Endnote: Assessing the Authenticity of the Eclipse Hadith
The Light of Truth
Related to Page Number 17
Know that the opponents harbour objections and doubts at this juncture, but all of them point to a deficit of reflection and a surplus of enmity like the reproacher. The greatest objections involve the discrediting and criticizing of the narrators. In response to this, know that I do not accept such criticism without proof from the research scholars. Allah the Exalted states:
This verse indicates that accepting the testimony of evil people is impermissible except after an investigation [so thorough] that it renders the enquirer completely content. With this resolved, I declare that one of the Holy Qur’an’s commandments and affirmations of the Furqan is thinking well of the believers. Moreover, I declare that Daraqutni did not accept this hadith from these narrators without conducting an inquiry that was sufficient for its verification. As such, how would it be possible for Daraqutni to deliberately transmit [a hadith] from a sinful
correctness of the report fully, lest you harm a people in ignorance, and then become repentant for what you have done (Surah al-Hujurat, 49:7). [Publisher]
was a revered Muslim scholar and compiler of the hadith collection Sunan ad-Daraqutni. [Publisher]
liar and thereby himself join the evil people! There can be no doubt that he built his endeavour on information and examination; therefore, reflect with justice and patience and be not of the deviant. How can the heart of a believer be so audacious as to consider the likes of him [Imam Daraqutni] among the people of immorality and transgression, to abuse a person of virtue and faith and to consider him a traitor and cause of disorder.
The truth of the matter, which must be accepted, and the light that removes doubts upon its emergence, is that Daraqutni did not find anything among the narrators that could be attributed to defects, and observed the reputation of the hadith with his own eyes, so he took this eye-witnessing for two just witnesses.
Now, if we were to suppose that Daraqutni considered the narrators of this hadith to be from among the wicked and yet recorded it without investigation like the godless fabricators, then this act would place him at the forefront of those who are disgraced by evil actions. It would prove that he was outside the realm of virtue and righteousness, and was in fact among the worst narrators, because he accepted the narration of a person who was a deviant liar and a narrator of false reports; he would fabricate for those with errant beliefs; he was a deceiver, the greatest liar of his age, and a weaver of fabrications; and he was a recognised and well-known maligned individual, as documented by the Ghaznavid author of Siyanatul-Anas. So, what do you think? Do you consider Daraqutni to be an evil person, bereft of righteousness or religion?
Moreover, know that the Trustworthy Qur’an does not prohibit us from accepting the testimony of the wicked. Rather, it states:
This is to say, accept their testimony after investigation and completing all the steps of examination; do not accept it hastily. Hence, thinking well [of others] is to acknowledge that Daraqutni accepted this hadith from its narrators only after he investigated the matter and found them to be among the trustworthy, thus becoming content. You find that certain narrators in [Sahih] al-Bukhari were accused of deviating in their belief and various immoral actions; however, there are other chains of trustworthy narrators of this hadith. Consider what Na‘im bin Hammad and Abul Hasan al-Khairi recorded about Ali bin Abdullah bin Abbas in al-Juzziyyat, and reflect like those with knowledge. Hafiz Abu Bakr bin Ahmad bin al-Hasan has recorded the like of this hadith as have Kathir bin Marrah al-Hadrami and al-Baihaqi.
The Holy Qur’an sits in judgement over all these [ahadith] through the bayyinat and muhkamat [clear proofs and decisive verses]. Hence, only those will reject it whose hearts have hardened and who have fallen into the abyss of bigotry; having no experience of investigation; being ignorant of the deepest depths of cognisance; having not unearthed the crypts of fine subtleties; nor having sought the truth like those who strive to be rightly guided.
The well-known nature of the hadith, along with its many chains [of transmission], indicate that it is a statement of the Messenger of God, peace and blessings of God be on him, and this is how it was understood by all those who taught and learned [the Hadith]. If this were not the case, then what was the need that led [the Muslims] to drink from the cup of others? Were the ahadith of the Best of Messengers not sufficient for guiding the virtuous? Why would they have collected sayings that were not from Khatamun-Nabiyyin [the Seal of the Prophets], the Trustworthy Messenger? Is this anything but falsehood, deceit, and the work of satanic people? None carry out such acts except those who strive to create disorder in the world and destroy its inhabitants like the deceivers.
As for those who, enabled by the Gracious God, have been granted a share of faith and a provision of obedience to the Sunnah [of the
Holy Prophets (as)], they feel a sense of shame in front of God and do not substitute non-revelation for divine revelation nor replace the Word of the Gracious God with the word of man, like the audacious. You find many mursalat in the ahadith of the Greatest of Messengers and Best of Creation. However, the narrators did not state that they themselves were the original speakers [of these quoted statements] or that these were their own statements or the statements of their peers from among the virtuous and God-fearing. Rather, they reported these statements with such complete certainty, honour, and reverence that is not befitting for the speech of anyone of the righteous except that of Khatamul- Anbiya’ [the Seal of the Prophets], the Chief of the Messengers.