16 July 1900
Malfuzat – Volume II, Part 2
One ought to ask these people: do points of guidance take precedence or narratives? If a contradiction exists between the two, which shall be given preference? Allah the Exalted states again and again that those who die, do not return. There is a Hadith in Tirmidhi that a companion of the Holy Prophet (sa) was martyred. The companion submitted: ‘O Lord! Send me back to the world.’ On this, God Almighty responded, by saying:
My word has already gone forth.
It is an inviolable law for a township which We have destroyed that they shall not return.
Now we have the Holy Qur’an and the clear words of the blessed Hadith are present in the form of a commentary. In comparison to this, what value can an imaginary and hypothetical tale possess in this respect? I ask, what more do the people want? I present the Holy Qur’an and the Hadith. Furthermore, sound intellect and experience also supports my view. If I was presenting a self-invented idea, people could have put forth a narrative, but in this case, I am presenting a point of guidance from the Holy Qur’an and a Hadith in support. What more do the people seek?
So what would you have after discarding the truth except error?
It is not necessary for God Almighty to disclose to us the underlying facts in narratives. Just believe in them and leave the intricate details to God. In the case of fasting, the Arabs would ask about relevant details and many verses expound various aspects of this injunction. However, in the case of narratives, this is not necessary. For example, it is unnecessary for God Almighty to tell us about the appearance of the idols that belonged to the idolatrous opponents of Abraham (as). To pursue such thoughts is disrespectful. In short, remember that it is improper for one to overdo an issue unnecessarily and raise absurd questions as to the details of narratives related in the Holy Qur’an. A human being cannot follow an instruction until it is clear. Therefore, God Almighty states that He has made points of guidance simple, and in the same manner, Allah the Exalted has clearly explained that the dead do not return.
If our opponents possess a sense of honesty and fear of God, when they relate the narrative of Ezra (as), it is incumbent on them to not ignore those verses of the Holy Qur’an which state that the dead do not return.
Now, I will come down a degree for the sake of argument and provide another response. I have already mentioned that as far as narratives are concerned, a general belief in them is sufficient. However, since instructions are meant to be acted upon in the practical sense, therefore it is necessary for one to understand them. Now, it is written that Ezra (as) remained ‘dead’ for a hundred years and the Arabic word used for this is amata. It should be known that one definition of amata (to cause to die) is anama as well, which means ‘to be put to sleep.’ The word ‘death’ has also been used in the Holy Qur’an to describe a loss of strength in the faculties of growth and perception. In any case, we can also infer a meaning of sleep in this context, like the account of the Dwellers of the Cave. The difference between the account of the Dwellers of the Cave and that of Ezra (as) is that in the case of the Dwellers of the Cave, there was the dog, and in the case of Ezra (as) there is a donkey. The baser self is akin to both a dog and a donkey. God likened the Jews to a donkey and mentioned the dog in the context of Balaam. It is evident that the baser self does not let go of man. One who is unconscious will either be with ‘a dog’ or ‘a donkey’.
Therefore, another aspect of this discussion is—as I have mentioned—that the Arabic word amata, which means ‘to cause to die’, is also defined as anama i.e. ‘to put to sleep.’ And I accept that one hundred years aside, a person may well sleep for two hundred thousand years—my contention is that once the soul is taken by the angel of death, it does not return to the world. In sleep, although the soul is seized as well, but the angel of death does not take it away.
Sleeping for an extended period of time is a matter that can, in no way, be objectionable. There are techniques written in Hindu books on holding one’s breath. Moreover, holding one’s breath is also practiced by yogis at various stages in meditation (abhyas). Only a short time ago there was a report in newspapers that during the construction of a railway line, a small hut belonging to a Hindu ascetic was discovered. Similarly, there was a report circulating in the newspapers about a young boy who slept for twenty years. In short, it is no surprising matter for a person to remain asleep for a hundred years.
Drink of Ezra (as) Being Preserved
Moving on, in the verse relating to Ezra (as), the words
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
(they have not rotted) are worthy of contemplation. If one were to keep in view our present-day experience, no difficulty remains in comprehending the underlying reality in these words. A reliable person writes that he once ate some meat that had been cooked thirty years before his birth—the meat had been air-sealed.
Now, thousands, rather hundreds of thousands of bottles are brought here from foreign lands such as Europe and America which contain cooked foods that are preserved, or in other words:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
(they have not rotted). This concept of
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
(i.e. to remain free from decay and be preserved) is applicable in the meditative practices of the Hindus and also reveals the underlying reality in today’s intellectual advances. The Holy Qur’an had already mentioned this phenomenon long ago.
The fact of the matter is that just as a particular characteristic in air causes food to decay, the human body is affected in the same way. Now, if food can be preserved by guarding it from the effects of air through a specific method, what is so astonishing about this? It is possible that some time in the future, a method is discovered by which humans are able to undergo a process that is similar to preserved food. These are the sciences. There is no harm in being open to such possibilities.
Various investigations and scientific experiments have led to the development of such footwear by which a person can walk on water. Moreover, fire-repellant and bulletproof vests have been invented as well. In the same vein, if the underlying reality in
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
(they have not rotted) as stated in the Holy Qur’an is proven at some point in terms of science, why should this be surprising? The effects of air cause food to decay and air has a significant effect on humans as well. There are two kinds of air. There is one form of air which when inhaled, revitalises, and another form, is exhaled through breathing, which is a burnt and foetid sort of air. In short, if the phenomenon alluded to in the words
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
(they have not rotted) was discovered, this would not harm us at all. In fact, the more and more that knowledge of the natural sciences spreads, the greatness and excellence of the Holy Qur’an will become all the more manifest.
I observe every other day that soups and meats cooked abroad are brought to India and they do not spoil. Foreign medicines come here from thousands of miles and are kept for months, even years, but they do not expire. A certain individual told me that if an egg is preserved in mustard oil, it does not spoil. The application of similar effects upon a person’s youth and strengths could very well be a possibility. Certain Muslims have also made endeavours in holding their breath. In fact, a person even visited me and said that he only takes two breaths in one day. Practical evidence demonstrates that air has an effect in the process of decay. So if a human is isolated from such air and their life is prolonged, why should this be deemed an impossibility? What harm is there in accepting that lives can be prolonged in this way?