An Address on 27 December 1901 After the Asr Prayer

Malfuzat – Volume IV, Part 7

The moral example of the Messiah is similar to what I have just described. If he had received any powerful authority and if he had the opportunity to seek revenge from his enemies, and then if he had showed love towards his enemies and forgave them their wrongdoings, we would invariably accept that, indeed, he demonstrated an example of his lofty morals. But when no such opportunity was available to him, it is utterly shameful to hold him up as an example of good morals. Until both of these aspects are applicable, there can be no evidence of moral quality. Now in contrast, observe our Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. The people of Mecca exiled him and continuously inflicted all manner of pain upon the Holy Prophetsas for thirteen years. His companions were subjected to such brutal and extreme torment that even the thought of them makes the heart tremble. The patience and forbearance that the Holy Prophetsas demonstrated is plainly clear. However, when the Holy Prophetsas migrated upon the instruction of God Almighty and he was given the victory of Mecca, in view of all the pain, hardship and brutality that the Meccans had inflicted upon him and his community for thirteen long years, he was well within his rights to execute everyone and destroy the people of Mecca completely. No one would have been able to object if they had been executed, because these people were worthy of death due to their atrocities. Therefore, if the Holy Prophetsas was possessed of a wrathful disposition, this was the perfect time for revenge—all of Meccans had been arrested. But what did the Holy Prophetsas do? He released them all and proclaimed:

No blame shall lie on you this day.

This is no insignificant matter. When one sees the pain and torment that the Meccans inflicted, and observes the manner in which these cruel enemies were forgiven by a person who had power and authority over them, this is an example of the moral quality of the Holy Prophetsas the like of which cannot be found anywhere else in the history of the world.

It is also worthy of note that the Meccans did not simply reject the Holy Prophetsas. Mere denial owed to a person’s simplicity does not move Allah the Exalted to send down punishment in this world. However, when the person who rejects a Prophet departs from the limits of nobility and humanity, and begins to raise allegations in a shameless and abusive manner, and when they do not stop at allegations, but increase their efforts to the extent that they conspire to inflict all sorts of anguish and injury, it is then that the jealousy of Allah Almighty is roused, and for the sake of His divinely commissioned ones and Messengers, He destroys the oppressors, as He destroyed the people of Noah (as), or the people of Lot (as). Divine chastisement of this nature always descends due to these sorts of evils and cruelty inflicted upon the ones commissioned by God and their communities. Otherwise, divine punishment for mere denial is not given in this world. The affair of such people is with God. He has created another world for their punishments. Divine chastisement descends when denial is taken to the level where pain is inflicted and when denial takes on the form of mockery and jest. If a person courteously and respectfully says that they do not understand the matter at hand and therefore they are reluctant to accept, such a form of denial does not draw in the punishment of God, because this is solely due to a person’s simplicity and lack of knowledge. I can honestly say that if the people of Noah (as) had objected in a noble manner, Allah the Exalted would not have seized them. It is a nation’s own wrongdoing that invites the punishment of God. God Almighty even states that those who come to listen to the Holy Qur’an should be conveyed back to their places of security, even if they are opponents who reject the message. There is no compulsion or coercion in religion, as the Holy Qur’an states:

There should be no compulsion in religion.

However, if someone kills or conspires to kill, and strives in the way of mischief and to inflict harm, it is inevitable that they will be punished. It is a matter of principle that anyone who indulges in criminal behaviour is apprehended. Hence, on account of their atrocities and criminal actions, the people of Mecca too were worthy of receiving harsh punishments, and it would have been good for this holy land and its environs to be cleansed of their beings once and for all. However, this man was:

A mercy for all peoples.

He was a man that held true to the words:

You surely possess high moral excellences.

So, even though he possessed full power and authority over his enemies who were worthy of being executed, he proclaimed:

No blame shall lie on you this day.

Now, the Christian priests should tell us where we should look to find such an example of moral excellence in the Messiah? Where can we find an example like that of the Holy Prophetsas from the life of the Messiah, when according to the Christian belief, he was always the subject of physical abuse and had no place to lay his head? This is not my belief, and I cannot imagine that a Prophet and a man appointed by God Almighty could ever be in such a humiliating and deprived state, but the hallmark of a man is his morals. However, in the life of the teacher himself who taught that one should turn the other cheek when slapped on the first, we find no practical example of this ‘moral quality.’

While he instructed others to refrain from abusive language, he himself called the holy Scribes and Pharisees among the Jews, adulterers, vipers and the brood of vipers. In contrast, the Jews possessed better morals than the Messiah for they would address him as ‘worthy teacher,’ but he would refer to them as adulterers and liken them to dogs and swine—even though the Scribes and Pharisees would ask him questions in a soft and gentle manner. Even in terms of worldly honour, they were given seats in the Roman government. The questions of such people should have been responded to in a very generous manner and they should have been given detailed explanations; instead the Messiah just continued to let out a stream of expletives. Is this what we call good morals? I reiterate that if it were not for the Holy Qur’an, if our Noble Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, had not appeared, put aside the divinity and prophethood of the Messiah, a wise person would perhaps be reluctant in even considering him to be a highminded person who possessed good morals. This is an all-encompassing favour of the Holy Qur’an and our Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, upon all the Prophets—and especially the Messiah—that they have provided proof of the truthfulness of previous Prophets.

Furthermore, there is another aspect from which we should analyse the divinity of Messiah. As far as his moral standing was concerned, we know that he swore at the venerable sages among the Jews, and ultimately when he was apprehended, he prayed to such an extent as is beyond measure, but regrettably, we see that his night-long supplication was rejected completely, according to the Christian belief, and this prayer bore no fruits whatsoever. In reality, it was contrary to the greatness of a god to pray in the first place. What he should have done was manifest some miracle that demonstrated his divine power so that the poor Jews would have had no other option but to accept and submit. Yet in this instance, we observe the very opposite. As the Persian saying goes: ‘how can he who is lost, guide others?’

Here, the state is that the Messiah prays, he wails, he laments, but unfortunately, his prayer goes unanswered, and the cup of death that is filled with the poison of the curse of the cross is not taken away. Now, what can we gain from a god who himself implores another and then remains deprived. On the one hand, he teaches that if you implore, you shall receive, but on the other hand, he demonstrates an example of his own failure and frustration. Now, someone ought to tell me with a sense of justice if any Christian priest can find comfort and solace in such a failure of a god?

Therefore, no matter the perspective from which we compare the Messiah to the Holy Prophetsas—including this claim of divinity—it becomes evidently clear that the Messiah simply cannot be compared to the Holy Prophetsas at all. The life of the Holy Prophetsas is a magnificent life of success.

In respect of his exemplary morals, his spiritual influence, his firm resolve, the excellence and perfection of his teaching, his perfect example and the acceptance of his prayers, in short, in every respect, the Holy Prophetsas is distinguished with shining examples and signs. Even the most foolish and dull person, provided that their heart is not filled with unjust obstinacy and enmity, can easily accept that the Holy Prophetsas was a perfect example of the words:

·

10 of 10 left today