Refuting Objections (cont’d)

The Light of Truth, Part 2

Among the criticisms of this sinful one, who is heedless of the Day of Judgement, is that he conjectures the Holy Qur’an errs in its explanation of Christianity and its beliefs; it misunderstands the purpose of its doctrines; and it attributes beliefs to Christians that contradict their faith. Know that his declaration is a great aspersion and a clear lie. The truth is that by the time the Holy Qur’an was revealed, the Christians had split into many sects. Some of them worshipped the Messiah, while others worshipped his mother alongside him, and some even prostrated before their portraits and worshipped them in the way they ought to have worshipped the Lord of all the worlds. They disputed and argued with one another exceedingly and intensely. They had all gone completely astray, save a few among them who remained monotheists, but even they adopted other harmful innovations and were like the [spiritually] blind.

So the Holy Qur’an clearly conveyed what it observed, reproaching and silencing them with a most compelling declaration. It said [to the Christians]: You worship a human instead of Allah the Self-Sufficient and you do not worship your Lord, the Most High. They did not absolve themselves from this; rather, they remained silent like one who is proven wrong and confesses his guilt. So the argument was made against them and the proof was put forth and it was established that they indeed held the beliefs which the Holy Qur’an stated, and that they associated partners with Allah.

Then, another generation of Christians came after them. They read books of philosophy and were dumbfounded, and became like drunkards. They perceived themselves like captives, shackled by the chains of shirk [associating partners with Allah]. They were greatly embarrassed by and felt remorse over their religion. So they contemplated reforming what had been corrupted and promoting what had been neglected. But ruin seize them! for how they plotted and contrived! They changed nothing aside from the mode of their preaching, but with the same conclusion.

So woe to the unjust people! They were consumed by the afflictions of misguidance, and their preaching achieved the same result [as their precursors], and they did not ponder with due care. They displeased their Master in order to please His servants. They forgot His warnings and His promises, and threw the teachings of the Prophets behind their backs. There is no doubt that they took Jesus as a god in preference to the Lord of all the worlds. To them, he is the Master of the Day of Judgement. On that day, they say that Jesus shall show no sign of being human, though he will possess a physical body with bones and flesh like humans. This is their belief and the belief of those who stumbled in the darkness of the early days [of Christianity], and which was observed during the advent of Islam.

Thereafter, in the present age, their eyes opened and their darkness decreased due to the spread of intellectual sciences and philosophy. They recognized the ignominy of their religion and the absurdity of their claim. Therefore, fearing criticism, condemnation, and the taunts of their opponents, they resorted to the practice of interpretation—for human nature cannot accept such shameful beliefs—and they rejected myths, which both men and women consider unmistakably false. This is particularly true in the present age when virtuous minds are inclining towards Tauhid [the Oneness of God] and the winds of Tanzih are blowing from every direction towards Allah the Matchless, and the bazaars of the polytheists are no longer drawing patrons. But how would they hide that which has been made public, spread widely, and exposed? Could they conceal a matter so widespread across so many countries and lands?

The similitude of one who barters away good in exchange for bad, who forsakes virtue and hastens towards vice, and does not fear God when concealing misdeeds and fabricating myths, is like a man who eats waste matter for a long period of time, thinking it to be a pleasant and fresh vegetable, and unaware that it is filthy, impure, and not a food for humans. He then meets the acquaintance of a noble and immaculate man, who is upright and graceful. This gentleman observes him eating filth and rebukes him in the way a judge reprimands a transgressor, saying: ‘Stop doing that! Do you really consume dung, O ye who are the filth of malefactors?’

Regretful, he thinks to himself: ‘How can I remove the mark of this rebuke; and how can I redeem myself from the repugnance of this embarrassment?’ So he sculpts a response, like those who present their brine as clear and fresh water, and replies: ‘Most assuredly I do not eat filth nor did I ever possess it, so I am not bothered in the least by this provocation. I have also never exhorted [others] towards this act, which is the worst of all abominations. This is nothing but the allegation of a liar and a slanderer, and I am innocent [of this charge]. My opponent does not recognize the truth and disregards appropriate behaviour [in his haste to criticize]. As it is, I eat only those portions of this food that disintegrate during the gastrointestinal digestive process by design of the Creator of all things, which the body’s natural process also directs to certain intestines. This substance is then expelled through the usual exit point along with a nominal amount of bile. However, it is something altogether different and not excrement, as my opponent presumes; in fact, it is a wholesome food that has been prepared for the likes of us who are pure.’

Be fearful of this parable and ponder over the life of the Messiah and what he said. Everything Jesus the Prophet of Allah said is good. However, woe be to those who did not comprehend his teachings. I shed tears over the condition of the transgressors and those who abuse and vilify us. Indeed we pray to Allah to guide them and have mercy on them, for He is the Best of those who show mercy. By God I do not mock you, but rather I weep over your condition, that you conceal the true matter and put on a façade, O unjust ones. What is the matter with you that you do not understand? I show you but you do not see. I give but you do not take. You spread falsehood yet you feel no shame. I rouse you from your slumber but you do not awaken. Do you not fear Him to whom you will be returned? Or do you think you will be given free rein forever?

I have just stated that the Holy Qur’an does not paint only one picture of the Christians, but rather, makes some of them as witnesses to [the condition of ] the others. It says: Some of them worship the Messiah and intentionally take him as a god; others among them worship his mother along with him and praise her with great reverence; and there is also a small sect among them that worships Allah and considers Him to be Gracious and Merciful, and regards the Messiah to be a mere mortal and human being.

These were the three factions that were present at the time of our Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. The Holy Qur’an has been read out to Christians for centuries but not one of them objected that the Holy Qur’an attributes to them that which conflicts with their beliefs or the teachings of their leaders; that it does not understand the concept of the Trinity; or that it errs in conveying their beliefs. If you think anyone has made assertions like these, or you have found a book that bears witness to such statements, then bring forth your book if you are truthful. However, if you are unable to, then fear Allah and do not follow the views of an immoral people.

Bear in mind that in the present age—which is an age of contemplation and scrutiny—you have surely realized in your own minds that the beliefs you hold are mere tales which cause great harm and lead young men and women to laugh at you. Therefore, you desire to cover them with the curtain of ta’wilat [interpretation], so that you may be saved from the rebukes and jeers of those who curse. For this reason, you embellished your lies to nullify the truth thereby—and you were a people who exceeded all bounds. As for your beliefs being impure, this is not something that can be hidden from mankind or from the eye of the intelligent, who possess understanding and the ability to reason. Do you not worship Jesus in this age the way you worshipped him during the revelation of the Holy Qur’an? Do you not exalt him and venerate him and aggrandise him as the God of the universe? Do you not say that every matter has been entrusted to Jesus; that he is God in the present world and the hereafter; that he is the one to whom you will be returned and presented? And he will judge between you like a great and noble king? And you will recognize him by his appearance as the Son of Mary?

O polytheists! Die of shame! How will you conceal your associating partners with Allah when your secrets have been revealed and the news has spread; and when you have propagated your beliefs in such haste, running forth like the fledgling of an ostrich? I have recognized you and I have recognized your ruse and strategy, so how can I think favourably of you after being enlightened? You are a people who misguide mankind through your many deceptions, to incline them towards your ignorant beliefs, to make them accept your myths, and to come to you as though they were mesmerized. I have heard you vilify my Prophet through both falsehood and fabrication, and so, I have been burned by these two fires. However, I complain to Allah alone, and He is the Best of Helpers.

10 of 10 left today