An Address on 27 December 1901 After the Asr Prayer
Malfuzat – Volume IV, Part 8
Develop within yourselves the attributes of Allah.
They will accept that he was the perfect man. However, when a person observes the life of the Messiah, a wise and just individual feels reluctant to accept that a man who responds to respectful and civilised comments with expletives, and refers to those who call him a worthy teacher as vipers, the brood of vipers and adulterers, could even be a Prophet, let alone God.
Aside from all of these points, the Jews were faced with another strange predicament, and apparently one can see how they could have been right. They had read in the book of Malachi that it was necessary for Elijah (as) to descend from heaven before the advent of the Messiah. Until he comes, the Messiah would not appear. Now, the Jews had no previous example before them of any second advent, and they had always read in their scriptures that Elijah (as) would descend from heaven. They did not witness Elijah (as) descend from heaven, so when the Messiah made his claim, on what basis would the Jews have accepted him? While the Messiah gave the verdict that John (as) had appeared as Elijah (as), the Jews had reasons, on face value, to reject this suggestion, because they were given the promise of Elijah (as), not the ‘likeness’ of Elijah (as). They had no previous precedent of this sort before them. Therefore, they felt compelled to reject the Messiah.
I have a book in my possession written by a Jew, who has vigorously argued this point and then makes an appeal saying, you tell me, what should we have done in such a case? In fact, he has gone so far as to write that if God Almighty calls us to account on this, we will open the book of Malachi and place it before God. So this was one of the challenges faced by the Jews. The second difficulty that they confronted was that the Messiah was crucified, and the curse of death on the cross further reinforced their denial. For they had read in the Torah that only a false prophet is hung on the cross and in turn becomes accursed. So, on the one hand, the Jews thought that Elijah (as) had not come, and then furthermore, the person who claimed to be the Messiah had given a verdict as regards the account of Elijah that was apparently in contradiction to the book of Malachi. As a result, their desire to oppose ‘a liar’ as it were, and the behaviour and conduct of the Messiah himself further inflamed the Jews—when he would call them adulterers, and vipers and the brood of vipers. Therefore, the Jews sought to crucify him; when they had hung him on the cross, their initial views were further strengthened because they saw that this man had been hung on the cross and he had therefore become accursed, so he could not have been truthful.
The Jews became firm in their belief that when this man himself had become accursed, how could he be an intercessor for others? His crucifixion had set a seal on his being a liar. Two witnesses are enough to have a man hung. They said to the Messiah at that time too that if you are truthful, then come down from the cross, but he could not. This increased their ill-thinking even further.
Since the Christians were unaware of the deeper connotations and meaning of curse when they initially claimed that the Messiah had taken God’s curse upon himself, they did not stop to think about the ultimate outcome. Furthermore, since they harboured spite for the Arabic language, they did not develop full mastery in Hebrew either. Both of these languages are branches of the same tree. A person who knows Arabic can study Hebrew with greater ease than others. But due to their malice, the Christians were unable to benefit from the Hebrew lexicon either.
The word la’nat or curse, describes a state when a person becomes extremely averse to God Almighty and when God Almighty is averse to them. Lexicons published at presses owned by Christians which come from Beirut also give the same definition of the word la’nat. The word la’in (accursed) refers to Satan. The level of these people’s understanding disappointments me immensely. For their own purpose, they have terribly dishonoured a most magnificent Prophet and have deemed him to be accursed. They did not stop to realise that the term ‘curse’ relates to the heart. Until a person’s heart is turned away from God, they cannot be accursed (mal’un). Now ask any Christian that is this definition of the word la’nat not agreed upon in both the Arabic and Hebrew lexicons? If the heart is not wicked and obstinate, and if it is the pleasure of God Almighty for which a person adopts a certain religion, then is this subject of ‘curse’ not sufficient to uproot the Christian faith? So firstly, one ought to reflect that when it was an accepted belief and it had already been stated in the Torah that cursed is the one hung on a tree and he is a liar, then tell me how can a person intercede on our behalf when he is himself cursed and a liar? As the saying goes: ‘how can he who is himself misguided, guide anyone else?’ I am truthful when I say that since the time that the Christians have forsaken God and have placed the crown of divinity on the head of a humble man, they have become blind—they cannot see a thing. On the one hand they deify a mortal, and on the other hand they put him on the cross and declare that he is accursed, whereafter they send him to hell for three days as well. Did he go to hell to advise the inmates of hell or did he go there to be an atonement for them?
So in brief, these are the sorts of inconsistencies that we have. Now the actual point is that not only this, but rather no moral example is established in the person of the Messiah, and it is only by the support of the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, that he is vindicated. If one had to accept him on the basis of the Gospel, who could believe in him in the face of all these difficulties? The Christians, as well as the Gospel, have even further stained his character. The sorts of allegations that are raised by the Jews are such that one feels embarrassed even to mention them. These brazen people have even accused the mother of Jesus (as). Then, there is another serious issue for which the Christians have no answer whatsoever, which is that the mother of Mary (as) had pledged that she would serve the Holy Temple and live as a renunciate and remain celibate. Even Mary (as) herself had made the same oath that she would remain in the service of the temple. So what calamity and affliction had descended so that this oath was broken and she was married? In books of history written by Jewish authors, putting aside other things, it is written that Joseph was coerced into this marriage and the elders from among the Israelites said to him that he would have no choice but to accept this marriage. Now in view of this account, one can see how many objections arise. Firstly, when an oath was made, then why did the mother and grandmother of god break this oath? Secondly, according to the Christians, if polygamy is tantamount to adultery, how do they respond to the fact that Joseph was already married and Mary (as) was his second wife? Is this not an objection which they themselves direct towards their holy virgin? Thirdly, when she had already become pregnant, why was she married during her pregnancy? These are three powerful objections that arise in this context. Let us put other matters aside.
For example, when the angel came bringing glad tidings to Mary (as) and proclaimed that god had descended into her womb, she ought to have loudly announced this fact; she ought to have informed the people to be ready to welcome god as he was soon to be born from her womb. Why was this hidden? As I mentioned, I put aside these objections for the time being, but the three major objections which I have just presented are ones for which the Christians really have no answer. The actual reason, as it appears, is that Mary (as) became pregnant while she was in the temple. She thought that if she told the people that an angel had come to her and given her glad tidings of the birth of a son, they would ridicule her and some would say that she must be dreaming of marriage; while others would say that she was guilty of fornication. But when her belly could no longer be hidden and news began to spread, ultimately everyone became worried. If she had disclosed this fact when the angel had first appeared to her, perhaps such an outcry would not have arisen. However, her view was that if she had disclosed this information in the beginning, people would say that she desires a husband. It is often seen that if an unmarried girl hints even slightly about marriage, these are the sorts of conclusions that people make about her. So Mary (as) was apprehensive and for this reason, she thought it best to remain silent. But after four or five months, when her belly became more conspicuous and this matter could no longer be hidden, there was no other option. The elders of the temple clearly understood that Mary (as) was pregnant and they grew concerned. As it is observed, if the daughter of a noble family becomes pregnant, they quickly and hurriedly have her married to protect their honour. These elders also felt the same apprehension because they were completely oblivious and unaware of the actual matter at hand.
So they did not care at all about the other issues, such as how this marriage would go against the oath that was made or how a second marriage, according to the words of Christ, would show her to be a fornicator, or how it was unlawful to marry off a pregnant lady. Even her dear ones thought that if we continue on the road of silence even now and she is not married to someone, everyone will be disgraced. So the marriage took place. However, these are the numerous objections that arise as a result.
However, a question that calls for contemplation is why the Gospel writers have not shed light on this account with integrity. This is against the demands of honesty. In one instance, a Gospel writer states that Christ has done so many works
that if every one of them were written down, the whole world would not have room to contain them. However, one cannot help but lament the sense of this person, because this one sentence alone has exposed the true nature of the Gospels. It
is these sorts of exaggerations with which the Gospel is replete, because after all, how amusing is it to suggest that the works performed over a span of three years cannot be contained in the world if written down. When these actions were able