Foreword
Khilafat-e-Rashidah, Part 8
Malik bin Hisham bin Ayyub Al-Himyari Al-Mu‘afiri, published by Darul Kutubil ‘Ilmiyyah, Beirut, Lebanon. First edition, AH. 1420, AD. 2000.
Rahman Al-Barquti. Published by Al-Matba‘ Rahmaniyyah, Egypt. AH 1347, AD 1929.
the Prophet (sa) was ever asked, “O Messenger of Allah, when you pass away, then what will happen? Will there will be Khilafat, or parliament, or a committee to look after the affairs of the Muslims?” Only a hardhearted person can speak on such matters, or one who is devoid of love for a Prophet and unaware of his greatness. The Ahadith show that the Companions (ra) enquired from him about many problems and received information by putting questions, but the issue of succession was one which the Companions (ra) could not ask about, nor could they think of it, for they thought that he would outlive them. Thus, this issue, to some extent, remained veiled, and the death of the Prophet (sa) was the real time of its disclosure.
These were the state of affairs at the time of the death of the Prophet (sa). Upon his demise, the Companions (ra) felt a great shock. It was the first time they realized that it was possible for the Prophet (sa) to be separated from them; for the first time, the importance of their need for an organization, in accordance to the ways and wishes of the Prophet (sa), dawned upon them in its true significance, and they began to reflect on its different aspects. No doubt, the details of the organization are present in the Holy Qur’an, but they remained veiled to them and they never discussed them. They read them in some other context. They did not interpret them in such ways as would reveal to them what they should do after the death of the Prophet (sa).
Every Prophet has Two Lives (I) Personal, (II) National
There is Divine wisdom working behind this devoted love, because there are two lives of a Prophet—one is personal and the other is national. Allah, the Almighty initiates both these lives by revelation. The personal life of a Prophet starts with revelation as follows: When he is thirty or forty years old, revelation begins descending upon him, and he is called a Messenger for the guidance and purification of people. As a result of these revelations, he sees extraordinary blessings of Allah, the Almighty descending upon him, and feels a new vigour, a new life, and new nobility.
The national life of a Prophet also starts with revelation. When he passes away, the organization which is initiated after his demise is not based on any ready-made scheme. Rather, an instant change occurs, and Allah, the Almighty diverts the hearts of people toward that organization by an indirect revelation.
Prophet’s Personal Life is First
Manifestation of Divine Power and his National Life is Second
Just as Allah, the Almighty starts the personal life of a Prophet with revelation, in the same way, his national life, which starts after his demise, begins with revelation. Thus, there is a resemblance between the two. This is why the Promised Messiah (as) has named it the Second Manifestation of Divine Power. The First Manifestation of Divine Power is the personal life of the Prophet, and the Second Manifestation is his national life. Since Allah, the Almighty lays the foundations of his national life with revelation and by His Divine Power, He keeps its details veiled from the eyes of people in the life of the Prophet. When the Prophet passes away, Allah, the Almighty diverts the attention of people to the details of this life by indirect revelation. It is stated in the Gospels that after the demise of ‘Isa (as) (Jesus Christ), his disciples gathered at one place, and the Holy Spirit descended upon them and they started speaking many different languages. Though the authors of the Gospels have turned it into an absurd story, the incident makes it clear that after the assumed demise of Christ, there was a sudden change in the hearts of the disciples, of which they had no hint of before. They had to attribute this change to Divine Power. In short, Allah, the Almighty starts the new life of a Prophet like the personal one, with His revelation and Divine Power. That is why the details of his new life are kept veiled from the eyes of people during the life of Prophet.
Here I want to mention an interesting incident. There has been a prolonged dispute between the Shias and Sunnis, which is called the dispute of Qirtas [folio]. It is mentioned in Ahadith that when the Holy
Prophet (sa) was suffering severely in his final illness, he asked the Companions (ra) to bring a folio, a pen, and inkpot, so that he might dictate for them something which would keep them rightly guided. The Shias assert that the Holy Prophet (sa) wanted to dictate that Hadrat Ali (ra) would be the Khalifah after him, and that he should be honoured as their Imam. They say that Hadrat Umar (ra) did not let him dictate, and asked the people to leave the matter, saying that the Holy Prophet (sa) was in great suffering, and it was not advisable to trouble him, and that the Holy Qur’an being sufficient as guidance, nothing else was required. The Shias call this the connivance of Hadrat Umar (ra), that in order to usurp sovereignty from Hadrat Ali (ra), he did not let the Holy Prophet (sa) dictate a will. They say that if he had let the Holy Prophet (sa) dictate a will, he would have dictated in favour of Hadrat Ali (ra). There are many answers to this objection, but I will give only two at this time.
First, if the Holy Prophet (sa) wanted to dictate a will of Khilafat in favour of Hadrat Ali (ra), then why, on the intervention of Hadrat Umar (ra), did he not ask again for the pen and inkpot? He, after all, should know that the attempt of Hadrat Umar (ra), being an enemy of Hadrat Ali (ra) (God forbid), could not benefit Hadrat Ali (ra) in any way. In such a situation, the Holy Prophet (sa) would have surely asked of Hadrat Umar (ra) the reason for his conduct. He, no doubt, was suffering, but he did not take any notice of it. He could have ordered that the pen and inkpot be brought quickly, so that he might dictate something, but he did not ask for the pen and inkpot a second time. When Hadrat Umar (ra) said that the Book of God was sufficient as guidance, the Holy Prophet (sa) kept quiet. It clearly means that the Holy Prophet (sa) wanted to dictate the same thing as was stated by Hadrat Umar (ra). After hearing the commitment of the Companions (ra) to act according to the Book of God, the Holy Prophet (sa) felt no need to dictate a separate will. Therefore, this incident does not convict Hadrat Umar (ra) in any way, rather it shows how close his thinking was to that of the Holy Prophet (sa).
The second answer, which provides great historical evidence as a conclusive rebuttal of the baseless ideas of the Shias, is the following: On such occasions, a will is dictated by a person who is on his death bed. If the will is not dictated at that time, then there no opportunity is left to do so. However, a person who has hope that Allah, the Almighty will grant him recovery from a simple ailment gives no importance to a will and considers it useless to trouble himself with it. When we consider these incidents in light of the circumstances which the Companions (ra) faced on the demise of the Holy Prophet (sa), we find that Hadrat Umar (ra) had no notion of taking sovereignty in his hands when the Holy Prophet (sa) was about to depart. When the Holy Prophet (sa) passed away, the shock was so severe and sudden, and so contrary to expectations, that it made Hadrat Umar (ra) somewhat senseless, and he did not believe in any way that the Holy Prophet (sa) had passed away. He was the one who, even after the demise of the Holy Prophet (sa), did not believe that he had passed away, and whose heart was full of the hope of his revival, and who came forward with a sword in his hand announcing that whoever would say that the Holy Prophet (sa) had died would be killed. How can it be imagined that such a person assumed that the Holy Prophet (sa) was about to die and stopped him from dictating something in favour of Hadrat Ali (ra). Rather, when we consider events from the perspective of the Shias, we find that certain doubts may possibly be raised against Hadrat Ali (ra), who appeared to be expecting the demise of the Holy Prophet (sa). On the other hand, Hadrat Umar (ra), in the intensity of love, appeared to be expecting his recovery from what he believed was a simple ailment, and hoping that he would not die. Thus, this situation, from the Shia perspective, raises some questions about Hadrat Ali (ra). However, it does not malign Hadrat Umar (ra); indeed, it proves his nobility, righteousness, and excellence.
Allah, the Almighty Starts National Life of a Prophet with Revelation
I was pointing out that after the demise of a Prophet, Allah, the Almighty starts his national life by revelation. Therefore, Allah, the Almighty keeps the establishment of Khilafat and its details veiled until the demise of the Prophet. In the circumstances under which the Holy Prophet (sa) passed away, some Companions (ra) initially considered that he had not passed away, but when they came to know of his demise, they were struck with shock and grief. They started agonizing over what should be done and what steps should be taken to continue the mission of the Holy Prophet (sa)? In such confusion and pain, they moved here and there, and consequently, in a short time, they were divided into two groups, which, later on, became three.
Three Groups of Companions (ra) after the Demise of the Holy Prophet (sa)
One group thought that, after the Holy Prophet (sa), there should be a person who would establish an Islamic system. They thought that as the family members of the Holy Prophet (sa) were considered the best judges of his wishes, thus, a Successor should be from the family of the Holy Prophet (sa), and not from any other family. They believed that if a Successor were chosen from another family, people would not obey him, and thus the Islamic organization would be jeopardized. If the Khalifah was chosen from his family, then the people, who were used to obeying the family of the Holy Prophet (sa) would obey him willingly as well, just as when a king dies and his son becomes his Successor people obey him willingly, just as they obeyed the father.
The other group thought that the condition of choosing from the family members of the Holy Prophet (sa) was not necessary. The purpose was to have a Successor to the Holy Prophet (sa). They thought that whoever was more competent should be entrusted with the responsibility.
This second group was further divided in two sections. Although they agreed that there should be a Successor of the Holy Prophet (sa), they differed on which people the Successor should be from. One group was in favour of a person who had been under his supervision for a long time, and for this, the deserving person should be from the Muhajirin [Immigrants], and especially the Quraish, whom the Arabs would obey willingly. The other group thought that, as the Holy Prophet (sa) passed away in Medina where the Ansar [Helpers] were in majority, they could fulfil this obligation best.