawiyah (ra) say this he unknotted the cloth wrapped around his feet with the intent of standing up to tell Muawiyah (ra), “O Muawiyah (ra), the one who is more entitled for this post than you, is the person whose father has fought against your father under the flag of the Prophet (sa), and who has himself fought in the Islamic armies against you and your father”. But then he thought that the worldly things had no significance for him and his saying anything at that time would create a disturbance, and weaken the power of Muslims. So he remained sitting and did not speak against Muawiyah (ra). To sum up, the Companions (ra) considered the act of Muawiyah (ra) quite absurd and attached no value to it.

Not to speak of the consent of other people to the Khilafat of Yazid, his own son did not agree to it. Immediately after his accession to throne, he went into seclusion and surrendered the throne. It is a well- known historical event, but I am not sure why Muslim historians have not highlighted it. They should have repeated it frequently because it is another clear proof of the atrocities of Yazid.

It is recorded that after the death of Yazid, his son, who was also named Muawiyah (ra) after his grandfather, acceded to throne and went home after taking the Bai‘at of the people. He did not come out for forty days. When he came out, he rose to the pulpit and addressed the people that he had accepted the Bai‘at from them, not because he was more entitled to it, but because he did not want dissention among them. He had been continuously meditating in his home to find a person more entitled to take the Bai‘at of the people so that he might get himself relieved of chiefdom by handing it over to him. But in spite of his great efforts he did not find any such person. Therefore, he said, “O people listen to it carefully that I am not fit for this post. I also want to tell you that my father and grandfather were also not entitled to this post. My father was inferior to Husain (ra), and his father from the father of Hasan (ra) and Husain (ra). Hadrat Ali (ra) at his time was more entitled for Khilafat than my grandfather, and after this Hasan (ra) and Husain (ra) were more entitled than my father. Therefore, I retire from this chiefdom, and you can take the Bai‘at of the person of your choice.” At that time his mother heard the speech behind the veil, and she burst out: “O wretched, you have dishonoured your family and damaged its dignity”. He replied, “I have said what is true, now it is your turn to say whatever you like”. He then remained confined to his home, and died after a few days.

What great evidence it is that, not to speak of others, even his own son did not agree to the Khilafat of Yazid. He did not do so for some vested interest nor did he oppose it due to the fear of any opposition. He made a decision after serious meditation that Hadrat Ali (ra) was more entitled than his grandfather, and Hasan (ra) and Husain (ra) than his father, and he himself was not ready to take the responsibility. Therefore, appointment of Yazid by Muawiyah (ra) cannot be called an election.

Commentary of the Promised Messiah (as) on Ayat-e-Istikhlaf

The third answer for Ahmadis is that the Promised Messiah (as), commenting upon this verse has written in Sirrul-Khilafah that:

Abul Karam Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Karim bin Abdul Wahid Ash-shibani, known as Ibnil Athir, publisher Daru Sadir, Dar Beirut, AH 1385, AD 1965.

·

10 of 10 left today