Correspondence with Shaikh Muhammad Husain Batalawi

The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 4

I went to Batala and stayed at the residence of Babu Fateh Din, Sub-Postmaster, which was situated close to the Batala courts. The case was in the court of a Hindu judge whose name I no longer recall, but who was lame of one leg. Sultan Ahmad’s lawyer came to me and said, ‘The case is about to be called, what statement are you going to make?’ I said my statement would be in accordance with the facts and the truth, whereupon he said ‘Then there is no need for you to go; I will go myself to withdraw the case.’ So, I ruined that case myself, with my own hands, merely for the sake of truth; I preferred truth to gain God’s pleasure and did not mind the material loss at all.

These last two examples are not without proof either; witnesses to the first are Shaikh Ali Ahmad, Lawyer, Gurdaspur, and Sardar Muhammad Hayat Khan, C.S.I. Moreover, the file must be preserved in the Gurdaspur District records. Witnesses to the second incident are Babu Fateh Din and the lawyer himself, whose name I do not remember at this time, and also the judge whom I have already mentioned and who has now perhaps been transferred to Ludhiana. The suit was brought about seven years ago. Also, I recall that Nabi Bakhsh, Patwari [Village Land Revenue Accountant] at Batala, was also a witness to what happened in this case.

Now, Hadrat Shaikh Sahib! If you also have any instance of a trial of this degree of seriousness, in which you had seen your life, honour, and property at risk in the event that you had spoken the truth, yet you stuck to the truth caring not for your property or life, I would beseech you in the name of Allah to come forward with that incident along with the full proof thereof. It is, however, my belief that most of the mullahs or maulawis of this age are just talk; they are ready to sell their faith for a single penny; for, our Noble Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, had declared the maulawis of this latter age as the worst of creation.

Moreover, the late Nawwab Siddiq Hasan Khan, whom even you believe to be a Mujaddid [Reformer], has acknowledged in Hijajul-Kiramah that that latter age is this very period of time. Thus, to acknowledge the piety and righteousness of such maulawis without proof would mean falsifying the saying of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. Therefore, let us have instances of your experience, but if you fail to present any, it will be established that you only possess a claim to piety, but no claim is worthy of acceptance without evaluation.

The state of your inner being is known only to God Almighty as to whether you ever soiled yourself with the filth of lies and fabrication, or it might be known to those who are acquainted with your affairs. The man who emerges as truthful at a time of trial and does not abandon the truth earns the seal of truthfulness. If you possess this seal, come forward and show it. Otherwise, fear God Almighty lest He may expose your flaws.

What harm can your nonsensical malicious talk do to me? You write that I have been working as a legal agent and have been involved with litigation. You should desist from making such fabrications. You know well that my humble self has never been involved in acting on behalf of others in courts. But yes, it is true that in my father’s time, most of the cases in connection with the family were conducted through lawyers and sometimes, I too, had to go personally to the courts. But if you insinuate that those cases might be false, you only make an accusation filled with satanic stench. Are cases of all plaintiffs false? Do they all always tell lies?

O perverse-natured shaikh! Only Allah knows the state in which you shall die. Does a man who brings an action in court to protect or secure a due right always have to tell a lie? Certainly not. On the contrary, the man upon whom God Almighty has conferred the capability of truth and who loves truthfulness is by nature averse to telling a lie, and if some worldly benefit is dependent only upon telling a lie, he forgoes it. It is regrettable, however, that a man who himself eats filth considers all people to be eaters of filth. The people given to falsehood always say that without falsehood recourse to a court of law is impossible. So, this statement of his would be true only under the circumstance when a party to a suit would never be prepared to bear any loss to himself and wants to win each and every case by all possible means. But why should a man who always gives precedence to truthfulness do so? Why would someone, who is prepared to suffer loss, place any reliance on falsehood?

Now, let it also be clear that it is true that in my late father’s time I had to resort to the courts of law to get satisfaction of the family’s legal rights in connection with the business of our estate. But my father’s legal actions were either for the arrears of rent, or for compensation for cutting down a tree without permission, or for recovering the proprietary dues from village headmen. These were not complicated cases because of the administrative arrangement whereby the testimony of the Village Accountant—viz. the Patwari—often sufficed for the decision. Falsehood had no place in such suits, for they were decided on the evidence of official records. And because land was not properly taken care of in those days, there was always loss incurred in agriculture and many times one had to take a loss oneself when dealing with cultivators having little income by treating them favourably.

Knowledgeable people are aware that a landlord who is honest can treat his tenants with the highest dictates of honesty and virtue. There is no inherent conflict between landlord-ism and goodness. Notwithstanding this, no one can prove that after my father’s death I was concerned with any case except the one in connection with the letter which I have already mentioned. If I had not been temperamentally averse to litigation, I would have freely indulged in it throughout the fifteen years that have elapsed between my father’s demise and now.

Again, it must also be noted that only innately evil people would compare these lawsuits with the litigation of the moneylenders. I cannot conceal the fact that for many generations, we have been a family of landowners; we are even now, and a landowner does need to go to a court of law sometimes, but this cannot be anything objectionable in the eyes of a fair-minded person. Just look up the ahadith: the man who is to come in the Latter Days—in the days when the Quraish would be deprived of temporal authority, when the followers of Muhammad, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, would be disunited and in a state of anxiety—would belong to the landed class, and God Almighty has informed me that I am that person.

Ahadith of the Prophet clearly state that in the Latter Days a defender of the Faith and the Muslim community would be raised; and, he would be a landlord [zamindar]. The Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, says in this context that every Muslim should accept him and help him.

Now, just reflect upon this. Being a landlord is a proof of my truth; it is not something to be criticized. And the Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, has commanded that he be accepted, not rejected.

·

10 of 10 left today