Admonition—Misconception in the Nur Afshan

The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 7

In short, it is the way of Allah that sometimes Prophets and saints of the past descend upon the earth in this manner. Elijah’s manifestation in the person of John [the Baptist] was of this kind. It has been disclosed to my humble self that the real truth about the second advent of the Messiah is of this same nature. If there should still be someone who persists in doubt, I am prepared for a mubahalah [prayer duel].

I had earlier refrained from mubahalah because, as I understood, cursing Muslims was impermissible. But now, I have been informed that he who calls another Muslim a kafir [disbeliever] and—despite finding the other’s adherence to the Qiblah [direction of Prayer], affirmation of the Kalimah, and belief in the doctrines of Islam—does not desist from calling him a kafir, is himself outside the pale of Islam. I have, therefore, been commissioned to enter into a mubahalah [prayer duel] with those individuals who are the leaders in the campaign of declaring me a disbeliever and are called mufti, maulawi and muhaddith and who also have wives and children. It would be necessary that in a public gathering, I should first set forth my reasoning in a detailed speech, and refute all their charges and doubts that agitate their minds. If, after this, they do not desist from calling me a kafir, I should enter into a mubahalah with them.

The basis for the mubahalah will not be that they exclude me from their technical appellation of Ahl-e-Sunnah wal Jama‘ah. I do not mind it in the least; for, I find that a ghair muqallid [not a follower of one of the four Imams] who calls himself the Ahl-e-Hadith, addresses the followers of the four Imams as bid‘ati [innovators]or belonging to the Faij-e-A’waj and considers them as contradicting the practice of the holy Companions and as opponents of the earlier elders in the Faith. Similarly, a Hanafi [follower of Imam Abu Hanifah], for example, believes that all those who subscribe to the Oneness of God but do not follow any of the Imams, are faithless and outside the pale of the Sunnah Jama‘at. Why, then, should I be worried of being considered outside the community of the followers of the Sunnah? Nowadays, to call oneself Ahl-e-Sunnah wal Jama‘ah is not considered the exclusive right of any sect; everyone thinks of himself to be the Ahl-e-Sunnah and excludes others from its fold.

This, therefore, is not a weighty dispute in the view of God. But to hastily call anyone kafir for a minor difference in opinion and to declare him to be deserving of everlasting Hell is not, in the view of God, to be taken lightly or as an ordinary offence; it is a grave affair. It is a matter of great surprise that a man who believes in the Kalimah, faces the Qiblah, believes in One God, and accepts Allah and the Messengers (as), and truly loves them, and has faith in the Holy Qur’an, should, merely on account of some minor difference of view, be declared a kafir like the Jews and Christians or even worse than them, and that Miyan Nadhir Husain and Shaikh Batalawi should acquiesce in his being called not only a kafir, but an akfar [the greatest of disbelievers]; that is, deserving of punishment even somewhat greater than everlasting Hell.

The learned know that the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, held views that differed greatly from each other. None of them was above this conflict of views—neither Siddiq [Abu Bakr] nor Faruq [‘Umar], nor any other Companion. Indeed, it is reported that Hadrat Ibn-e-‘Abbas, may Allah be pleased with him, notwithstanding the great eminence all the ulema grant him, differed from the general body of the Companions on fifty questions of theology. This difference had reached such an extent that he regarded some such matters as being lawful which other Companions considered quite unlawful or clearly sinful. Similarly, Hadrat Ayeshah Siddiqah [the Truthful] and Hadrat Mu‘awiyah, may Allah be pleased with them, along with their adherents, were entirely opposed to the other Companions in their views of the nature of the Mi‘raj [Spiritual Ascension] and perception of the person of the Almighty, but no one called anyone kafir. But times have taken such a turn that the maulawis consider it ever so easy to pronounce a Muslim brother as a kafir and deserving of everlasting Hell as if it was nothing more than taking a sip of water. They have declared me a kafir under the influence of this same old habit.

Therefore, I am now commissioned to invite the people, the leaders of the heresy campaign—Nadhir Husain of Delhi and Shaikh Muhammad Husain Batalawi, and their peers who are of the same line of thought—to a mubahalah. In discharging this responsibility, I publish below the mubahalah announcement addressed to these leaders of the heresy hunt.

An Essential

Conclusive Argument for

Sayyed Ahmad Khan C.S.I.

After seeing some of the writings of Sayyed

Ahmad Khan C.S.I., the leader of a new sect of Muslims, particularly his commentary [of the Holy Qur’an], it appears that his

ideas are along the lines of denying that anyone can really be blessed with converse and discourse with Allah. As of now, what I believe to be his view is that he denies the wahy [revelation] which is granted to Prophets through Gabriel, peace be upon him, and comprises of Allah’s power, unveiling of the unseen, and other supernormal phenomena, and which descends purely from the heavens, and is not any natural human faculty.

He seemingly professes faith in the existence of Gabriel, but his Gabriel is not the Gabriel who is unanimously believed by 200 million Muslims of the world. He also believes in the revealed Word of Allah, but not in the Word which is comprised of the light and power of God. Rather, he believes it to be only a natural capacity which, in accordance with its measure, accepts the grace of God—not the wahy which emanates from the spring of the Divine.

The surprising fact is that Sayyed Sahib believes as well that the Noble Qur’an is from God, and from what he has been doing, it appears that he also loves Islam, has concern for Muslims, and is also keen about the material welfare of the progeny of Muslims. It is utterly surprising why, despite all this, he would express senseless and unorthodox opinions against the authoritative dicta of the Noble Qur’an.

The reason seems to be an inadvertent trial in which he has become ensnared. Namely, that before he could devote his thoughts to the teachings of the Noble Qur’an and attain complete awareness of its convincing arguments, he was attracted, at an inauspicious time, towards the books written in this age by European philosophers, who are very close to being atheists. Moreover, it appears that he has also been listening to the ideas of the modern free thinkers who were entrapped by European science and philosophy. Consequently, he had to suffer the same fate which is the lot of those taking a one-sided view of a matter. Having been ignorant of the lofty verities of the Noble Qur’an, he was affected by the magic of the discourses of philosophers. Had he not been supported by the grace of God Almighty and the purity of his heart which is the outcome of that grace, no one can say where his wanderings would have landed him by now.

As a matter of fact, Sayyed Sahib’s honesty of purpose is praiseworthy because he has not forsaken the Holy Qur’an, though inadvertently he has cast himself so far away from its purport, teaching, and guidance as to cause him to suggest interpretations of the Noble Qur’an which were neither within the knowledge of God and His Messenger, nor the Companions, nor Saints, Qutbs, Ghauths, or Abdal and in support of which there was no authority nor any indication in the text.

·

10 of 10 left today