Endnote: Assessing the Authenticity of the Eclipse Hadith

The Light of Truth, Part 2

This is the greatest proof and most conclusive evidence that they did not relate a mursal hadith except when their firm belief was that it was from the Best of Messengers, and that it was a hadith of the Messenger of Allah, Khatamun-Nabiyyin. The reason for [the existence of ] irsal was that the reported news was already so widely known as to have reached the point of completeness; and whatever was mashhūr [well known], prevalent, and widely mentioned among the rijāl [narrators] did not require raf ‘ [escalating the chain of narration to the Prophets (as) ] or ittisal [having an unbroken chain of narration]. In contrast, those ahadith that were ahad [reported by only a single narrator] did necessitate raf ‘ in order to dispel doubts of interpolation, faithlessness, or error on the part of the narrators. Indeed, how many well-known and fully accepted reports exist, which we do not doubt nor suspect to be fabrications, but rather, which we consider with full certainty to be a part of the pure Sunnah and the Signs of Islam, despite never establishing that these ahadith are marfu‘ and muttasil. This is a great secret of religious wisdom, so accept it and be grateful.

Furthermore, know that the ultimate standard for [judging the veracity of ] ahadith which contain matters of the unseen and news of the future is not the formula established by the scholars of Hadith and implemented by the narrators. Rather, the true and ultimate standard is whether such ahadith correspond to the manifestation of predicted events and promised, decreed matters, and whether there remains no difference [between the prophecy and the event] in the estimation of those who reflect.

Those who abrogate this standard and have no regard for the manifestations [of prophecies] are the most ignorant people with regard to the methods of investigation. The sum of their intelligence is to blindly follow speculative traditions and to abide by weak, doubtful reports, and they are not guided along the ways of the rightly guided. Those who act wrongfully allege that a da‘if [weak] hadith remains weak according to the Ahl-us-Sunnah even after its truthfulness becomes evident through direct observation, like those prophecies concerning future events whose truthfulness is made plain through observation [upon fulfilment] and it is established that they originate from the Best of Creators; and [even though] they read the hadith of the Best of Creation,

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

ل [i.e. ‘hearsay is not like seeing’] and know that the Messenger of Allah, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, strengthened the manqulat through [corresponding] observations. Further, as a warning, he told those who lie and turn away that one who [secondarily] reports is not like one who sees, and called on those who hear to give precedence to the testimony of those who witness.

Among their weak delusions is that eclipsing the sun before its appointed days and decreed timing is not far removed from [the practice of ] Allah, Creator of the heavens and the earths. They say that Ibrahim, the son of the Messenger of Allah, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, died on the tenth day of the [lunar] month, and upon his death, the sun was eclipsed by the permission of Allah, the Gracious; why, then, would it not eclipse [on the 15th of Ramadan] in the Latter Days by the permission of the Lord of all the worlds. They do not know that this narration is inauthentic; in fact, it is a clear lie a statement of the fabricators.

Ibn Taimiyyah has observed that this narration is from al-Waqidi, thus, everything in it is false, for, al-Waqidi was not [accorded the status of ] hujjah [‘proof ’] by general consensus with regard to the chain of narration of what he related; and how could it be [trustworthy] when it is maqtu‘ [having a broken chain of narration], and the account of the speaker that the sun eclipsed on the 10th is like his saying that the hilal [crescent moon] appeared on the 20th! Furthermore, accurate and decisive examination and true and sound observation have testified that the practice of Allah has decreed that the moon will not be eclipsed except during the days when its light is fullest and the sun will not be eclipsed except during the final days of the [lunar] month. And there is no change in the established practice of the Lord of all the worlds.

Hence, the prophecy of the lunar and solar eclipses manifested according to this ancient practice and continuous, clear pattern. Thus, what need arose such that we must abrogate a correct and accepted concept, and what tragedy struck such that we must change what is recognized and understood? The truth that Allah desired to manifest has indeed manifested, so do not deny the truth after its having come to you, and do not turn away from that which is proven, present, visible, and attested to. I have presented my words as an invitation for the seekers, and I have conclusively proved this matter on the basis of the Holy Qur’an, Sunnah, and the statements of the Imams and the salaf [predecessors] of the ummah. So, is there anyone who would fear Allah and adopt the ways of the righteous?

Another delusion of theirs is that this hadith is not a hadith of our Prophet Muhammad, the Chosen One, but rather a saying of Imam Baqir and we do not even find the name of the Chief of Mankind in it.

As for the answer [to this objection], know that this prophecy is one of the matters of the Faith and it was not for Imam Baqir or anyone else to make a declaration befitting the status of Prophets. Moreover, Imam Baqir, may Allah be pleased with him, did not say that this was his own statement, nor did he attribute it to himself. This is decisive proof that it is a statement of the Best of Messengers.

Evidence of this is that it was among the practices of the Salaf that when they spoke about the Religion by means of a statement, but did not attribute the statement to themselves, nor to another believer besides themselves, nor investigated it like researchers; rather, they transmitted it like the muqallidin [those who strictly follow a specific tradition], this indicated that they meant the statement was a saying of the Messenger of Allah, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. They would quote it as a mursal narration as an indication of its widespread recognition, which obviated the need to investigate its isnad [chain of narrators]. This is established by its widespread acceptance, leaving no need for any other support. This is the truth, so accept it and do not be among the doubtful.

Among their greatest misconceptions—which arose due to their insistence on suspicion and prejudice and their not suckling from the breast of truth with pure intention, instead becoming emaciated from hunger—is that they say: ‘There were almost 200 Signs for the Mahdi, so we will never accept you nor believe your claim until we see them all with our own eyes. Before they appear, we do not consider you anything but an abrogator, fabricator, and liar. We will not reconsider our hatred for you nor establish a bond of trust with you except after every single one of the Prophetic traditions is fulfilled in your person. And we do not accept what you said before this; indeed, we consider you to be a mischief-maker.’

As for the answer [to this objection], know that these are all delusions which resemble a mirage. Prominent people were deceived by them, considering the spring of punishment to be sweet. The ulama assumed the position of casting doubt and employing deceit and misled the people. They rejected the word of [Muhammad s (as)] the Truthful, [Hakam] the Arbiter. They distorted the truth like the corruptive Antichrist, committed excesses in mischief, and presented clear deceit.

·

10 of 10 left today