The Light of the Holy Qur’an - Number Two
Part 9
Perhaps you have heard the saying of one of your holy elders that lying is not only permissible, it is worthy of divine reward. With respect to justice, which cannot be achieved without strict adherence to the path of truthfulness, God Almighty says:
Meaning: ‘Let not a people’s enmity incite you to act otherwise than with justice. Be always just, in this alone is righteousness.’
Now, you do know how hard it is to be equitable in dealing with such nations who torture you unjustifiably and cause injury to you, and cause bloodshed, and pursue you, and kill women and children—as the Makkan infidels had done—and then do not cease their warmongering! But the teaching in the Holy Qur’an did not usurp the rights even of such mortal enemies, and admonished in favour of justice and equity. But you are fallen in the pit of prejudice, how could you understand such holy teachings?
The Gospel does say ‘love your enemy’, but they do not say that the hostility and cruelty of the nations who are hostile to you should not deter you from justice and truthfulness. I state it quite truthfully that it is easy to treat an enemy cordially, but it is quite difficult and, befitting only of the gallant, to safeguard the rights of enemies and not to forsake justice and equity in litigations. Most people love their rival kinsmen, and treat them with sweet words, but usurp their rights. A brother loves his brother, but under the guise of that love, he defrauds him and deprives him of his rights. For example, if he happens to be a landowner, he slyly gets his brother’s name not recorded in the title deed, while showing such affection as though he is eager to sacrifice his life for him.
Thus, in this verse, God Almighty did not mention love, but mentioned the touchstone of love, for one who renders justice unto his mortal enemy and does not compromise truthfulness and equity, is really the one who holds sincere love as well. Your ‘God’, however, was not mindful of this teaching that he should have stressed justice even for tyrannical enemies, as emphatically as the Holy Qur’an did. He did not emphasize the need to extend an equitable deal to the enemy and to hold truthfulness as inviolable as assiduously as the Holy Qur’an did, and he did not teach the subtle paths of righteousness. It is regrettable that what he taught, was the teaching of deceit and he could not help establish [his followers] on the straight path of righteousness. I say this with reference to your imaginary Jesus Christ, a few of whose disarrayed pages is all you have in your possession; and who got crucified in the end while continuing to proclaim his godhead, and who tearfully supplicated all night long to be saved somehow but was not. Our lord and master, the Prophet of the Last Age, may the peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, prayed on his own accord that he be taken from this world, saying
God]. Your ‘God’, on the other hand, loved this transient mortal world so much that he spent the entire night praying that he may be permitted to go on living. In fact, even on the cross, words of assent and acceptance [of the will of God] did not come out of his mouth. The only words that escaped his lips were Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani? ‘My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?’ and God did not reply to him at all, that He had forsaken him.
rasulillah, Hadith 1619. [Publisher]
But it is quite obvious that he made a claim to being God and showed arrogance, so he was forsaken.
The Holy Prophet, may the peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, was given the choice at the end that if he wished he could live in this world, and if he wished, he could come to Him. The Holy Prophet s (as) submitted: ‘O my God! I now desire that I should come to You.’ And the last words that he uttered while his blessed soul departed were
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
. Meaning that, ‘I do not wish to live here now; I wish to go to my God.’
Now, compare these two statements. Your ‘God’ not only spent the entire night praying for mortal life but even on the cross he cried and cried out loud to be saved from death, but who was listening to him? On the other hand, our Master, the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, did not pray for mortal life at all. God Himself gave him the authority that if he desired this life, the same would be done. But he said that he did not wish to live in this world anymore. Is this the ‘God’ you depend on? You ought to die of shame!!!
And your contention that the Holy Qur’an commands people to hide their faith is merely a false accusation and calumny that has no basis in reality. The Holy Qur’an, in fact, curses٭ those who wilfully hide the testimony of faith, and it curses those who lie. Perhaps, on account of your ignorance, you have misconstrued this verse of the Holy Qur’an which is in Surah an-Nahl:
Meaning: ‘Whoever disbelieves in Allah shall have a severe punishment; save him who is coerced thereto—that is, he is prevented from performing the tenets of faith due to some tyranny that is beyond the limit of his tolerance—while his heart finds peace in his faith, such a person is excusable in the estimation of God.’ The purport of this verse is that if a tyrant inflicts some very painful and unbearable wounds on a Muslim, and in this agony, he utters some words that are tantamount to disbelief in the eye of the disbeliever, while the Muslim did not intend to utter words of disbelief—rather his heart brims with faith and his only intention is to conceal his faith due to the unbearable torture—and it is not wilfully but unwittingly when he is out of his senses and is almost delirious due to the unbearable torture to which he has been subjected; then, in this state, upon seeking forgiveness, God shall forgive him with the stipulations recorded in the following verse, because God is Most Forgiving and Merciful:
Meaning: ‘Those who hide their Islam during unbearable torture, their sin shall be forgiven on the condition that they migrate after having suffered this torture—that is, they should move away from such an environment or such a country wherein faith is being coerced—and then they strive very hard in the cause of God and show perseverance in the face of hardships; then God shall forgive their sin, for He is the Most Forgiving, Ever Merciful.’
Now, it becomes clear from all these verses that even a person who hides the declaration of the faith of Islam in the face of unbearable torture at the hands of the enemy is still a sinner in the eyes of the Almighty God. However, after performing honourable deeds, and after leaving such an environment or country wherein coercion is used, and after showing perseverance and steadfastness, his sin shall be forgiven, and God shall not let him go to waste, for He is Most Gracious, Ever Merciful.
In short, God does not speak of this concealment [of one’s faith] as something praiseworthy; rather, He has designated it a sin and has described the means to atone for it in the above verse. And, as I have already written, God praised believers at many places who do not conceal the testimony of faith even if they lose their lives for it. On the other hand, He also does not desire to cast aside a person who, due to the limitation of his capacity and unbearable torture, conceals the testimony of his faith while being tortured. Rather, He accepts such an individual on the condition that in the future he parts from such an environment and such a country where he is coerced, and seeks to win the pleasure of his Lord through sincerity, steadfastness, and spiritual striving. Then the sin of concealing one’s faith shall be forgiven, for the God who created mere mortals is most Benevolent and Merciful and does not cast anyone away from Himself for minor shortcomings.