The Light of the Holy Qur’an - Number Two
Part 18
It is quite possible that after hearing this hadith, some Companion observed that somewhere the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, came across a young woman, and he also came to know that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, happened to have had intimate relations with his wife around the same time, so he inferred on his own from this coincidence that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, had acted in accordance with this hadith.
Moreover, even if we were to suppose that the said statement of the Companion was true, it would still be the work of a wicked and vile person to draw a negative conclusion from it. The fact is that the Prophets, peace be upon them, are extremely eager to demonstrate for their followers all good and pious deeds so as to instil a practical example in their minds. Hence, they do sometimes condescend to do some good and righteous deeds in which the only intent is to set a practical example, while they have no personal need for it.
Such instances are mirrored in the laws of nature among animals too. For example, a hen will peck at a grain with its beak merely to teach its chicks how to pick the grain from the ground. Likewise, it is incumbent upon a perfect teacher to demonstrate a practical example, albeit every action of a teacher doesn’t reflect the state of his heart. Besides, if one inadvertently casts a glance on someone beautiful, there is nothing intrinsically wrong in acknowledging that the person is beautiful. Of course, evil thoughts are incompatible with perfect piety. So would it be incompatible with perfection if someone pursues the intricate paths of righteousness and acts to safeguard against evil thoughts as a precautionary measure even before the threats?
This teaching of the Holy Qur’an is sublime that:
Meaning that, the degree to which a person is mindful of the intricate paths of righteousness, is the very degree that his station is loftier in the sight of God. Hence, it is—without a doubt—a very lofty status of righteousness that steps be taken by means of precaution to safeguard against danger before the threats [of sin] should emerge.
If it is asserted that those who are perfect are immune to such threats under all circumstances, and they are not in need of any precautions, then such a claim would be the result of absolute stupidity and flawed understanding. This is so because the Prophets, peace be on them, cannot, even for a moment, consciously resolve to commit any sin or disobedience. For them to do so would be like [committing] a cardinal sin. Yet human urges can show their effects in them also, even though they are fully safeguarded from evil suggestions ever becoming evil intents.
For example, if a Prophet was very hungry and saw some trees laden with fruits, then—while we concede that he could never extend his hand towards the fruit without the owner’s permission nor would he resolve his mind to pick the fruit—such a thought, however, could certainly cross his mind that had the fruit been his own property, he could eat it. Such a thought would not be incompatible with perfection [of his morals].
You will recall how your so-called ‘God’ was unable to withstand the pangs of a little hunger and how he hurried towards the fig tree. Can you prove that the tree was his or his father’s property? Thus, the man who could not restrain himself upon seeing someone else’s tree and rushed towards it to satiate his hunger, could not—in your own words—even be a perfect human being, let alone be ‘God’.
In short, it is irrelevant if someone admires something for its beauty. Whoever has been bestowed eyes by God, can differentiate between beautiful and ugly just as he can differentiate between a flower and a thorn. Perhaps your so-called God was not blessed by nature with this ability to differentiate. However, out of hunger, he did rush towards the fig tree without even considering to whom it belonged.
How strange that a glutton and a drunkard is not called lascivious, whereas the holy personage [of the Prophets (as)], whose life and whose every deed was for the sake of God, is branded as ‘given to carnal pleasures’ by the filthy people of this age! What a strange age of darkness this is! It is but one example of the sublime teaching of Islam that it says one should never deliberately raise one’s eyes to look upon a woman, for it is a prelude to evil thoughts, and if you do, per chance, glance at a beautiful woman and she appears attractive to you, then you should ward off that thought by going to bed with your own wife.
Remember well that this teaching and exhortation is meant as a preventive measure. For example, if a person takes some medicine during the cholera season as a preventive remedy to protect himself from cholera, can we say that he is suffering from cholera or that he is showing the signs of cholera? Rather, this action of his would be considered a sign of his intelligence and it would be understood that he is naturally averse to this disease and wishes to remain far away from it. No one will agree with you that adopting the paths of righteousness is incompatible with perfection. If the Prophets, peace be on them all, do not show an example of righteousness, then who else should show it?
The one who fears God the most, is foremost in adopting righteousness also. He keeps himself away from evil and steers clear of the paths that carry the risk of sin. But what can I say or write about your Yasu‘ [Jesus] and for how long should I lament his condition! Was it appropriate for him to give this opportunity to an adulterous woman in the prime of her youth and beauty, to sit close to him with uncovered head, and to so coyly and lovingly caress his feet with her hair, and to massage his head with perfume bought with her earnings from prostitution? Had the heart of Yasu‘ been free of sinful thoughts, he would certainly have stopped a prostitute from coming close to him. But such people who derive pleasure from being touched by prostitutes do not even listen to the counsel of any advisor while they are in such a sensual state. Therefore, when an elder, with a sense of honour cautioned him with a view to stopping him, saying that to do such a thing was not appropriate, Yasu‘, realizing from the sternness of the man’s face that he was displeased with this conduct of his, he tried to talk away the objection like lewd people and asserted that this prostitute is very sincere and that such sincerity was not found even in the person who was objecting.
Praise the Lord! What an excellent reply! Your Yasu‘ [Jesus] is praising an adulterous woman saying how pious she is! Claim of Divinity and deeds the like of these! A person who stays intoxicated with wine, intermingles with prostitutes, and is so given to eating and drinking also, being foremost of all, that the people have come to calling him a glutton, what righteousness and piety can be expected from him?