Admonition—Misconception in the Nur Afshan
The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 11
The information we accept as true because of our faith in a Prophet or because of a presumption in his truth, must be such that while, rationally, it might be highly probable, the ignorant might still be disposed to believe it to be false, so that, by taking the Prophet to be true and by aligning ourselves on the side of the truth, we might become worthy of the reward that may follow from our goodwill, our refined judgement, our respectful attitude, and our faith. The same is the essence of the teachings of the Noble Qur’an that I have presented. However, the sages and philosophers have not even trodden this path. They have always been careless of faith, and have been searching for knowledge, the certainty of which, they wish, might be made openly manifest to them immediately.
Nevertheless, bear in mind that while God Almighty requires faith in the unseen from the believers, He has not desired that believers be deprived of certainty of knowledge. Rather, faith is a ladder for the acquisition of certainty of knowledge. It is a grave error to search for true knowledge without climbing this ladder, but those who do climb up this ladder most surely see the face of clear insight and satisfying explanations. When a man of faith, being a true believer, accepts the commandments and information from God simply because such commandments and information have been bestowed upon him by God Almighty, proceeded from God and have reached him through a truthful bearer of news, he becomes worthy of attaining the reward of cognition of God. That is why Almighty God has ordained that His servants should first have faith in the unseen and should join the party of the obedient ones, and only then should they be admitted to the stage of cognition when all their spiritual difficulties are resolved. But—alas!—man is hasty and fails to adopt this course.
Almighty God has promised in the Noble Qur’an that if a man only believes the Noble Prophet to be true and if he then tries to discover the true reality of the unseen through spiritual effort, the same would be disclosed to him through visions and ilham [inspiration], and the faith of such an individual would be raised up to the stage of irfan [divine cognition]. The truth of this promise has always been made manifest to the holy ones who seek Almighty God through spiritual effort. In short, what is above the ordinary understanding of believers should not be sought by begging at the door of the school of philosophers or by asking the way from one who has lost it himself. Rather, they are granted the stage of Divine cognition through sincerity and perseverance. That is the stage where all their spiritual difficulties are resolved.
Do not be disheartened by the furious struggle going on in this age between religion and science and the attack upon religion being made by science, wondering what to do. Be sure that in this struggle Islam has no need to sue for peace like a conquered and helpless adversary. Rather, this is the age of Islam’s spiritual sword, just as there has been in the past an age of its temporal might. Bear in mind this prophecy that, in this battle too, the enemy would very soon be vanquished with disgrace and Islam would be triumphant. The new learning of this age may launch attacks ever so severe with ever so new weapons, but they are doomed to suffer defeat.
I say this in a spirit of gratitude of the blessed favour that I have been granted knowledge of the great powers of Islam, on the basis of which I can make the assertion that Islam will not only remain secure from the attacks of modern knowledge, but will, instead, prove the ignorance of all present knowledge which is against it. The Kingdom of Islam has nothing to fear from the invasion of philosophy and science. The days of its grandeur are at hand, and I can clearly see the heavenly Signs of its triumph. This glory is spiritual and the triumph is also spiritual, so that the powers of a false philosophy opposed to it may be broken and reduced to nothing by the Divine power of Islam.
I wonder from whom and where you heard and how you came to believe that the principles put forth by the philosophy and science of this age are dominant over Islam. Thoroughly bear in mind, sir, that philosophy merely possesses an incomplete weapon in the shape of reason, whereas Islam not only wields this weapon in full, but also many other heavenly weapons. Why should Islam then fear the assault? Hence, I do not know to why you are so fearful of this philosophy? Why do you fall at its feet, and why do you struggle to give a far-fetched interpretation to the meaning of the verses of the Holy Qur’an? It is a pity that you have accepted a great hoard of those statements of which to believe even one of those statements makes it incumbent to deny all the tenets of Islam, and it is strange that in spite of denying miracles, denying angels, denying news of the unseen, denying revelation, denying acceptance of prayer, and other denials, you also accept everywhere that the Holy Qur’an is true, the Messenger is true, Islam is true and everything opposed to it is false; then on account of the fusion of these diametrically opposed ideas, your writings have become likened to that bizarre beast that is forced together in such a way that its mouth is of a man, its tail of a monkey, hide of a goat, claws of a wolf, and the tusks of an elephant for show while the truth inside is altogether different.
Again, the extreme extent of pity of it is that like the Shiites, your writings contain examples of taqiyyah—in stating some of your views you make them so ambiguous as not to be the least intelligible. Your words, like the ostrich, are capable of assuming both the forms of a camel as well as a bird.
You may perhaps repeat your assertion, which I have just refuted, and say that writings of this kind were the need of this age. You may be thinking that when the whole of one’s property is at risk in some calamity, one should bear a small loss in order to avoid a greater loss; for, it is better to lose a little than to lose it all. However, all such ideas would result from lack of due deliberation. You should bear in mind that not a dot of the Holy Qur’an is in danger owing to any coordinated attack launched by the philosophies of those in the past or the present. The Holy Qur’an is the kind of stone that will crush whoever it falls upon, and whoever falls upon it shall himself be broken into pieces—so why should you be so anxious to sue for a humiliating peace?
What have you done for Islam outside of accepting many false ideas of contemporary philosophy? You have sought to subordinate the Book whose every letter wields Divine glory to the ideas of the philosophers, and have sued for a humiliating peace. In my opinion, such endeavours on your part cannot defend against the corruption of the Antichrist in this age. Rather, they are a branch of its many branches because from the inside you have opened the gate of the Citadel of Islam for its enemies, helping to tie the hands and feet of the Muslims so that the enemies may comfortably enter this City and plunder it as they please, while the Muslims remain utterly helpless.
I am, however, of the opinion that you have not done so knowingly. Undoubtedly your motives must be honest, for it can be gathered from your writings that there is no reason to doubt your goodwill for Islam. But your goodwill actually has resulted in evil consequences, and it is really the community’s misfortune that the Muslims’ cause has been harmed in a way that no declared mischief-maker could have done, by one who purports to be a reformer. You may perhaps put forward the excuse that this had a purpose, that you published these writings at a time when the evils of Western education were overtaking the world and when the storm of spiritual darkness was at its height; that you supplied this dirty food for those who would wish to have it, lest they might apostatize from Islam—they might eat dirt but they must not abjure Islam!
This assessment of your efforts formed by some people may perhaps be partially true, that if Sayyed Sahib had not supplied this food for such people, then only God knows how they might have degraded themselves like animals. Had this been your motive, even then, in my opinion, it was not free from error, for you cannot prevent anyone’s inherent evil from expressing itself. Allah, glorified be His eminence, says:
Meaning that everyone acts according to his nature.
One should only teach the truth regardless of whether anyone accepts it or not. This is the way of the Prophets, and not that one should destroy one’s own eye upon seeing another blind person. There may be a hidden fear in your mind that the ship of Islam was in great danger amid the storm of this new philosophy, and although it was full of jewels and carried a fine cargo—as it had been overwhelmed by a violent storm—it was expedient at the time of such a sudden calamity when there was no other help, that some of those bundles of jewels and fine cargo be thrown into the sea and that having made the ship a little lighter, human lives might be saved. If this was your motive, it was an unwarranted disobedience, which was none of your business.