The Light of The Holy Qur’an - Number One
The Light of the Holy Qur’an, Part 8
Here seemingly an objection arises; namely, if an idolater says: ‘Even though I concede that idolatry was uprooted at the hands of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, I do not accept that idolatry was bad. On the contrary, I say that it alone was the right path from which the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, barred them. Thus, it follows that he did not reform the world, rather he erased the path of goodness.’ Similarly, if a Zoroastrian says that: ‘I accept that in reality the Holy Prophet s (as) truly abolished fire worship, and also totally erased the name and any vestige of sun worship, but I will not accept that this was a good deed, rather that was indeed the true path that he erased.’ Likewise, if a Christian says that: ‘Even though I admit that the Holy Prophets (as) uprooted the Christian doctrine from Arabia, I cannot categorize this as an act of reformation and that it was a good deed whereby the worship of Jesus and his mother was prohibited and the crosses and images were broken, rather the path that was opposed was the only righteous path.’ Similarly, gamblers, alcoholics, adulterers, murderers of girls, misers, spendthrifts, those who prefer to commit all kinds of atrocities and dishonest acts, together with thieves, thugs, and dacoits advance arguments of their own, saying that even though they admit and accept that Islam dealt with their sects very efficiently and meted out strict punishments to thousands of thieves, liberating vast swathes of land from their evil and mischief, yet in their opinion, they were unjustly persecuted. For, they used to steal and rob by putting their lives on the line. Therefore, the looted goods that they seized after so much effort were lawful for them and they were unjustly persecuted and an age-old custom, which had become a religious ritual, was abolished.
The reply to all these groups is that no one from among these sects will admit any wrongdoing on their part, but some of them stand witness against others. For example, a person who worships Ramchandra and Krishna Jee and deifies them, will never repent of it and declare them mere mortals, but will continue to stress the point that both these sages possessed the light to the Universal Soul and were Divine despite being mortals. They embodied within them one aspect of creation and one aspect of Divinity. Their [aspect of ] creation was temporal and the shortcomings of creation—like death, grief, and eating or drinking—were all temporal, but their Divinity is eternal and the attributes of Divinity are also eternal. However, if it is said to them: ‘Gentlemen! If this is the case then please also accept the Divinity of Ibn Maryam [the Son of Mary], and take pity on the poor Christians who promote this propaganda day and night as the proverb goes,
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
رس ذگتش ہچ [When water passes over the head, then what difference does it make if it is a cubit over the head or a yard?]’ In response, these people reject the Messiah with such disrespect that let alone Divinity, they even deny his prophethood. More than that, they often go so far as to abuse him, and say: ‘What comparison does he bear with Shri Maharaj Barham Moorat Ramchandra
Jee and Krishan Gopal Rudder? He was a mere mortal who made a false claim to prophethood. What earthly comparison is there between Shri Maharaj Krishan Jee and Jesus, Son of Mary?’ And surprisingly, if these two great avatars are mentioned before the Christians, they too, not only deny their Divinity, but also show disrespect even though these two sages were the very first to lay the foundation of deification in this world and they were progenitors of the lesser gods. The Son of Mary and others came after them and are their offshoots. The Christians, in deifying Jesus, have followed in the footsteps of these very people who had deified the above Mahatmas, as has been pointed out by the Noble Qur’an. See the verse:
Meaning that, the Jews say that Ezra is the son of Allah, and the Christians say the Messiah is the son of Allah; they are but words of their mouth. They imitate those people who disbelieved before them by deifying men. Oh how the people cursed by Allah are turned away! So, this verse pointedly refers to the Hindus and the Greeks, saying that these were the people who had deified men before. Then, as the ill luck of Christians would have it, these doctrines reached them and they thought, why should they stay behind these nations? It was their wretched luck that the Torah already contained an expression in which men had been referred to as ‘sons of God’ at certain places, and even ‘daughters of God’, and some of the earlier ones were even called ‘god’. In keeping with this common expression, the Gospel applied this word to Jesus as well and this proved to be a deadly poison for the foolish. The entire Bible is proclaiming emphatically that this word is not reserved for the Son of Mary alone, but has been used for every Prophet and righteous one, with Jacob even being called the Firstborn Son. But when an unfortunate person is caught in a trap, he cannot escape it. And curiously enough, all the rules prescribed for the Divinity of Jesus Christ—namely, that he is both God and man—had already been set down with regard to Krishna and Ramchandra in the [sacred] books of the Hindus. This new [Christian] teaching is so much similiar [to the earlier one of Hindus] that we cannot but express the view that all this was an imitation of the Hindu doctrines. The Hindus, also, held the doctrine of Trimurti which alluded to the Triad of Brahma, Bishnu and Mahadev. Hence, the doctrine of Trinity appears to be a mirror image of this doctrine.
What is surprising is that whatever logical hair-splitting the Christians were offering in order to make Jesus into God and to avoid rational objections and whatever links they are inventing between the humanity and divinity of Christ with the view of somehow circumventing rational objections—still, they cannot avoid them and finally they try to get away by consigning it to Divine mysteries—exactly the same is the case with Hindus who declare Ramchandra and Krishna to be Ishvara [also spelled ‘Eshwara’—god]. This means that they also give the same explanations as do the Christians and when they completely run out of arguments they claim that this is the secret of Ishvar that is revealed only to those who practice yoga, renounce the world, and engage in ritual [Hindu] worship. But they do not realize that this secret was exposed the minute these false gods were unable to demonstrate any sign of their Divinity which men had not demonstrated before. It is true that the Granths are full of stories about these Avatars performing extraordinary wonders; they resurrected the dead and lifted mountains on their head, but if we accept these stories as true, even then on their own admission, it is established that there were such men who had worked miracles and yet who did not claim Divinity. For example, just think whether the works of Jesus were greater than those of Moses. On the contrary, his miracles were tarnished by the account of the pool [of Bethesda]. Are you gentlemen not aware of the miraculous pool that existed at that time? And have there not appeared such Prophets amidst the Israelites, whose mere touch resurrected the dead? Then what reasons are left to brag about Jesus’ ‘Divinity’? What a Shame!!!
The Hindus have attributed many extraordinary feats to their Avatars and have tried to establish their Divinity without any rhyme or reason. Since their tales are no less absurd than those of the Christians and even if we assume that there is some truth in them, still a humble man, who is by nature fragile and weak, cannot become Parmeshwar, and literal resurrection of the dead is itself false and runs counter to the Divine Books. However, miraculous resurrection, which does not concern one’s actual returning to the world and staying therein, is possible, but not an evidence of Divinity, for its claimants are common. There have been many in the past who could communicate with the dead but this phenomenon belongs to the vision of the dead. But the Hindus do hold a kind of superiority over the Christians and we recognize it. This superiority consists in their being the forerunners of
Christians concerning the deification of men and it is their innovation that the Christians have also followed. We cannot hide the fact that whatever justifications the Christians have invented in order to escape rational objections are not their own creations; rather, they have plagiarized them from the Granths and the Shastars. This entire fabrication scheme, which came in handy for the Christians, had already been devised by the Brahmans with regard to Krishna and Ramchandra. Therefore, the notion that the Hindus may have plagiarized from Christian books is demonstrably false, for their scriptures date back to a time when Jesus did not even exist, so we have no choice but to accept that the Christians themselves are plagiarists. [ John] Davenport, too, acknowledges that: ‘Trinity is the result of following an erroneous thought according to Plato. But the fact of the matter is that [ancient] Greece and India were like mirror images of each other in their doctrines. It is quite probable that such an abundance of idolatry would have first made its way from India to Greece in the form of Vedic knowledge, and then from there the naïve Christians stole them and grafted them onto the Gospel and thus tried to set their affairs in order.’
To return now to the actual meanings, I would like to point out that since each of these sects rejects the other, there remains little doubt that each of them believes in demolishing the beliefs of their opposing sect in order to reform the world, and each holds that the doctrines of its opponents are completely wrong and corrupt. Thus, when every religion acknowledges this corruption by viewing its opponents, therefore, all religions are compelled to acknowledge that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, brought about a universal reform of the world and he was, in fact, the Greatest Reformer. Moreover, the scholars of every faith agree that at that time, the adherents of their respective faiths had fallen into all manner of corruption and misguidance. For instance, Reverend Pfander in his book Mizan ul Haqq, and researcher Davenport in his book, and Padre James Cameron Lace in his lecture published in May 1882, all agree on this fact. Furthermore, those who recognize true righteousness and the right path, know that all these religions are wallowing in a pit of darkness٭ and none of their gods, whom these naïve people have set up as gods, is the True God.
If they had truly been ‘Gods’ the history of their lives should have manifested the magnificence and glory as the heaven and earth are manifesting the grandeur of a True and Illustrious God. However, these humble and suffering gods are totally lacking in this sign. Can sound reason accept that a frail mortal can be God in any respect? Certainly not! Never! Rather, the True God is One whose Immutable attributes are eternally seen in the mirror of the world. He is the One Who is in no need of a son who should commit suicide so that people may be saved through it. Rather, since time immemorial, there has always been one true path for redemption, which is free from innovation and deceit. Those who follow this path attain true salvation and its fruits in this very world, and witness its manifestation in their own selves. In other words, that true path is that one should accept the divine herald and follow in his footsteps in such a way that one’s selfish being should die and thus pay one’s own expiation. This alone is the way that God Almighty has ingrained in the nature of the seekers of truth from the very beginning. Since ancient times, and ever since man was created and granted the means of this spiritual sacrifice, and with his nature being inherently endowed with these means, the physical sacrifices, too, have been ordained in order to remind him of this. This is the true reality which the shortsighted and ill-fated Hindus and Christians have not understood. They did not reflect upon spiritual realities and fell into extremely evil, abominable and dark thoughts. Nothing has ever surprised me more than the plight of these people who have abandoned the Perfect and Living God, the Self Subsisting One and the Sustainer of all, only to follow these absurd beliefs and take pride in them.
To return now to the basic issue, as I have already pointed out, the reform that was carried out by our lord and master, the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is very sweeping and general and is acknowledged by all. This degree of reform had not been achieved by any previous Prophet. If anyone studies the history of Arabia, he will come to know how bigoted the idol worshippers, Jews, and Christians of the time were, and how much their reform had been despaired of for centuries. Then, look up and see how the teachings of the Holy Qur’an, which were wholly opposed to them, proved so effective that they swept aside every false doctrine and every vice. Drinking, which is the mother of all evils, was abolished, gambling was discarded, female infanticide was ended, and everything that was opposed to compassion and justice and purity was rectified. Moreover, the criminals were suitably punished for their crimes. No one can, therefore, deny the greatness of the reform that was carried out.
Here, it should also be kept in mind that when some contemporary Christian missionaries, who are apt at concealment of truth, realized that such sweeping reform occurred at the hands of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, as could not be concealed, and in contrast, the reform brought about by Jesus Christ in his time was negligible, they became worried; for, to reform the misguided and bring the sinful back into the fold of righteousness is the authentic hallmark of the True Prophet, and it was carried out in such a perfect and complete manner by the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, that the reformation effected by Jesus bears no comparison with it. Seeing this, they tried to veil the Sun with their deceitful schemes. As Reverend James Cameron Lace has published in his lecture, they misled the ignorant by saying that the people [of Arabia] had already been prepared for this reformation and that idolatry and shirk had already fallen from grace in their eyes. But, if those who express this view are right in their opinion, it is incumbent upon them to back it up with the kind of proof that is advanced by the Noble Qur’an against them. It says: