Foreword
Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 4
(Justice) is based. Thus, it specifies the types of witnesses and their numbers, and the issues that should be taken into consideration while reviewing their testimonies as well. Likewise, it gives various instructions about the judiciary and mentions how judges should pass a judgment. It also prescribes physical punishments for various crimes which come under the authority of government, e.g. the sentence for murder and theft. It outlines the laws of inheritance, restricts the government’s jurisdiction of taxation, gives details about taxes, and defines the authority of the government in relation to the expenditure of these taxes. Rules for the army and rules governing treaties between nations are also set forth. Similarly, it gives basic principles for international relations. It also specifies rules for employees and employers, and even for roads. In short, Islam defines all matters concerned with government. Thus, it cannot be said that Islam has given free reign to government; rather, it has discussed every department of government in details. Whosoever follows Islam, and finds details of all commands related to government, cannot deny the relationship between government and religion. On the contrary, he will have to admit that those acts of the Holy Prophet (sa) which are related to government are as binding as the principles of Salat, Fasting, etc. This is because the God Who commands us to pray, fast, perform Hajj, and pay Zakat has also given guidelines for the political affairs and organization of a country. It cannot be said that every nation and every country is at liberty to invent an organization of its own choice; rather, it has to follow Islamic rules in all spheres of life. If the Holy Prophet (sa) had adopted these of his own choice, we could have argued that people were free in this respect. However, when we admit that these rules and regulations have been described in the Holy Qur’an, and that the Holy Prophet (sa) narrated them under the command of God Almighty, then it shows that it was not the personal approach of the Holy Prophet (sa).
Considering that the Holy Qur’an has revealed all the basic precepts of governance, it would be unreasonable to assume that it does not clarify how government should implement them. It would be like a person who collects timber, windows, doors, paint, etc. to build a house, but when asked about the expected time of construction and proposed drawing of the house, he shows complete ignorance. Clearly, when he arranged for the bricks, had the doors, windows, and ventilators made, and acquired the lime and clay, his purpose was to build a house and not to let all these things go waste. Similarly, when the Holy Qur’an has mentioned all these things related to government, then the human mind cannot accept that it has not given commands on how to run government and the type of organization the Islamic government should have. If it does not make this clear, then one would have to admit that the Holy Qur’an (God forbid) is flawed.
Comprehensive Guidance of Islam about all Institutions of Government
As Islam has given detailed guidelines for all the institutions of government, one cannot say that religion has nothing to do with these matters and that every nation and every country is free to choose a suitable organization for itself. One can argue on whether the Islamic sharia has granted individual freedom in certain matters, but it would be illogical to assert that Islam discusses minor issues but ignores the most important issue, the issue of the rights of a person against the government and how the government should implement Divine commands in its jurisdiction. If this statement were taken as true, then we would be admitting that religion is flawed. A religion which declares the sharia to be a curse can argue that these matters are beyond its jurisdiction; and for the reason that it does not give clear guiding principle for every aspect of human life, it is considered imperfect. For example, if such a religion does not discuss the relation of man with God, the relation between men, or provide guidelines for the affairs of government and politics, it can escape blame because it declares the sharia a curse. On the other hand, a religion that deals with these matters and accepts the authority of God the Almighty to provide guidance in all these matters, but overlooks such an important issue and endangers the lives of billions of people, will definitely be negligent and defective.
After this introduction, I now come to the actual issue. The Holy Prophet (sa) was raised in Arabia, and Arabia had no written constitution. For them, their tribal customs were law. Each tribe had a law of its own. They would decide their disputes according to their tribal customs, or, whenever they felt the need for an agreement, they would do so accordingly. When the Holy Prophet (sa) came, he presented the Divine sharia and told them that God had sent these teachings for them to practice. The Holy Prophet (sa) had them [Arabs] follow it. If the Holy Qur’an, a Divine scripture, had confined itself to the injunctions of Salat, Fasting, and some other beliefs, and the Holy Prophet (sa) himself had prescribed political and national measures and had implemented them by force, one could have argued that: The Arabs destroyed their own government by brutally attacking the Muslims, thus leaving the country devoid of any organization and law; due to this difficulty and because of the dire need of the time, the Holy Prophet (sa) introduced and enforced some laws in order to save the country from chaos, but these steps were not a part of his religion.
However, we see not only that detailed commandments for these matters are present in the Holy Qur’an, but that there are also guidelines for their implementation. For example (1) Allah, the Almighty says in surah Al-Hashr:
“And Whatsoever the messenger gives you, take it; and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain from that.”
In other words, the commands given by the Holy Prophet (sa) are binding upon the Muslims in all circumstances. (2) At another place, Allah, the Almighty says:
“But no, by thy Lord, they are not believers until they make thee judge in all that is in dispute between them and then find not in their hearts any demur concerning that which thou decidest and submit with full submission.” Some people used to raise this objection—and even today some critics say—that the Holy Prophet (sa), (God forbid) had no authority to issue guidelines for the settlement of mutual disputes and for the establishment of an organization. However, Allah says, We reject them in this matter and openly declare:
They cannot be declared believers until they make you, O Muhammad (sa), the judge in all their disputes, and then submit whole-heartedly to what you decide.
Two very important matters are mentioned in this noble verse.
Firstly, God the Almighty declares the Holy Prophet (sa) the final Justice and treats his decision as final; no one will ever have the right to challenge it. The fact that the Holy Prophet (sa) was declared to be the final Justice shows that he had been granted the right of governance by Allah, the Almighty.
Secondly, it becomes evident from this verse that Allah, the Almighty considers submission to his decrees a part of faith. He says that:
i.e. By thy Lord! They can never be believers until they submit themselves to your decrees.
Thus, this is also a part of faith, just as Salat, Fasting, Hajj, and Zakat are parts of faith. Suppose two people have a quarrel. One says that ten dollars are due from the other, and the other denies this claim. Both come to the Holy Prophet (sa) and put their dispute before him. The Holy Prophet (sa) decides the case in favour of one of them. If the other does not submit to the decision, then Allah, the Almighty calls him a disbeliever, despite the fact that he might be following Islamic injunctions of Salat, Fasting, and Hajj. Allah, the Almighty gives His decree against that person, that he does not remain a believer if he does not abide by the decision given by the Holy Prophet (sa). Thus, the words reveal that God Almighty has declared this a part of religion and does not treat it separately.
(3) It is said in a third verse:
When God and His messenger call the believers and say, come, we will decide your disputes, their response is that we hear and we obey. We have heard the command of the Holy Prophet (sa) and we shall always obey him.
Allah, the Almighty says: These are the people who will always succeed and will always be victorious.
The fact that Allah, the Almighty has, on one hand, linked submission to the decisions of the Holy Prophet (sa) with faith, and on the other hand, called those people triumphant who say, “we hear and we obey”, and do not go against his decisions, shows that the approval of God is in all these matters. If one does not obey these commands, then the punishment of
God befalls him and renders him unsuccessful. However, this does not apply to worldly matters where only natural consequences come forth.
(4) Then Allah, the Almighty says:
Meaning, those who follow him who is the Prophet (sa) of God, His Messenger, and the Immaculate one, about whom there are prophecies in the Torah and Gospel, know that he always enjoins on them good and forbids them from evil. It is as if he enforces a law on the people and guides them in what they should do and what they should not. He enjoins goodness and forbids them from evil. He gives appropriate instructions for human behaviour, speech, and eating habits. He tells them what to do and what not to do; what to say and what not to say. Similarly, he removes the burdens from them which had become unbearable for them, and releases them from their shackles that have blocked their path to progress.
So those who believe in this Prophet (sa), and honour his commands and support him, help him, and follow the light that has been sent down with him—these shall prosper in this world and the hereafter.
It is obvious that governments always make similar laws, permitting some things and prohibiting others. The Holy Qur’an declares that the authority pertaining to a government is given to Hadrat Muhammad (sa). Those who follow him will prosper and those who deviate from it will be unsuccessful.