24 December 1901
Malfuzat – Volume IV, Part 2
Now, if you judge Christian doctrine and faith against these criteria, you will find nothing but decaying bones and dead elements, as it were. They all accept unanimously that today there is not a single individual in their midst who can show signs that would set a seal of attestation on the proof of the truthfulness of their religion and the Messiah’s blood. This is a great thing. I would even state that according to the signs stipulated in the Gospel, it would perhaps be impossible to find even a single person who possesses faith among the Christians.
Nevertheless, put aside living signs for a moment. The Christians present a sign in support of their religion by giving details regarding the whereabouts of a certain grave from which the Messiah resurrected a dead person. These narrations have no greater worth than stories. This is why I have said repeatedly that these spectacles of healing disease, which are shown even by certain Hindu ascetics and by experts of mesmerism in this modern-day, cannot be accepted by anyone as forms of miracles. It is prophecy alone that serves as a powerful sign and is seen with honour in every era. I must say with regret, however, regarding the prophecies of the Messiah that are recorded in the Gospel, that one cannot help but laugh on reading them: there will be famines, there will be earthquakes, the rooster will crow, etc. Now go to any village and you will see that roosters crow all the time, do they not? Similarly, famines and earthquakes also are ordinary things. Experts today are able to reveal even greater detail by telling us that there would be a storm at such and such time, or that there will be rainfall at a certain time.
Now look at the prophecies of the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, how 600 years prior he said that a fire would emerge which would spare vegetation but consume stone, and it was fulfilled. They should present shining prophecies like this. I published an announcement with a reward for 1,000 rupees about the prophecies of the Messiah. However, to this day not a single Christian has been able to prove that in their strength of proof and in number, the prophecies of the Messiah are greater than my prophecies, of which the entire world is a witness.
The miracles of the Messiah which are presented in the form of stories furnish no evidence of any extraordinary divine succour. Today, greater miracles and wonders are shown in the field of medicine. This point is further reinforced when we read in the Gospel that there was a pool which healed those who bathed in it just once. Such springs exist even today in certain European countries. Even in India, the water from certain springs or wells possess this effect. A few days ago, there was a story published in the newspapers that the water from a certain well was curing people suffering from leprosy. So what signs of divine succour should one look to in the Christian faith? The signs of the past are like the ones I have just described, and in the present age no one can show any signs either. If one is supposed to believe blindly, then what fault have the Hindus committed so that their 330 million gods should not be accepted; why should the tales narrated in the Puranas not be accepted? Dayanand invented a new movement and washed his hands of the Hindu faith by stating that the name of Ram is not mentioned anywhere in the Vedas, but the essence of the Vedas that he presented himself also turned out to be nothing but filth.
There are two things which form the essence of religion and in actuality, these two aspects serve as the basic foundation for every religion: the rights owed to God and the rights due to God’s creation. However, in both these respects, Dayanand has presented nothing but filth, and he states that this is the essence of the Vedic teaching.
One ought to remember that there are only two rights. Firstly, there are the rights due to God, which relate to the manner in which one should believe in Him and worship Him. Secondly, the rights owed to other human beings, or in other words, how one should show benevolence and sympathy towards God’s creation.
I will speak at another time about the teachings that Dayanand has given in this respect. However, firstly I must state that in both these principles, the Christians have also demonstrated the most absurd of examples. We have already observed in respect of the rights owed to God that they abandoned the God Who manifested Himself to Moses (as) and other pious and righteous souls, and they have instead turned a weak mortal into God. As for the rights due to God’s creation, they have disfigured them to such an extent that there is no way to set them right. The entire teaching of the Gospel leans to one side and it cannot nurture all of the faculties given to human beings. Firstly, by accepting the concept of Atonement there can be no way to prevent the infringement of the rights due to humanity at large. For when a person accepts that the blood of the Messiah has removed and cleansed the impurity of sin—even though blood cannot cleanse filth in ordinary circumstances either—the Christians ought to tell us what, pragmatically, prevents them from creating disorder in the world? How can one believe for certain that any punishment would be given for stealing, usurping another person’s wealth, robbery, murder, or giving false testimony? If despite believing in the concept of Atonement, a sin is still a sin, then I fail to understand what is the meaning of Atonement and what have the Christians gained from it?
Therefore, in order to completely fulfil the rights of humanity, Allah the Exalted vested human beings with various faculties, and the purpose was that we would use these faculties in the appropriate instances to benefit humanity at large. However, the Gospel lays all of its emphasis on the faculties of forbearance and meekness, even though they can have the influence of a deadly poison in certain circumstances.
So our civic life, which is built on the social interaction of people possessing various dispositions, inherently demands by virtue of this very mixing and structure that we employ all of our faculties at the appropriate time and place. However, the Gospel has completely ignored the importance of gauging the situation and circumstances at hand, and blindly gives the same teaching in every instance. Is turning the other cheek when slapped on the first a teaching that can ever be adopted in the practical sense? Have you ever seen anyone give their cloak also to the one who asks for their shirt? Can any man, no matter how ardent a lover he may be of the Gospel teaching, ever hand over his daughter to the evil and wicked man who attacks his wife? Of course not.
Just as it is necessary for us to consume various foods according to the changing weather and seasons, and dress accordingly as well for the health and wellbeing of our body, so too, regulation is necessary for the wellbeing of the soul and to develop and nurture its faculties and properties. In our physical way of life, just as we must give due consideration to hot and cold, leniency and strictness, move-
ment and restraint, in the same manner, for our spiritual health, the very bestowal of differing faculties to us is clear evidence of the fact that the wellbeing of the soul necessarily depends on the correct use of these faculties. If we do not employ
these various faculties or if we teach that they should not be used, then in the estimation of a God-fearing, indignant individual, the one who gives such a teaching would be guilty of insulting God, because such a one suggests that God has given