22 December 1901
Malfuzat – Volume IV, Part 3
Similarly, they raise an allegation against the concept of polygamy. However, I must say with extreme regret that these foolish people who raise this allegation do not stop to think for a moment what effect this has on their own Lord Christ. It grieves me deeply when I see that this allegation of the Christian priests is actually a vicious attack on Jesus (as) himself. The reason being that Mary wedded a man who had a prior wife. Then what would we say about this child? Moreover, when Mary and her mother had vowed before God to not marry, then what calamity and affliction had descended so that she was married? It would have been better for her to deliver this baby of the holy spirit in the holy temple. One must say with great disappointment that the Christians have not looked into their own home. Otherwise, it was the duty of these people to be the first to accept the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, because they had similar examples to follow. However, just as they lost that time, even today they do not accept the Promised Messiah, even though the account of Elijah (as) is before them, and this is the entire criterion for the truthfulness of the Messiah. If the Messiah actually revived the dead, then why did he not breathe life into Elijah (as) and bring him back to life? This would have saved the Jews from falling into trial, and even the Messiah himself would have been saved from the pain and difficulty to which he was subject, due to the metaphoric interpretation he presented in relation to Elijah (as). I have a book by a Jewish author who clearly writes that if God Almighty asks us about our rejection of the Messiah, we will put the book of Malachi before Him and say, does this not state that Elijah (as) would come before the Messiah; where does this state that John (as) would come? He has argued this extensively, and then the author makes an appeal to the readers by saying: you tell me, am I right or wrong? Therefore, it is particulars such as these which people present in a negative light to deceive others. In selecting your allegations, do keep these points in mind, which I have just told you about.
The matter of religion is a very important and sensitive affair. This requires great reflection and contemplation. One ought to adopt a perspective that accommodates the commonalities between religious communities. It should always be kept in mind that something for which there are no examples cannot be acceptable. For instance, if someone says that a thousand rupees were put in a chest, and it has magically vanished into thin air, who would believe this? This is also the state of Christian doctrines as well. You should gather your objections and present them; God willing, I will respond to them.”
Munshi Abdul-Haqq: If you can disprove the Trinity and the Atonement, I will perhaps ask nothing else.
Promised Messiah (as): In due course, God willing, I shall indeed present so many arguments to refute the concepts of Trinity and Atonement as will exceed
what is deemed sufficient to prove their falsity. However, in my opinion, if you follow the course which I have indicated, this would prove most beneficial. At this instance, I do not wish to confuse our discussions, but to allude briefly, I do consider it necessary to say that presently there are three peoples: Jews, Muslims and Christians. Among them, the Jews and Muslims agree with one another on their belief regarding the Unity of God; the Christians, however, believe in the Trinity. Now, I ask the question that if the doctrine of Trinity was actually true, and if this was the real means for salvation, then why such silence that no sign of this teaching can be found anywhere in the Torah? You can ask the Jews and see what they have to say about this. Additionally, there is another point that is worthy of reflection. There are different sects among the Jews and there is disagreement between them on various issues, but as for their profession of God’s Oneness, there is no disagreement whatsoever. If belief in Trinity was truly the foundation for salvation, would every single sect forget this teaching without even one or two denominations remaining firm on this supposed doctrine? Here we have a great nation among whom there have always been thousands upon thousands of scholars in every era, and among whom Prophets appeared continuously until the time of the Messiah, peace be upon him. Would it not be a matter of wonder if every one among them was completely oblivious to such a teaching which was given to them through Moses, peace be upon him, especially when this fundamental teaching formed the basis for their salvation? This is completely illogical and absurd. This clearly demonstrates that the doctrine of Trinity is a self-invented concept; there is no mention of it in the prophetic scriptures, nor should there have been, because it is contrary to the truth.
Hence, agreement among the Jews in respect of God’s Unity and the fact that none of them subscribe to the doctrine of Trinity is a manifest argument that this is a false doctrine. In fact, there has always been disagreement even among the various sects within Christianity in relation to the Trinity. The Unitarian sect among the Christians is present even today. I once asked a Jew if the concept of Trinity is mentioned anywhere in the Torah, or if there is any trace of it in their traditional practice. The person clearly stated: ‘Absolutely not, our doctrine of divine Unity is precisely in accord with what the Holy Qur’an teaches and none of our sects within Judaism believe in the Trinity.’ He also stated that if salvation hinged upon belief in the Trinity, then where the Jews were instructed to write the commandments of the Torah on their doorposts and sleeves, they should
also have been instructed to write something about the Trinity.
Then, the Promised Messiah (as) said: “The second argument which proves this to be false is that no parallel for this concept can be found in the law of intuition. In fact, the law of intuition itself reflects the phenomenon of divine Oneness. Reverend Pfander has confessed in his books that if a person lives on an island where the Trinity has not been introduced, they will be judged by God according to the doctrine of divine Unity, and not Trinity. So, this clearly demonstrates that the law of intuition calls for Unity and not Trinity. For if the Trinity accorded with human nature, then this would have been the criterion by which to judge a person.
The third argument which proves the falsehood of this doctrine is that all of the basic elements which God Almighty has created are spherical in shape. You may observe a droplet of water, the heavenly bodies and even the earth. All of these things are spherical in form because this is the shape of oneness. Therefore, if God was characterised by trinity, these things ought to have been triangular in shape. Notwithstanding all of these points, the burden of proof lies with the claimant. A person who believes in the Trinity is responsible for putting forth arguments in favour of this concept. Anyone who reflects with righteousness upon the points that I have made regarding divine Unity—citing the continuous practice of the Jews despite mutual disagreement between various sects on other issues, the mark that we see in the law of intuition present within us, and the parallels that are found in the physical law of nature—will come to realise that the extent to which emphasis has been put to promote the Trinity is a manifest injustice.
It is human nature that one will never tread a path that causes unease. This is why most people prefer to walk on public ways as opposed to narrow trails, because they feel no fear or danger, and they know that these streets are more reliable. Therefore, when this is a phenomenon that we observe on a daily basis, then why would anyone follow a path for the hereafter that causes unease, for which there is no sufficient, reliable, and most of all, living testimony. Now, the material world has carved thousands of avenues, but fortunate and blessed is the one who abandons the allure of this world and embraces a life of simplicity and devotion to God and sets out to search for the path that leads to God. Indeed, those who search for Him with sincere intention, find Him.
I have an ocean at my disposal to uproot the Christian faith and now the time has come for this spell to be broken so that the idol of the cross may fall. The fact of the matter is that even if Allah the Exalted had not raised me, the present era has given rise to such factors as would have exposed the truth about Christianity anyway. For it is opposed to the jealousy and majesty of God Almighty to suggest that a child born from the womb of a mother should be God—a child who is not even minutely free from human needs and requirements.
I have written a book in which I have proven with solid evidence that it is a false notion that the Messiah died on the cross. The truth is that he was taken down from the cross alive and after he was saved, he travelled to Kashmir, where he lived until the age of 120 years. Even today, his grave is present in Mohalla Khanyar and he is known by the name Yuz Asaf or the Prince Prophet. This fact is not without irrefutable and compelling evidence. In fact, the account of the crucifixion written in the Torah itself shows that the Messiah did not die on the cross. Firstly, the Messiah has likened himself to Jonah (as). Now did Jonah (as) enter the belly of the whale dead or alive? Moreover, the wife of Pilate saw a terrible dream of which she informed Pilate as well after which he began to think of ways in which he could save Jesus (as). This is why Pilate attempted to release the Messiah by various methods. Ultimately, he washed his hands and said that he was innocent of this man’s blood. Then, when the Jews could not be dissuaded in any way, efforts were made to put Jesus (as) on the cross on a Friday in the late afternoon. A person would die on the cross over a period of many days, due to thirst, hunger, being out in the sun etc. but the Messiah was saved from this condition. For how could it be possible for the Messiah to not be taken down from the cross before sunset on the very same Friday, in light of the Judaic religious law, which stated that it was a grave sin for anyone to remain on the cross either on the day of Sabbath or the night before. Since the Messiah was put on the cross on Friday in the last hour, when certain events transpired, including a storm, he was swiftly taken down. Then, the two robbers who were put on the cross along with Jesus (as) had their bones broken, but the Messiah’s bones were not broken. To continue, the Messiah’s body was handed over to a man who was his disciple. In reality, even Pilate and his wife were followers of Jesus (as). As such, it is even narrated that Pilate was a Christian martyr and his wife is described as a saintly woman.
Greater than all this, is the remedy known as the Ointment of Jesus, about which Muslim, Jewish, Roman, Christian and Magian physicians have all written in their works that this was prepared to heal the wounds of the Messiah; this is also called the Ointment of Jesus, the Ointment of the Disciples, the Ointment of the Messengers, or Marham-e-Shalikha, etc. This remedy is recorded in at least one thousand books and no Christian can prove that the Messiah sustained any wounds aside from the ones inflicted upon him during the crucifixion; at the time the disciples were present as well. Now tell me if all of these circumstances arise together, would this not be clear testimony to the fact that the Messiah was taken down from the cross alive?
At present I do not wish to engage in a lengthy discussion on how Jesus (as) set out in search of the various Jewish tribes that had dispersed to the land of Afghanistan and Kashmir, after which he ultimately died in Kashmir. However, even European research scholars now accept that the Kashmiris are actually none other than the children of Israel. Accordingly, this is what Bernier has written in his travelogue as well. Therefore, when it is proven—and in fact, established by authentic accounts—that Jesus (as) did not die on the cross, rather, he was taken down alive, then what remains of the Atonement?