The Light of the Holy Qur’an - Number Two
Part 17
God Almighty has named this faith as Islam for the purpose that man should worship God, not out of selfish motives, but out of instinctive passion; for, Islam means to be pleased with the will of God, having cast aside all motives. With the exception of Islam, there is no religion in the world that has these objectives. Without a doubt, God has given the believers promises of various bounties in order to point out His Beneficence, but to those believers who aspire for the lofty status, He has indeed taught that they should worship God Almighty with a personal love.
However, there are clear testimonies in the Gospel that the disciples of your Yasu‘ were greedy and dim-witted. Hence, the guidance they received was commensurate with their ability and intellect and so was the Yasu‘ whom they discovered, who dissuaded the simpletons from worshipping [God] with the hoax of his own suicide.
Should you contend that the Gospel, by teaching that God be called ‘Father’, alluded to a personal love for Him, the reply is that this thought is completely erroneous; for, when we reflect upon the Gospel, we find that the Masih [the Messiah] used the phrase ‘son of God’ in two ways: (1) Firstly, it was an old custom in the time of Christ that anyone who did good and charitable work and treated people with kindness and compassion, would openly declare that he was a ‘son of God’. His intent in uttering this phrase was that just as God showers His mercy on both the righteous and the sinner, and both the good and the bad benefit from His sun, His moon, and His rainfall; in the same way, it was his habit to show kindness to everyone, the only difference being that while God was Great in these works, he, on the other hand, was small. Hence, the Gospel described God as ‘the Father’ in the sense that He is Great, and described others as ‘sons’, for they are small, but equated them with God in the core feature; that is to say, it accepted a difference in their scope, but the ‘father’ and the ‘son’ were one in character.
As this was a latent form of idolatry, the Perfect Book—namely, the Holy Qur’an—did not permit this kind of nomenclature. It was permissible for the Jews who were in a crude state, and Yasu‘, in following them, employed it in his discourses. Hence, there are many places in the Gospel where such references are made that you should show mercy like God, become a peacemaker like God, and, like God, be kind to your enemies as you are to your friends; you shall then be called ‘the sons of God’, for your works will mirror His. The only difference would be that God is Great like a Father, and you are small like a son. Thus, this teaching was actually taken from the scriptures of the Israelites. That is why, even to this day, the Jews object that this is stealing and plagiarism and these things were written in the Gospel having been stolen from the Bible. In any case, firstly, this is a flawed teaching; and, secondly, ‘son’ in this sense has nothing to do with personal love.
(2) The second kind of ‘son’ mentioned in the Gospel is the absurd statement like in John chapter 10 verse 34. In this verse everyone in this world, no matter how impious he is, has been made not only son but god, and the argument given is that scriptures cannot be false. In other words, the Gospel adopted a word that was well known among its people by following their example. Besides, the notion that God should be called ‘father’ is itself wrong, and who could be more ignorant and disrespectful than the one who applies the word ‘father’ to Almighty God?
I have, by the grace of God, already dealt with this question at length in the book Minanur-Rahman, which will prove to you that it is extremely vile and foul to apply the term ‘father’ to God Almighty. This is why the Noble Qur’an, in order to help people understand, did exhort them to remember God with love as they would remember their fathers, but it did not say anywhere to literally consider Him to be a father.
Another flaw in the Gospel is that nowhere did it teach that the sublime way to worship is to entertain no selfish motives in the worship; instead, if it taught anything, it was how to pray for bread. On the other hand, the Holy Qur’an taught us the following prayer:
That is, establish us on the path which is the path of Prophets and the Truthful and those who love God. The Gospel, on the other hand, teaches, ‘Give us this day our daily bread.’ I have read the entire Gospel, but there is no sign or trace of such sublime teaching.
[Fateh Masih’s Objection:] Eyes of Muhammad s (as) fell upon some lady. Thereupon, he came home and went to bed with his wife Saudah (ra). How can such a person be considered all perfect who, upon seeing some lady, cannot rein in his carnal self without going to bed with his wife and satisfying his lust?
My Statement: I submit that the hadith which the critic has misconstrued is found in Sahih Muslim and its words are as follows:
Saudah (ra) is not mentioned in this hadith anywhere. What this hadith does say is that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, saw some lady. He then came to his wife Zainab (ra), Allah be pleased with her, who was tanning a hide. Then he qada hajatahu [fulfilled his desire].
Note that there is absolutely no mention in this hadith anywhere that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, was attracted to the beauty and charm of that other lady. There isn’t even any mention whether that woman was young or old. Nor is it proved that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, came and went to bed with his wife. The words of the hadith only say that he fulfilled his want with her.
The phrase qada hajatahu is not exclusive for intimacy in the Arabic lexicon. Answering the call of nature is also called qada-ehajat, and it is used with many other meanings. So, from whence came the knowledge that the Holy Prophet s (as), went to bed with his wife? It is clearly mischief to restrict a general phrase to a specific meaning. Besides, it does not state that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said that he went and had intimate relations with his wife upon seeing some woman. The fact is that there is a hadith in Muslim related by Jabir which is translated as follows: If one of you sees some woman whom he finds attractive, then it is better for him to go home and go to bed with his wife immediately, so no evil thought should enter his mind and the remedy could be administered proactively.