22 December 1901
Malfuzat – Volume IV
After reading certain sections of Al-Hakam and various writings of His Holiness, peace be upon him, Munshi Abdul-Haqq Sahib of Qusur, the B.A. student from Lahore, who was a Christian for the last three years, wrote a letter to the Promised Messiah (as) saying that he desired to see a practical example of the truthfulness of Islam. On this, His Holiness, the Vicegerent of Allah, wrote back to him saying that he should come and stay in Qadian for at least two months. As such, he set out for Qadian, the Abode of Peace, and arrived here on 22 December 1901 in the afternoon. Therefore, everything that we record here is about him.
The First Audience
His Holiness, the Champion of Allah in the mantle of the Prophets, peace and blessings be upon him, has been feeling ill for the last two or three days on account of his heavy workload. During these days, His Holiness (as) remains engaged in his work long into the night. On the one hand, the Promised Messiah (as) needed to complete an exposition so that it could be translated in time to include in a periodical. On the other hand, he was also working on the treatise that he had promised to write for the editor of the periodical Al-Manar. Moreover, he is also compiling over two hundred magnificent signs and prophecies to present in the form of an ordered list. However, for the sake of the guests and for this seeker of truth who is visiting Qadian, today the Promised Messiah (as) said that he would go for a walk. Therefore, at about nine o’clock, His Holiness (as) graced us with his presence. As soon as he came out, Munshi Abdul-Haqq Sahib, the Christian, was presented before His Holiness (as). The discussions that followed thereafter between the two are presented herewith as follows:
His Holiness (as): How long has it been since you became a Christian and what factors led you to convert to Christianity?
Munshi Abdul-Haqq: It has been three years this December. I had certain Christian friends that I would meet. In Ferozpur I also knew Reverend Newton who was always very kind to me. These were the initial factors that moved me to accept Christianity.
His Holiness (as): You have done very well to come here for two months. This is an apparent sign of your desire to seek the truth.
Munshi Abdul-Haqq: Good sir, I have had my name removed from the college register; they were not giving me time off.
His Holiness (as): This shows your determination to an even greater extent. In my opinion, a more effective and appropriate course of action for you, which can prove most beneficial, is that now you should write down a list of any objections that you hold against Islam, which are significant, and then present them to me one by one. I shall, God willing, continue to answer them. You are free to ask the same question repeatedly if my answer does not satisfy you, and you should clearly and openly say that you are not satisfied with a certain answer. However, in writing these objections, keep in mind that none of them should be such as would prove to be allegations against the past scriptures, otherwise this would be a waste of time. When you have put forth your objection, I will tell you about the merits of Islam. These are the only two fruitful ways to proceed; one task relates to you and the other I take upon myself.
The Promised Messiah (as) said: “There are two reasons that cause a person to convert to another religion. The greatest factor relates to certain matters which, due to misunderstanding and misinformation, are turned into something completely different. The actual principles of the religion are usually ignored. For example, when Christians speak to someone about Islam, they begin to raise allegations
about the wars that took place in Islam, even though there are examples in their own religion of the wars fought by Joshua (as) and Moses (as). When these wars are compared to the wars of Islam, they prove to be far more objectionable than the
wars of Islam. For I can prove that the wars of Islam were completely defensive, and they are not characterised at all by the same severity and cruelty that can be seen in the wars of Moses (as) and Joshua (as). If they respond by saying that the wars of
Moses (as) and Joshua (as) were a chastisement from God, I would respond by saying, then why should the wars of Islam not be considered a form of divine chastisement? Why should the Mosaic wars be seen in a preferential light? In fact, in
the Islamic wars, large and significant concessions were given as compared to the Mosaic battles. The actual fact is that those who raise these objections are unaware of the divine commandments. Therefore as compared to the opponents of Moses, peace be upon him, Allah the Exalted demonstrated an extreme level of
mercy, for He is Forgiving and Merciful. Then, in contrast to the Mosaic wars, the wars of Islam are greatly distinct in the fact that the servants of the Holy Prophetsas, and even the Messenger of Allah himself, peace and blessings of Allah
be upon him, were constantly subjected to the most horrific pains and torments at the hands of the Meccans for thirteen years. These cruel people subjected them to all sorts of grief. As such, many of them were killed and others died after being