Endnote: Assessing the Authenticity of the Eclipse Hadith
The Light of Truth, Part 4
[ The crescent (al-hilal): the beginning of the moon (al-qamar) which people seek at the start of the month. It is also said: the first two nights of the month are called hilal, then it is no longer called hilal until it (the crescent) returns the following month. It is also said: the moon is called hilal for the first three nights, then it is called qamar. It also said: it is called hilal till it begins filling out. It is also said: it is called hilal until its light overtakes the darkness of the night and this does not happen until the seventh night. Abu Ishaq states: That [position] which I hold, as does the majority, is that the moon is called hilal the first two nights because by the third night its light becomes clear.]
So look, O ye who possess sight, if you are of the seekers.
assessing the authenticity of the eclipse hadith 497
Now, I will produce a table for you to show you that the Messenger of Allah s (as) did not call the moon qamar on the first night of the [lunar] month, but rather, he named it hilal . If you deny this, then produce [evidence] to the contrary; but if you do it not, then accept what is proven to be from the Messenger of Allah, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, if you are from among the believers.
Name of
Book Page Location
Press
[and
City]
Excerpt from the Matn of the
Hadith
1 Sahih al-
Bukhari
255 Book of Fasting, the Hilal
Ahmadi,
Meerut
[He said that (Laith related that) Uqail and Yunus related to me ‘for the hilal (crescent moon) of Ramadan’…]
[The statement of the Prophet s (as): ‘When you see the hilal (new moon) then begin fasting.’]
[‘Do not begin (Ramadan) fasting until you see the hilal…’]
4 Sahih
Muslim
347 Book of Fasting, ment of Ramadan Fasting for
the Sighting of the Hilal
Ansari,
Delhi
[Ibn Umar reports that the Prophet s (as) mentioned Ramadan and said, ‘Do not fast until you see the hilal.’]
[The Messenger of Allah s (as) said: The month [of Ramadan may consist of ] twenty-nine days. So when you see the hilal…]
Name of
Book Page Location
Press
[and
City]
Excerpt from the Matn of the Hadith
[The Messenger of Allah s (as) said when you sight the hilal…]
[The Messenger of Allah s (as) mentioned the hilal (new moon)…]
[The month of Ramadan commenced for me while I was in Syria and I sighted the hilal…]
[Then he (Abdullah ibn Abbas (ra) ) mentioned the hilal and asked (Kuraib): ‘When did you see the hilal?’]
[See note 1]
[He (Abul Bakhtari) said: We tried to see the hilal. Some of the people said: It is three nights old. (Others) said…]
[See note 1]
[We observed the hilal, but some of the people said…]
1. In present-day editions of Sahih al-Muslim, this hadith is found under
Babu Bayani annahu la I‘tibara bi-Kibaril-Hilali wa-Sigharihi [Chapter: ‘Immateriality of Whether the Moon is Large or Small’]. See hadith 1088 in Sahih Muslim: Arabic-English, vol. III. New Delhi: Idarah Isha‘at-e-Diniyat (P) Ltd., 2007; 286–288. [Publisher]
ENDnote Related to Page Number 17 499
Name of
Book Page Location
Press
[and
City]
Excerpt from the Matn of the Hadith ing of his s (as)
[He (Abul Bakhtari) said: ‘We saw the new moon of Ramadan…’]
13 Sahih
ad- Daraqutni
232 Book of Fasting, ing to Sighting the Hilal
Faruqi,
Delhi
[He (the Emir of Makkah) asked: Who saw the hilal…]
[They both sighted the hilal the day before…]
[Some ahillah (crescent moons) are larger than others, so if you sight the hilal…]
[If you sight the hilal…]
[Some ahillah (crescent moons) are greater than others, so if you sight the hilal…]
[He sighted the hilal…]
[Some ahillah (crescent moons) are greater than others, so if you sight the hilal…]
[That they both sighted the hilal…]