Correspondence with Shaikh Muhammad Husain Batalawi
The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 2
Meaning that, it is a special quality of the believers that, as compared with others, their dreams turn out to be true. You have also just claimed that you, too, believe in the Holy Qur’an. Very well! Let us also test from the perspective of the Noble Qur’an who possesses the sign of a believer.
Both these examinations can be conducted as follows: A gathering can be held at Batala, Lahore, or Amritsar, to be attended by witnesses of the dreams of both parties, and then whoever between the two of us is proven to be
اَصۡدَق [most true] in his dreams on the basis of conclusive and convincing evidence, his opponent shall right there and then be given to wear the ‘medal’ of the epithets ْ کَذَّاب [kadhdhab—arch-liar],
دَجَّال [dajjal—deceiver], ْ کَافِر [kafir—disbeliever], ْ اَکۡفَر [akfar—the greatest of disbelievers], and ْ مَلْعُوْن [mal‘un—the accursed], or whatever names are deemed appropriate. And if you are unable to prove the truthfulness of your past [dreams], I agree and allow you up to six months to publish in a few papers such dreams of yours which may embody news of the unseen. As for myself, I shall not only furnish proof [from my dreams] of the past but shall also, God willing, publish present dreams of mine against yours.
And just as you profess to have faith in the Holy Qur’an and the Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, so do I believe with all my heart and soul in that beloved Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and in that beloved Book, the Noble Qur’an. Now these tests, therefore, would determine who is true and who is false in his claim.
In case I lose according to the test appointed by the Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him and the Noble Qur’an, you would be the truthful one; and I, according to you, would be considered to be a kafir [disbeliever], a dajjal [deceiver], infidel, satan, kadhdhab [the greatest liar], and a fabricator. Moreover, in that case all your mischievous doubts would become true and justified; namely, that I defrauded the people through Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya, cheated them of their money by holding out promises of acceptance of prayers, and lived on ill-gotten wealth. However, if the munificence of God Almighty which accompanies the believers and the truly righteous, establishes my truthfulness, then tell me yourself whether all these epithets would apply to your claimed priestly pretentious stature, or whether there would still be a way of escape left for you?
You have caused me great pain and distress; I continued to exercise patience, but you did not show an iota of fear of that All-Powerful Being who is aware of your very essence. He has informed me by way of a prophecy regarding you and those of your bent of mind, that:
Meaning: ‘I shall humiliate him who designs to humiliate you.’
So rest fully assured that the time is now close at hand when Almighty God will prove that you have lied in making all these accusations. He will send down upon you all those humiliating punishments that slanderers and liars face by way of disgrace and shame. You claim to profess belief in the Holy Qur’an and the Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. Thus, if you are true in this claim of yours, come into the battlefield for a test, so that Almighty God may Himself judge between you and me, and so that he who is a liar and a dajjal may be disgraced.
At this moment, something in support of the truth arises from my heart. I cannot suppress it, for it does not proceed from myself. It is an overwhelming inspiration from my Lord. It is that as you consider me to be a kafir and declare lying to be a special trait of my character, I adjure you in the name of Allah, glorified be His eminence, to immediately come and compete with me in the above-mentioned manner so that it be seen who is proven to be the liar, dajjal, and kafir according to the Noble Qur’an and the sayings of the Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
Following this elucidation, should either one of us hesitate—notwithstanding such intense passion, accusations of disbelief, and denunciations of lying and sinning—and refrain from entering the battlefield, skulking away like a jackal with its tail between its legs, then he merits the following prize:
And, this completes the number up to ten.
Th1819awi’s Statements & Their Responses 339
This is that verdict which God Almighty will deliver Himself; for, it is His promise that a believer will prevail in any case. As, He Himself says:
Meaning: It can never be that the kafir should find a way to overpower the believer. He also says:
Meaning that: O believers! If you become righteous, God Almighty will place a distinction between you and the others. What is that distinction? It is that you will be granted a light which will not at all be found in the others—namely, the light of [Divine] revelation, the light of acceptance of prayer, and the light of miracles of the Chosen Ones. Now, obviously, how can he who has not even abandoned falsehood, be considered a righteous person in the eyes of God Almighty, and how can he perform any marvels? In short, this method will expose the hidden reality of us both and people will see who enters the battlefield and who is proven to be true according to the verse
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[for them is
good news] and the hadith
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[Truest of you in his statements]. There is another thing also with this by means of which the truthful ones can be tested, and which God Almighty Himself brings into existence. Namely, that sometimes a man is involved in such a calamity from which no way of escape or success can be seen by him except that he should tell a lie. It is at such a time that he is tested as to whether there is truth or falsehood in his nature, and whether at such a delicate time his tongue utters the word of truth or whether, fearing for his life, honour, and wealth, he starts uttering falsehood.