Foreword
Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 27
Qadian (as), Vol. 8, p. 334.
“In these verses Allah, the Almighty has
promised Muslim men and women that He will
make some believers from among them
Khalifah by His grace and mercy.”
Since the Promised Messiah (as) mentions that:
does not refer to the whole nation, but only to some individuals in the ummah, no Ahmadi can take it to mean the whole community.
The fourth answer is also for Ahmadis. the Promised Messiah (as) has repeatedly inferred his Khilafat-e-Muhammadiyya from this verse and has included the Khilafat-e-Nubuwwat in it. And it is evident that Khilafat-e-Nubuwwat cannot apply to the whole nation but only to some specific individuals. To illustrate, wherever the Holy Qur’an mentions the kingdom, it uses the expression or He made you kings. But when Nubuwwat is mentioned then it is said, or, “He has appointed Prophets from you”. The reason for this difference is that we can say that God granted kingdom to a nation but it cannot be said that nation has been appointed as Prophet. Therefore, if the promise of Nubuwwat can be fulfilled through some individuals, even when the whole nation is addressed, then the promise of Khilafat can also be fulfilled through some individuals even when the whole nation is addressed. The way one part of the promise is fulfilled, can also be the way the other part would be fulfilled.
The fifth answer is that the acts of Allah, the Almighty provide evidence of the actual meaning of this verse. Allah, the Almighty says:
Meaning that He would appoint those who believe and do good deeds Khulafa’ in the same way as He appointed them to earlier people. If Allah, the Almighty meant for the establishment of democracy then we should have seen democracy established after the Prophet (sa), or if it was the plan of Allah, the Almighty that some persons of ummah will get Khilafat and all the people will be entitled to have the blessings of Khilafat, then we should have seen whether or not Khilafat was established among the Muslims in this way. However, the way God fulfilled this promise after the Prophet (sa) can be the meaning of this verse because nobody can fulfill the promise of Allah, the Almighty better than He Himself. With this point of view when we study the circumstances after the death of the Prophet (sa), we find that only a few individuals were bestowed Khilafat; not all of them. Therefore, either believe that after the death of the Prophet (sa) the people did not remain worthy of being called [those who believe and do good works], or as Shia believe that there were left only two and a half believers in ummah. In this way you will have to declare that all who were left were hypocrites (God forbid), so the promise of national Khilafat could not be fulfilled by them. But if they were on the path of their faith and acts of goodness then who can be more worthy to fulfill the promise than them? However, the way that Allah, the Almighty established Khilafat amongst the Muslims after the Prophet (sa) is the only evidence needed to show that the promise with the people is fulfilled through individuals.
Resemblance of the Four Khulafa’ with the Previous Ones is not Necessary in Every Matter
The second objection to this verse is that the Khilafat of specific individuals is promised in this verse. However, it is a shared common belief that the Khilafat of the previous Khulafa’ was either through Prophethood or through kingdom, but then it is also agreed that the four Khulafa’ after the Holy Prophet (sa) were neither prophets nor kings. Then how was this promise fulfilled, and how can it be a testimony of this verse? The answer is that there is no doubt that the previous Khulafa’ were bestowed Khilafat either by way of Prophethood or in the shape of kingdom, but the resemblance does not mean complete identity in everything. Resemblance is only seen in principle. To illustrate, we may talk of the heights of two persons and say one is as tall as the other. There would be no point in someone’s asserting that they do not resemble each other because one of them is a thief and the other is a devoted worshipper; or that one is the scholar and the other is illiterate. In this case, resemblance will only be seen in height and not in other traits. There are instances of this in the Holy Qur’an. Allah, the Almighty says:
“Verily, We have sent to you a Messenger, who
is a witness over you, even as We sent a
Messenger to Pharoah.”
Allah, the Almighty has pointed out the resemblance of the Holy Prophet (sa) and Hadrat Musa (as) (Moses), whereas Hadrat Musa (as) (Moses) was sent to Pharoah and the Holy Prophet (sa) was not sent to any such king. Similarly Hadrat Musa (as) (Moses) was sent for the guidance of Bani Isra’il but the Holy Prophet (sa) was sent for the guidance of the whole world. The period of the Prophethood of Hadrat Musa (as) (Moses)
extended to few centuries and, at last, it came to an end. But the period of the Prophethood of the Holy Prophet (sa) extends to the Day of Resurrection. Thus, there are important differences in the lives of Hadrat Musa (as) (Moses) and the Holy Prophet (sa). In spite of these differences the Muslims affirm that the Holy Qur’an says that the Holy Prophet (sa) resembles Hadrat Musa (as) (Moses), whereas the Holy Prophet (sa) was sent neither to a king like Paroah nor some particular nation but to the whole world; and neither did his Prophethood come to an end in any age like that of Musa (as) (Moses) . If these differences do not bring any change in resemblances then there is no harm when the Khulafa’ of Islam partly differ from the Khulafa’ of the past. In fact the resemblance of the Prophet (sa) is only in the sense that just as Musa (as) (Moses) was bestowed a book of sharia that was complete and covered all the subject matter to meet the needs of that age, similarly the Holy Prophet (sa) was bestowed the book of sharia which is perfect and covers all the subject matter to meet the needs of humankind till the Day of Resurrection, and is superior and exalted above the Old Testament. Just as the community established by Hadrat Musa (as) (Moses) continued after him through the Prophets; similarly, whenever there arises any deficiency in Ummat-e-Muhammadiyyah, Allah, the Almighty sends some persons who reform the ummah. Their resemblance also shows that just as a Messiah came thirteen hundred years after Hadrat
Musa (as) (Moses), the Promised Messiah (as) would come in Ummat-e-Muhammadiyyah after thirteen hundred years.
It is not the case that because Hadrat Musa (as) (Moses) was for a specific period and for a particular nation, the Prophethood of the Holy Prophet (sa) is also for specific period and for a particular nation. So if there is a resemblance of Khulafa’-e-Rashidin in some matters with the Khilafat of the previous Khulafa’ then we’ll have to admit their resemblances. It is not necessary that they should have resemblance in every matter. The real point is that just as some individuals were raised to rejuvenate the people after the death of earlier Prophets, similarly, after the death of the Holy Prophet (sa), Allah, the Almighty would raise such personalities to rejuvenate his ummah, and this objective was comparatively better achieved by the Khulafa’ of the Holy Prophet (sa) than the previous Khulafa’. No doubt, the successors to Hadrat Musa (as) (Moses) were Prophets, as were the successors to Hadrat Ibrahim (as) (Abraham), as well as other Prophets (as); but can anyone say that the establishment of faith that was achieved through these Prophets was not achieved by the Khulafa’ of the Holy Prophet (sa). If we analyze the circumstances with wisdom and insight we will have to say that Joshua (as), Isma’il (as) (Ishmael), Ishaq (as) (Issac) and Ya‘qub (as) (Jacob (as)) could not do for the establishment of their religion, what was done by Abu Bakr (ra), Umar (ra), Usman (ra) and Ali (ra). An ignorant person may say that my statement about the Prophets is derogatory, but there is actually no element of humiliation in it. When it comes to the question of Prophethood, we’ll say that Abu Bakr (ra) was not a prophet nor was Umar (ra), or Usman (ra), or Ali (ra). But when there is a question of the establishment of religion, we’ll say that in this matter, the Khulafa’ who succeeded the Holy Prophet (sa) are surely greater than the previous Prophets.
The fact is this that since Prophets who were raised before the Holy Prophet (sa) did not bring complete sharia, either Prophets were raised or kings were appointed after them. When there was the need of revelation for the reformation of the public, a Prophet was raised, and he got the status of Prophethood directly. When there was a problem in the system, a king was appointed. The people had not yet reached the maturity to manage their own affairs. Therefore, Allah, the Almighty directly assigned not only the status of Prophethood but also of kingship. It is said in the Holy Qur’an: [Allah has appointed for you Talut as a king (Al-Baqarah, 2:248)]. The people were still not capable of electing their king nor was the sharia so perfect so as to enable one of its followers the acquisition of Prophethood.
On the other hand, the Holy Prophet (sa) brought a complete code of life, so it resulted in a distinctive status for both types of Khulafa’. The Khulafa’ of the previous Prophets were Prophets though they were bestowed Prophethood directly. If the kings were appointed to run the administration, they were not elected but they acquired kingdom either by inheritance or appointment by a Prophet appointed under the command of Allah, the Almighty. As the followers of the Holy Prophet (sa) were exalted, there was no need of Prophet Khulafa’ after him. Similarly, the lesser form of kingdom was also abolished, and a perfect form was granted. It is evident that the promise is fulfilled with the Muslims is through Islamic Khilafat—the element of election is included, and the public rights are preserved. This was not the case of the previous kings. The creation of a better situation is not against the promise. For example, if you promise someone to give him five rupees it would not be a violation of the promise to pay him ten rupees. It only means that just as the Holy Prophet (sa) was superior to the previous ones, so his Khulafa’ are also superior to those of the previous Prophets.
“The Ulema of my Ummah are like the Prophets of Bani Isra’il’ Refers only to the Spiritual Khulafa”
The second answer is this that the Holy Prophet (sa) says, i.e. “The Ulema of my ummah are like the Prophets of Bani Isra’il”. It does not mean that every scholar among the Muslims is like the Prophet of Bani Isra’il, because there are also socalled scholars whose religious and moral condition is very depressing. At the age of ten or eleven, I went to Amritsar to purchase a few things with my maternal grandfather (deceased). I saw a Maulawi wearing a long cloak with a staff and a rosary in his hand, walking in Rambagh. Behind him was a poor person begging him repeatedly, “Maulawi Sahib, for God’s sake give me my money.” After walking a few steps the Maulawi turned back and said, “Go away, you wretch!” At last the poor man was tired and left him. I asked him what the matter was. He told me that he saved about two hundred rupees with great difficulty for his marriage and, considering the Maulawi a religious person, he left the money with him as trust. But now on his demand the Maulawi refused to pay it back, and denied recognizing him as well as his deposit. Can such Ulema be like the Prophets of Bani Isra’il? Can it be said that the Hadith of the Prophet (sa) is concerned with such shameless Islamic “scholars”.
The fact is that the Ulema mentioned in this Hadith are actually the Khulafa’ who are the spiritual Ulema. The meaning of this saying of the Prophet (sa) is that the tasks that were performed by Prophets in earlier times would now be entrusted by Allah, the Almighty to some divinely guided Ulema, i.e. the Khulafa’-e- Rashidin. Just as, after Hadrat Musa (as) (Moses), his work was entrusted to Joshua (as), now this work would be entrusted to Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra). The work of Hadrat David (as) would be performed by Hadrat Umar (ra), and the work of some other Prophets, e.g. Hadrat Suleman (as), would be performed by Hadrat Usman (ra) and Hadrat Ali (ra). In short, the Holy Prophet (sa) has pointed out in his sayings that Allah, the Almighty has given him such a status that in his ummah the Khulafa’ will perform the deeds that were performed in earlier times by the Prophets. Here Ulema does not refer to the corrupt ones, but to the scholars Hadrat Abu Bakr (ra), Hadrat Umar (ra), Hadrat Usman (ra), and Hadrat Ali (ra). As long as the need remained limited, Allah, the Almighty raised these Ulema, and then when the age was in need of a Prophet more manifestly, Allah, the Almighty fulfilled His promise through the Promised Messiah (as). The difference is that the previous Prophets received Prophethood directly but the Promised Messiah (as) obtained his Prophethood by total submission to the Holy Prophet (sa).
The third objection is that in this verse the words are [as He made Successors from among those who were before them]. Granted that the previous Khulafa’ fulfilled this promise, because they headed a political system. But how can the present Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya satisfy this promise, because it does not have any political system under it.