Admonition—Misconception in the Nur Afshan
The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 10
The centre of Islamic spiritual wisdom and knowledge is the idea of the existence of God and His being the Master of His will and One without associates. And all the matters of our faith correspond to this concept. But, the centre of philosophical wisdom and knowledge is atheism, and all the investigations of philosophy correspond to that view. There are, however, some among them who make a verbal confession of God Almighty being the Cause of all causes, but they do not believe Him to be the Master of His own will, or to exercise any choice or prerogative over His creation, or to possess any detailed knowledge of the universe. They do not believe that He has any control or power over the universe. Hence, they too, in reality, are the younger brothers of atheists.
It is true that we should accept the truth wherever we find it, but, we should never eat from a dish which is among a number of poisoned dishes, hoping that in all probability it would be free from poison. Surely, everyone argues according to his principles; details of all discussions and investigations are governed by principles. When, therefore, the real creed of philosophers is atheistic or very close to it, how can one hope that there should be anything good in their discussions which necessarily must be governed by their creed? In fact, in the presence of the Word of Almighty God, what need and necessity remains for such discussions, that we should knowingly adopt a dangerous course which has always been leading to destruction? Five times a day, every Muslim recites the prayer in his daily Prayer that:
And, Almighty God has made it clear that the straight path is the path of the Prophets, the path of the Truthful, and the path of the Martyrs. Then we would be extremely foolish not to seek the ways which God has commanded us to seek, and to wander, instead, after the philosophers.
To say, moreover, that we should give rational proof of all our beliefs, with the exactness of mathematics or the preciseness of some of the conclusions of physical sciences because man is gifted with reason and that which is not consistent with reason is not something which is worthy of acceptance, is a dangerous and fatal misconception under which you belabour. That is why you do not keep religion and science apart as two separate entities; rather, you want to give the collection of religious issues and doctrines the character of a science like mathematics or like something even more. But, alas! You do not consider that if religious knowledge and doctrines had been the subject of such obvious proofs as the expression ‘two and two makes four’, then for what reason should we have been promised salvation for accepting and believing them?
I fail to see any relationship between salvation and the fact of one’s accepting and following an obvious phenomenon. If I were to say, ‘I admit that up to this day, the 30th of November 1892, Sayyed Sahib is alive and hale and hearty’; or, if I were to accept the fact that Sunday is followed by Monday; that one-half of twenty is, in fact, ten; should I expect any reward for putting my faith in, and following, these matters of fact? Again, for example, had the existence of angels been like tangible beings; had they been, for instance, believable such that Almighty God could have held them up physically to your view and you could have felt them with your hands and seen them with your eyes; and in similar fashion, the streams of Paradise, the fair maidens and young boys of Paradise had been seen by you while you were sitting in Aligarh; and you had also enjoyed a cup of the pure drink, and had seen Hell before your very eyes; then I cannot understand what merit it would have been to believe in all these things after witnessing such patent and obvious proofs of their existence?
My dear Sayyed, time is fleeting. Quickly realize the important and delicate issue that reward depends upon faith, and faith means acceptance of facts whose existence is possible on the basis of some evidence, but which nevertheless remain concealed and covered, because, by believing in such facts, a person becomes true in the eyes of Almighty God. The reason is that he has accepted the information of His Prophet and Messenger, and realizes His Messenger to be a True Bearer of news. Therefore, he attains salvation by virtue of his sincerity and goodness. It is the duty of every intelligent person to reflect over the deep mystery as to why Almighty God kept matters which man is obliged to have faith in, so secret and hidden that they cannot be solved or explained by the knowledge, wisdom, and philosophy of this world.
For example, in matters pertaining to faith, the foremost fact is that one has to believe in the existence of Almighty God, in His attributes of Knowledge, of His being Wise and Almighty, of His being the Lord of His will, of His being One without a partner, Eternal and Everlasting, Lord of the Throne, and then of His being Omnipresent, but what discovery can the reason of man make regarding these matters except that it may indulge in mere speculations and self-made conjectures? Further, how can such a person who is hungry and thirsty to discover the true reality and who desires realization of the Living God, be satisfied with the one-sided and inadequate argumentation of reason?
Human intellect may indulge in a thousand thoughts, and it may think—ever so deeply as if a hundred-thousand times—over the wisely planned creation of the earth and other heavenly bodies, but it can never dare make the assertion that there is a Creator of this universe; for, such an assertion can only be made if He has been seen or discovered. If, however, human reason does not fall prey to deception and does not go astray, it can only say that there ought to be a Creator of this highly organized, superbly planned, and wisely designed enterprise. Nonetheless, the extent of the difference that separates ‘is’ from ‘ought to be’ is obvious.
What I have said is only by way of mild statement. Otherwise, whoever has taken reason alone as their guide to find the Person of Almighty God, has been carried along by reason to either atheism or to such a weak belief in God Almighty, which is tantamount to disbelief. When the rationalists flounder even at the stage of God-realization, and, make a wrong start, then what can we expect from human reason in other matters pertaining to the unseen?
The answer to the question as to why these matters pertaining to faith have been kept a secret, is the very same as I have just stated that, the mercy, forgiveness, and grace of Almighty God has made these mysteries the path of salvation for man; for, Almighty God who is the Cause of all causes, His angels who are the planners of things under the command of God, the Day of Reckoning which is the Day of the manifestation of supreme power, Heaven, Hell, and the true reality of Prophethood, Messengership, and wahy were concealed from the view of the intellectuals. He gave knowledge of these facts to His unlettered servants, on whom He bestowed the crown of Prophethood and the robe of Messengership, and sent to the world to convey the invitation of faith. Then, everyone who took such a servant of His as the true bearer of news, and believed in them, were called ‘believers’ and they attained salvation, but those who questioned, worshipping reason and logic, became dead, kafir [disbelievers], and losers of both this world and the Hereafter, their abode being Hell.
But here, no one must deceive themselves into believing that this call to faith is based on compulsion, or that it places a burden on man which he is unable to bear, because—as I have already stated in this and in previous writings—these matters pertaining to faith are accompanied by such pointers that are a source of satisfaction for a seeker of truth, which are considered equivalent to arguments and proof by a reasonable man, and which kill and destroy superstition and philosophy. The call again, coming from the mouth of one who has with him heavenly light, blessings, and miracles, and who is supported by extraordinary events, undoubtedly gives to the Faith of a reasonable man a unique brilliance if he only but turns his attention to such blessings.
This is the philosophy of faith which I have presented. The Word of Almighty God teaches us to have faith so that we may deserve salvation. It does not guide us to demand philosophical arguments and proofs of a conclusive character in support of the doctrines that the Prophet, peace be upon him, taught regarding these matters. It does not tell us not to believe in these truths until and unless they are clear to us like the conclusions of mathematics. It is obvious that if a Prophet is to be believed only after his claim has been weighed in the balance of science, it would not be rendering obedience to the Prophet; for, every truth when completely revealed stands self-accepted, whether the same is put forward by a Prophet or by a man who is not a Prophet; it has to be accepted even if it is put forward by a sinner.