An Address on 27 December 1901 After the Asr Prayer
Malfuzat – Volume IV, Part 6
Holy Prophetsas appeared, he was met with thousands of ailing people, all of whom had reached the final stage of their disease, and they were close to death. In truth, they had already died, as is evident from the historical account of that time. Now, one ought to reflect with justice. One cannot even reform the faults of a servant. Then what greater argument can there be in favour of the truthfulness of a man who reforms a corrupt nation so that they become as though they had no faults to begin with?
One must say with regret that the Muslims have not reflected over this point. Otherwise, these are such shining arguments that such examples are rarely found in the lives of other Prophets. For example, when we look at the Messiah as compared to the Holy Prophetsas, one is terribly disappointed that the Messiah could not even properly reform a few disciples and always said that they were weak in faith. He even referred to some as Satan. They were so greedy that Judas Iscariot, the treasurer of the Messiah, would steal on certain occasions from the pouch that mostly remained in his possession. In the end, it was this very greed of his which compelled him to have his teacher and spiritual guide arrested for a mere thirty pieces of silver. However, when we look at the companions of the Noble Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, we observe that they thought nothing of even laying down their lives, let alone that the impurity of treachery would have any part in them. Even European historians have had to accept the fact that the love, loyalty and obedience that the companions of the Noble Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, demonstrated towards their Guide, may Allah shower His peace and blessings upon him, is an example that cannot be found among the followers of any other Prophet. The Messiah, peace be upon him, was especially deprived in this regard. Now, his greatness has been exaggerated to such an extent that, despite the weaknesses, and despite the aforementioned examples and accounts recorded in the Gospel, he has been turned into God. The illustration of his spiritual influence, magnetism and attraction that is shown as an example is that he could not even put right a handful of disciples. Then, in this case, what can be expected of him?
When the Christians are unable to provide an adequate response on the weakness of the disciples in terms of their faith and practice, they answer by saying that after the Messiah, they developed power and strength, and ultimately became a perfect example. However, this response is so laughable that as the Persian saying goes: ‘the excuse for a sin is worse than the sin itself.’ They suggest that in the presence of a lamp, there was no light, but after the lamp was extinguished, then the light suddenly appeared? Remarkable! Apparently, the disciples could not be cleansed and purified in the presence of a Prophet, but after him they were transformed? This would demonstrate that in his spiritual influence the Messiah was even more weak and powerless. Godforbid, was this some curse that until it remained before the disciples, they could not be purified, but when it was taken away, then they were filled with the Holy Spirit? Unbelievable!
Many British writers have also taken up their pens to write on this subject and have expressed the view that the Messiah came to a group of people who were already aware of the objectives of the Torah. They were a people who had heard the words of God from the Scribes and Pharisees. It would be no surprise if they had already been pious and righteous. For 1400 years continuously, every so often, Prophets and Messengers came to them, who conveyed to them the commandments and injunctions of God. It was as though their very seed was vested with a nature that inclined them to believe in God and revere His laws and abstain from evil deeds. How then was it possible for them to remain ignorant of the teaching that the Messiah wished to give them?
Even if the Messiah had reformed these people, this would not have been special by any measure. What merit is there in the efforts of a person who seeks to improve the condition of an individual who has already been fully cured by another physician? Therefore, assuming the impossible, if the Messiah did give some benefit to the people, this is nothing praiseworthy. It is unfortunate, however, that in the case of the Messiah, no benefit was given at all. Judas sold away his master for a mere thirty pieces of silver; Peter stood before Christ and cursed him. But on the other hand, the companions of the Noble Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, offered their heads and embraced death in the presence of the Holy Prophetsas at Uhud and Badr. Now justice demands that we recognise that if the Noble Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, had not appeared and if it had not been for the Holy Qur’an, then what would we say about a Prophet whose teaching and spiritual influence left behind the likes of Judas Iscariot and Peter? This was the state of his spiritual influence. His teaching also was so deficient that no wise person could ever refer to the Messiah’s teaching as being complete. Moreover, it has no relevance in the way of civic, social and political life, and has left behind no positive and lasting effects.
The Messiah’s claim is diametrically opposed to rationality, conscience, the law of nature, and the doctrines and established beliefs of past peoples. These British writers have conceded that if the Holy Qur’an had not appeared, a terrible state of affairs would have ensued. They have confessed that the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, reformed bloodthirsty savages, and then made them into a community of such truthful and loyal people that in their companionship of the Prophetsas, they never once cared for their own lives or wealth. Such loyalty, obedience, sacrifice and devotion cannot be developed until the leader and master possesses the greatest spiritual influence and magnetism. Then, an author writes that the Arabs were not only taught true righteousness, but their intellectual faculties also were trained and nurtured. The disciples would not have even been able to oversee the workings of a village, but the companions governed over the world. Who can say that the parents of Abu Bakr or Umar, may Allah be pleased with both of them, ever ruled or governed over a state and this is why they were experienced in administration and rule, or the laws of governance? No, not at all. This was due solely to the training of the Noble Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and due to the perfect teaching of the Holy Qur’an that on the one hand these people were not only transformed into angels, but also paragons of intellect.
It is manifestly evident that if a physician were to cure a group of diseased people who were deemed incurable, one would have to accept that the physician was a master in his field. Despite this, anyone who does not accept his expertise would be deemed nothing more than an ignorant fool. In the same way, our Noble Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, cured hundreds and thousands who were diseased with sin and all of these sick people were themselves full of a thousand spiritual maladies and ailments. Take the example of a person who says they are suffering from headache and cataract as well, along with dropsy, arthralgia and splenalgia, and so on and so forth. Now if a physician cured such an individual and restored them to good health, we would have no choice but to accept that the physician’s diagnosis and treatment proved effective and unfailing. The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, also cured people who were suffering from thousands of spiritual diseases. The more one visualises their weaknesses and their state of sin, and then observes the change and transformation that came about when they accepted Islam, the more one is filled with reverence for the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and the more one appreciates his spiritual influence. Obstinance and prejudice is another matter which, due to its darkness, takes away one’s ability to see the light of truth. However, one whose heart possesses justice and whose mind possesses sound reason will have to confess that in bringing about such a magnificent transformation towards piety, there has been no one greater than the Holy Prophetsas to step foot on earth.
O Allah, bless Muhammadsas and his family. Now in contrast, I would ask, who did the Messiah cure? What miracle did he show of his own spirituality, firm resolve and spiritual influence? There is no benefit in simply making verbal claims until they are demonstrated in the practical sense. When the greatness of the Messiah has been exaggerated to such an extent that despite his weakness and helplessness he has been given the position of God, we ought to have seen the effects of his general mercy; we ought to have seen a unique manifestation of his divine power, so that a death would overtake the life of sin on earth and the world would have become full of such people who lived like angels. But how strange indeed that he could not even reform the select few who always remained in his company?
The Christians are quick to compare their Lord Christ to our Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, but strangely they feel no embarrassment in the fact that they cannot bear to make the sort of comparison that I have just made. If they were to compare the Messiah to the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, as I have done, they would see the truth.
Always remember that a Prophet comes to prove that the following is true:
Develop within yourselves the attributes of Allah. Through their practical state they demonstrate that they are a true example of Allah’s attributes. It is evident that all of the things that God Almighty has created in the world are beneficial to man in some way or other. For example, God has created trees; the leaves, shade, bark, wood, fruit, in short, all the parts of a tree are beneficial to us in some form. A person derives many forms of benefit from the light of the sun. In the same way, all other parts of creation are useful and beneficial for us. However, it is disappointing to observe the state of the Christians who proclaim that a humble man is God and the son of God, but they have been unable to show what benefit he has given to the world. Moreover, they have no example to show of any manifestation of Christ that demonstrates divine power. Their son of God would have been best to demonstrate, as the saying goes: ‘if the father is unable, then the son ought to have done everything.’ However, when one reflects on his life history, one must say with disappointment that he did nothing—all he did was commit suicide. Upon witnessing the misfortune of others, is it wise and beneficial to sacrifice one’s own life? What benefit does this give to the ones struck by misfortune?
As for the demands of justice and integrity, in comparison to the Noble Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, one must accept that the Messiah failed completely. The fact of the matter is that the Messiah did not receive the same opportunity that was afforded to the Noble Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him; and this is unfortunate for him. However, this is why we cannot say at all that the Messiah presented a complete example. There are two aspects that complete a person’s faith. Firstly, it must be observed that when a person is subject to afflictions, what sort of relationship do they maintain with God Almighty? Does the person show sincerity, devotion, perseverance and true loyalty in the face of these afflictions, accepting the will of Allah Almighty with an open heart, and praise and glorify Him, or does the individual complain and lament? Secondly, when one receives success, prosperity and glory, in this state of power and good fortune, does one forget God Almighty and change in a way that is objectionable? Or does one continue to hold the same relationship with God, and praise and glorify Him, and forgive one’s enemies, and demonstrate magnanimity and nobility by showing benevolence towards them?
Let us take the example of a person who is beaten severely. If the person was never powerful enough to punish the attacker and seek retribution, but still says that he has not retaliated against his aggressor, this cannot be deemed a moral quality. We cannot call this forbearance and restraint, because the victim was never powerful enough to exact retribution. In fact, if someone swore at such a person, they would perhaps begin to weep out of grief. So this is a case of the proverbial ‘saint’ who is holy because he has no other choice. What relation does this have with good morals and forbearance?