22 December 1901
Malfuzat – Volume IV, Part 2
subjected to brutal forms of torture. Therefore, it is not hidden to anyone who has read the history that helpless women were killed after being tortured in the most shameful of ways. This is to such an extent that one lady was tied to two
camels and then those camels were forced to run in opposing directions and this poor woman was torn in two. It was these sorts of pain and torment that the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and his holy community bore
with patience and resolve continuously for thirteen years. Even after all this, the people of Mecca did not stop inflicting cruelty and ultimately a plan was hatched to assassinate the Holy Prophet himself, peace and blessings of Allah be upon
him. When the Holy Prophetsas received divine intimation from God Almighty about this conspiracy of the people, and migrated from Mecca to Medina, the Meccans pursued him. Finally, when these people set forth to attack Medina,
Allah the Exalted commanded the Muslims to thwart this attack, because now
the hour had come for the people of Mecca to taste the divine punishment that was due to them for their mischief and evil. Therefore, the earlier promise of God Almighty was fulfilled that if these people do not refrain from their evil ways, then divine chastisement would destroy them. The Holy Qur’an itself has clearly explained the reason for these wars:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
Meaning, permission to fight was given to those against whom the opponents had waged an attack in order to kill them. These people were given permission because they were wronged. Allah has the power to help those who are oppressed. These were the persecuted who had been unjustly driven out of their homelands. Their only crime was that they proclaimed: ‘Allah is our Lord.’
This is the verse which lays the foundation for the wars in Islam. Furthermore, the leniency that you will observe in the Islamic wars cannot be matched by any example among the wars of Moses (as) or Joshua (as). In the Mosaic wars, hundreds of thousands of innocent children were killed, women and the elderly were cut down, orchards and trees were burnt and laid waste—all evidenced by the Torah. However, despite our Noble Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, bearing at the hands of these evil people such atrocities and injuries that had never been seen before, he would order that children not be killed in these defensive wars, nor women and the elderly attacked; he would order that monks be left alone, that farms and fruit bearing trees should not be burnt and that places of worship should not be demolished. Now, compare the two sides and tell me, which stands superior? In short, these are absurd allegations. If an individual possesses a good nature, they can compare these two examples and find the truth themselves. Was there a different God in the time of Moses (as) and a different God in the time of Muhammad, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him? Just as the wicked would not refrain from their evil in the time of the Israelite Prophets, they had exceeded all bounds in their opposition during the era of the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. Therefore, the very same God, Who is Compassionate and Merciful, but shows His wrath also towards those who are evil, punished these enemies through wars, which they had brought upon themselves in the first place. What happened to the people of Lot (as)? What was the end of the opponents of Noah (as)? So if the people of Mecca were punished in this way, why should this be objectionable? Is it specified anywhere that divine punishment must come in the form of plague or rocks showered from heaven? God can punish in whatever manner He wills.
This has been the way since time immemorial. If an impulsive person were to take objection, they could raise an allegation on the era of Moses (as) and his wars in which no leniency was shown—and this stands as a contrast to the example of the Noble Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. No objection can be made against the Noble Prophetsas. This is the age of reason. These sorts of allegations can have no standing, because when one looks at this issue setting aside religious persuasions, they will manifestly see that in the Islamic wars, from beginning to end, the purpose has always been defensive; moreover, all forms of mercy were shown, which is something we do not see in the wars of Moses (as) and Joshua (as). I happened to see a book written by an Arya Samajist and he has raised strong allegations against the Mosaic wars, however, he could find no opportunity to raise any objections in relation to the wars in Islam. When an Arya Samajist or Hindu asks me about the Islamic wars, I always explain to them in a kind and gentle manner that those who were killed were actually slain by their own sword, as it were. When their barbarities reached the extreme, ultimately they were punished and their attacks were thwarted.
I am immensely disappointed when I see how the Christian priests explain the issue and also when I observe the people who accept their words. When it comes to the wars of Moses (as) they do not see the state of their own house, as it were, yet they begin to raise allegations against the wars fought in Islam. Then in their simplicity, those who listen to these priests accept what they tell them. If one reflects, the objections regarding the wars of Moses (as) are equally applicable to the Messiah (as) too, because he believed in the Torah and accepted Moses (as) to be a Prophet of God. If these wars, and the killing of women and children displeased him, then why did he accept these views? In a way, one could say that it was the Messiah (as) himself who waged these wars and that it was the Messiah (as) himself who murdered these women and children.
The truth is that the Messiah, peace be upon him, never had the opportunity to wage wars, otherwise, he was no less than his predecessor. In fact, Jesus (as) instructed his disciples to sell their clothes and purchase swords. It is absolutely true that if the Holy Qur’an had not come to guide us, we would lose faith in all of these Prophets. This is a favour of the Holy Qur’an upon all the Prophets, and it is a favour of Muhammad, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, that he appeared and absolved them of this accusation.
Recite the Holy Qur’an with deep reflection and it will become clearly evident that it teaches one to refrain from conflict. Show benevolence to those who have not attacked you. And as for those who are the first to attack you, and as for those who are tyrants, confront them only in defence, but do not exceed the bounds. In the beginning, Islam was faced with challenges of unparalleled proportions. If even a single person converted to Islam, the people would become ready to die and kill, and a thousand forms of aggression were inflicted upon them; and persecution is worse than killing. Therefore, in order to establish peace in society, resistance was necessary. If the Hindus raise an allegation, this is not surprising or disappointing. But it is indeed surprising and disappointing when those whose own affairs at home are even more objectionable raise allegations against others. The Christians have been most unjust in raising these sorts of allegations. Is this the level of their faith?
Then, among other matters of secondary importance, slavery is another concept with which they take issue. This is despite the fact that the Holy Qur’an has given teachings for the emancipation of slaves—emphatic teachings at that; in fact, such teachings that are not present in any other scripture. These are the unimportant issues that these people make a target for objection. Then they present misinformation to those who are uneducated and also to freethinking youngsters. Therefore, when you put forward an objection, you must only consider that to be a sin and worthy of objection which is a sin in the estimation of God and not what the Christian priests deem to be objectionable. I have been meeting with priests since the age of sixteen or seventeen, however, due to the light that God had given me, I was always able to see through their deceptive ways.