24 December 1901
Malfuzat – Volume IV, Part 3
us these faculties in vain.
Therefore, if the Gospel stresses one faculty alone—and indeed it does—I ask you to tell me with justice and fear of God, does this not show disrespect to the action of God whereby He has vested the human soul with various faculties and
capabilities?
The Gospel Stresses One Faculty Alone
If a Christian were to say that the faculty of meekness and forbearance alone are sufficient to nurture and develop all of a person’s other faculties, would anyone doubt the ‘intelligence’ of such a person? Even the attributes of God are
diverse and through them different actions are manifested. We have never seen a
Christian priest who, for example, wears clothing suited for hot conditions when it is cold and continues to eat foods that are not suited for the present season, or
who continues to drink their mother’s milk for their entire life, or continues to wear small sized shirts and trousers from when they were a child. Therefore, anyone who possesses faith and fear of God would feel embarrassed presenting such
a teaching. If forgiveness and forbearance was enough, then why did the followers of the Gospel take great pains to formulate laws for civil and criminal offences?
Why was there a need for a constitution in politics and to govern the affairs of
the State? As for those who turn the other cheek when slapped on the first, what need have they of armies and the police. For the sake of God, may the people reflect. So, this principle has ruined the rights that are due to God’s creation, in
fact, it has ruined all the human faculties.
Islam Supports Every Human Faculty
Now in comparison to this, look at the teaching of Islam and how it has nurtured all human faculties and powers. Firstly, Islam has taught that no faculty or strength conferred upon a human being is evil in its own right; rather, adopting an extreme and ill use makes it an evil action, whereas proper and balanced use makes the same action a good moral. It is this very principle that other nations have failed to understand, while the Holy Qur’an has explained it. In view of this principle, the Holy Qur’an states:
Meaning, the punishment of an injury is an injury the like thereof, except for the one who forgives, when forgiveness brings about reformation. The Holy Qur’an has invariably spoken of forgiveness, but not so that a wicked person may increase in their evil as a result of that forgiveness, or so that the laws and system governing civil or political affairs are disturbed; rather, in such circumstances, punishment is necessary. Forgiveness has only been encouraged in the case that it brings about reformation. Now tell me, is this not a teaching that completes and perfects human morals or is this purpose achieved by turning the other cheek and being slapped? Even the law of nature proclaims its support of the Islamic teaching just mentioned; and practically as well, this is the only teaching that is logical. If it is the Gospel that is to be followed, then today all of the courts should be shut down, and all police and security services should be suspended for just two days and then you will see the oceans of blood that begin to flow by accepting the Gospel. If the teaching of the Gospel had not been deficient and incomplete, then why were kings required to make new laws?
Therefore, this is the effect of the Gospel teaching on the rights owed to humanity. Now, I would also like to tell you what Dayanand has presented in light of these two principles as being the essence of the Vedas. As far as the rights due to Allah are concerned, the injustice he has committed is that he believes that God is not the Creator of anything. On the contrary, he believes that the particles and souls of this universe are eternal just like God Himself and He is only a joiner, which we would call a mu’allif in Arabic. Now what could be a greater destruction of the rights owed to Allah than to erase all of His attributes and reject His magnificent attribute of creation? When God is nothing more than a joiner, then I do not understand how the creation of this world would be affected even if at some point in time God died. For if God has not made the creation, then it is inherently independent in its existence and life. What need is there for God? No right or power on the part of God is established by His mere joining together of various elements, especially when body and soul both possess various powers enabling them to bond and separate. The soul possesses magnificent powers, like the faculty of vision. The manner in which the human soul can manifest this strength cannot be matched by the soul of any other creature, such as a cow or ox. It is a pity that the Arya Samajists do not consider even these human souls—along with all their powers and properties—to be the creation of God. Now, the question is when both bodies and souls exist independently, and when they possess the inherent ability to join and separate as well, what evidence can be derived from them to establish the existence of God? For when it is said that this water-vessel for example can walk one step, what reason is there to reject that it can walk two?
There can only be two kinds of argumentation in favour of the existence of God. Firstly, one observes the creation and reasons for the existence of the creator. This logical possibility does not exist here because they say that God has not created anything. If God had created anything, one could derive from this an argument for the existence of the Creator. The second possibility relates to extraordinary occurrences and miracles. This also furnishes powerful arguments in favour of the existence of God. However, in this respect also, Dayanand and all of the Arya Samajists have confessed that the Vedas do not contain any prophecies or mention of miraculous happenings—they say that there is no such thing as miracles. Now tell me what method remains for one to establish an argument in favour of the existence of God according to their religious doctrine? Then, their God is of such a nature that even if one tirelessly worships God for their entire life in the most assiduous manner, one will never receive eternal salvation; one will always have to go round in this circle of reincarnation, at times they may become an insect or something else.
As far as the rights due to humanity is concerned, it is sufficient to say that they believe in a concept known as niyoga, which stipulates that if a husband and wife cannot have children, the wife is permitted to sleep with another man to have a child. All of the expenses to provide food, water, fine tonics, bedding, etc. to the man who gives the gift of his sperm is the responsibility of the husband who permits his wife to bear the child of this other man. What could be more shameful than this? This is just a brief example. There was a teacher here in Qadian by the name of Pundit Somraj who was an Arya Samajist. I invited him to speak to me in the presence of a group of people—among which there were some Arya Samajists as well—and I asked him about this practice. He said: ‘Yes, what is wrong with this?’ When I heard him say this, all I could do was be astonished. Other Hindus present began to chant out the name of Rama in approval. When I heard this, I told them that I had heard enough and they could leave. So, this is the level of their consideration for the rights due to other human beings.”
Mr Abdul-Haqq: I have read your book Arya Dharam. Promised Messiah (as): The summary of my entire exposition is that every true religion and doctrine may be recognised by these three signs: namely, scriptural evidence, rationality and heavenly succour. I have briefly shown you from various aspects that the Christian faith does not meet this criteria. There is no mention in the Judaic scriptures of the Trinity, and we find nothing on atonement either; they were never waiting for the coming of a son of God or God. Rationality repels such notions from afar. In terms of signs, it is difficult to find anyone among these people who even meets the basic requirements of a person possessing faith. Once a Christian by the name of Fateh Masih said that he was a recipient of revelation. When I asked him to make a prophecy, he became anxious and instead challenged me by saying that a text would be written on a piece of paper and placed inside a closed envelope, and I should tell him what is written on it without seeing the text. God Almighty informed me that I should go ahead and accept this challenge. When I accepted, in the end, Reverend Weitbrecht said before an audience of many hundreds that Fateh Masih was a liar. Therefore, the truth is a thing which is not only supported by the testimony of scriptural evidence and reason, but is also supported by the testimony of divine light, and this form of testimony is the greatest of all. This is the one sign of the life of a religion. For a religion that comes from the living God must always possess the spirit of life within it so that this may serve as a shining symbol of its relationship with the Living God. However, this is non-existent among the Christians, even though the present era is known as the age of science and progress. Extraordinary signs of this nature are greatly needed so they can serve as evidence in support of the existence of God Almighty.